Watched R1 for the second time last night. My rankings remains the same-
Star Wars/The Empire Strikes Back
Return of the Jedi
Rogue One
I have a strong feeling from watching the trailer this might be remix of The Empire Strikes Back!
if that is the case then that will be a huge let down!
Early critic comments (not actual review just comments) indicate this not being the case, the general vibe of the article containing snippets of comments from people saw the premiere on RT is "very good, not what you expect. "
Not that that really means anything, but I’m going to be hopeful.
HYPE! i think a lot true fans will be disappointed!
we need a good director to do star wars series, I know 4 can make it really good!
^^ Cool. I like that.
Watched this for the second time last night. I feel about the same about it as I did leaving the theater back in February. It’s cool and fun. First act should be cut down and simplified. Darth Vader lava planet scene is funny for the wrong reasons and should have been left out. Third act is great.
Should Leia have become Queen at the end of the OT (and the ST)?
No. Queen of what? No.
I would also like to make it clear that the Bereadeus sock was not me.
Good point. the next person who doesn’t clear their name is probably the culprit.
must . . . resist . . . temptation . . . to . . . sigh . . .
You failed. And, as usual, we don’t now what you’re sighing about.
Well, tomorrow the big question gets answered: will Republican voters abandon all pretense of even the smallest shred of morality in their quest for political power? Or, more cynically, if you’re a Republican politician, can being really racist make up for being a child molester?
I vote “of course” on both, unfortunately.
^ Gonna have to try that. Sounds awfully sweet though…
the internet is unfortunately full of assholes, so it wouldn’t surprise me at all that if the table was public for editing, someone would intentionally sabotage it just for fun. 😕
Bah. Good point.
Seems like a good idea! So, this table would be public- where anybody with a little free time could contribute when they can?
WARNING!
SPOL’RS!
Luke throws his old saber. But then Rey goes n gets it.
Chewie don’t like the porgs. But then he does.
Luke don’t wanna train Rey. But the he does.
Seems riveting.
If someone wants, we could just have a thread with absolutely no limits on spoilers and make it very clear what you will find in the thread. Could be fun for people who stumbled upon some leaks already and want to theorize.
Good idea. We could call it: Episode VIII Discussion *SPOILER THREAD*
it is.
What are you looking forward to?
Actually, I guess I’m interested in this new Predator thing and maybe the Cloverfield one too.
Cool. I got no idea about it’s PT/EU origins, I just think it balances the shot very well.
I’ve had a relatively strict no-spoiler regimen since the real trailer came out, so I guess that explains the confusion.
Nah. Your confusion is justified no matter what in this situation.
I’m going to live out the rest of the year as the SW Universe’s greatest failure.
I don’t even understand this.
He apparently thinks that Disney has destroyed Luke’s character.
I don’t know how you could make that judgement based on 45 seconds of dialog-less film.
There’s much more than that out there now.
I’m not saying Disney’s ruined anything, but there’s a bunch of places to get confirmed info now.
There were thirteen posts here just yesterday!
But all the recent posts are "Just saw some spoilers, but I won’t share em here!"
It’s weird. I have no other source for this kinda thing and this is a handy place to read about it. But now it’s “Oh I don’t wanna drop this massive spoiler in the SPOILER THREAD.”
but… spoiler thread.
Why would you click this thread if you were avoiding spoilers?
Why’s everybody going hush-hush in the spoiler thread?
^ this.
Bingo, I’m glad to hear you may be getting help with getting out of your living situation.
I really hope things work out for you soon.
I wish there was more I could do or say.
I assumed that Luke wouldn’t acknowledge the ghosts or be aware of them, and they would just be watching him from a distance.
Hmm. I just might prefer that.
Danfun left just because he didn’t like the new forum software.
He was about as fun to interact with as that fact would lead you to believe.
True. Most misleading user name ever.