rpvee

brash_stryker said:

Looking good!

A few ideas. I agree that the saber coming out of the sleeve should be cut. Gives that much more impact to the saber igniting in the darkness.

Have Palps get up slower. Cut from him starting to get up to showing the Jedi again with their sabers drawn but have the lights flicker accompanied by the force rumble sound effect. Maybe insert a puzzled closeup shot of Mace's face during the flicker before cutting back to Palps getting up all the way as the lights dim completely.

I think it would be perfect then. I think it's important to get a reaction shot of sorts from the Jedi to the lights flickering/dimming.

 

How I would do it:

Are you threatening me, master jedi?

Not yet.

Palps gets up and the lights flicker as he does so

Cut to the shot of the Jedi with their sabers drawn. Lights flicker more along with inceasingly loud force Rumble.

Closeup of Mace's face in the flickering light.

Shot of Palps after the omitted sleeve closeup. It's treason then. (lights flicker and dim to nothing) Palpatine's saber ignites from the darkness.

THIS.  The only things I can add would be be perhaps having Palpatine keep the lights down when he charges, so that we only hear the Jedi's screams, then when only Mace is left and they're going into the hallway, have the lights come back up to show that Mace is now alone.  Plus having the lights come back up as quick as they do in the current preview make the dimming pointless.  They have to have a purpose, which would be having Palpatine killing the Jedi in the dark (plus only seeing the blades in all of that would be cool).

ALSO, you MUST get rid of that small remnant of the Force scream that's still in there!

What about that thud I mentioned when one of the troopers gets hit in the new clip?

EyeShotFirst said:

She kissed him, but they weren't passionate kisses. Looked like a friend kiss to me. So Luke was in the friend zone.

Do you grab your friends' heads and give them a good three-second long kiss often?

And even if they didn't know, that doesn't make it better for the viewer.  Anyways, I don't think I'm gonna win this one.

Another note: If the Empire destroys the power generator, shouldn't the lights in the base go out?

vaderios said:

rpvee said:

But it's still a kiss!  A very long and deep kiss! O_o

 

Also, just noticed that after 3P0 identifies the probe droid's code as possibly being an Imperial one, in the next shot he is suddenly facing away from the group again as if he never spoke.  Is this being fixed?

Well Leia kisses Luke again after the rescue from Bespin. Is just a kiss not hentai :P

 

I think the shot doesnt need fixing because 3po said what he had to say and returned to his duty. In fact he could be annoying if what he just said wouldnt be useful ;)

 

-Angel

Any Luke/Leia kisses are awkward when seen as part of the whole trilogy.  They make otherwise good scenes awkward at least a little bit.

And I'm not saying that 3P0's line should be removed, I'm suggesting his position in the shot after he talks be changed to match the previous shot.

vaderios said:

They hadn't have sex so its ok to remain in the edit ;)

 

-Angel

But it's still a kiss!  A very long and deep kiss! O_o

Also, just noticed that after 3P0 identifies the probe droid's code as possibly being an Imperial one, in the next shot he is suddenly facing away from the group again as if he never spoke.  Is this being fixed?

I know this is a pretty damn daring suggestion that most likely won't get done and probably will meet a lot of criticism, BUT... I am currently watching ESB on Spike and I can't help but wish Adywan would cleverly edit out the infamous Luke and Leia kiss.  Unless he plans to remove the sibling twist in Jedi, it really does just ruin the whole scene because any fan knows just WHAT is going on there.

vaderios said:

Silent darker? yup i think it works that way too.

No its not a trap

-Angel

That last one made me lol and would make a wonderful widescreen wallpaper. :D

He could always have text and audio commentary, right?

Ady, the clip is WONDERFUL!  I can't get over the new Cloud City, it looks beyond professional!  Just a couple things:

1. After 3P0 tells R2 to access the computer terminal, he then says "R2, hurry".  Could this be changed to just "Hurry"?  There's no need for him to say "R2" again.

2. When one of the stormtroopers is shot outside right by the doorway, I hear a slight thud when he's hit.  Why would there by a thud?

Sluggo said:

adywan said:

Happy Anniversary ESB

Here is the new clip as promised. Youtube links will be added later

New Clip 720p

New Clip Comparison

Total noob question here, but what will play a .ts file?

VLC Media Player... it plays EVERYTHING, I love it!

vaderios said:

bobgarcia74 said:

Maybe some lightening? Just alittle hint of it?

I was thinking of playing with the lights in the room, have them flicker for a second. But not sure how well that would come across.

They dont get that they f*cked up with the wrong mexican.. i mean Sith

-Angel

So maybe have the whole room like that, and then when he charges at the Jedi, light the whole place up to distract a bit?

Also, is it possible to remove that "Sith Scream" completely?  That little remainder of it makes the whole thing feel like a rough cut, when it really isn't.

Do we know what part of the film the clip will be from?

Happy birthday, Ady! :D

Perhaps they could gradually appear more and more with each shot of Anakin right after Obi-Wan is crushed?

That silent head twitch by Grievous before his laugh looks a bit odd.  And I vote for white.

Oldfan said:

Bingowings said:

So true which is why I would really love to see Leia line "Star Destroyer" removed.

In a film that is so visually intelligent (even after Lucas fiddled with it) having Leia do the Princess Obvious thing sticks out like a sore thumb in a way it never would in the PT.

I don't mind Leia saying that. Although it is obvious to us, the audience, that there is a Star Destroyer, in the heat of the moment, it seems quite natural that Leia, or anybody for that matter, would shout out "Star Destroyer" if you suddenly saw one. If you were driving along and suddenly a bus was coming right for you, your passenger is quite likely to shout out "LOOK OUT - A BUS!", even though it would be quite obvious. It's just a knee-jerk reaction.

 

The delivery of the line is so... bland, though.

Ady, question about your view of the project when you watch what's done so far, or even ANH: R.  When I edit videos that people seem to like, I personally cannot see what's so great because as opposed to seeing the whole forest of the video, I see each individual tree that is each cut and what-not, so that as the creator, I can't appreciate it as much as the viewers can.  Are you the same way with the Revisiteds?

bobgarcia74 said:

After a few people stating that they thought the shot was to plain (and I agree). I added in the Destroyer that Obi took off from originaly.

It would make sence that he tries to head back there considering he's in a remote system with a short ranged ship maybe thinking only his clones rebelled.

He would try to use the radio to dock, but like he says, hes lost all frequencies. Bail cuts in and tell him this madness is happening all over. So we're left to assume that Obi bolts out of there asap. How's that sound?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LufSYsn2jtw

 

Thanks to the people who mentioned it. 8)

In my opinion, it only makes the shot look a lot more still.  Earlier I hadn't noticed that as the ship moves, the stars don't go out of view.  Now, since the Destroyer doesn't get larger as we get closer, I noticed the stars, too, and thus the entire shot looks still.

bobgarcia74 said:

Ok this parts pretty much done. Just need the glass layer and its all set.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzuPNMWKHIc

Time to start putting some pressure on the Death Star issue now. I shall meditate on this.

 

Nice!  I like it.

I used to think that Palpatine and Vader were part of some strange humanoid species because both had strange, white pasty skin.  This was when I was 4-6, of course.

Ripplin said:

I bet we could get this guy in ESB:R pretty cheap:

That's pretty creative, really. :p

I speak no French, but I'm gonna assume that the image's host website is happilly telling us we can't see the image, so we've been given a happy face instead.  I don't believe we could use a happy face in Revisited.

Though posting that over Vader during the father scene would be humorous. lol

Heyyyyy you cut the banter!!!!! :D

bobgarcia74 said:

Thank you rpvee for your detailed review. Awsome work. Helping me a ton.

Not a problem!

I'll watch it Friday and just list all my little nitpicks as I go along, haha. That OK?

Hasn't Lucas and Lucasfilm encouraged what's done here?  If the copyright holders don't mind, I don't see a problem.