I do echo Brash's comments about Trooperman's workprint. Even in workprint form, that cut is phenomenal. If he can successfully polish it, it will be amazing.
Have yet to see an edit of AOTC that I liked honestly. Ep. 3? At the moment I still go to Spence's ROTS... But I'm hearing good things about Kerr's too... In fact, his is on youtube. =)
It's no problem. I guess people just simply have no opinion on this specific clip. I believe I've made a firm decision about it.... Don't need to sit on this one for too long.
Meanwhile I'm chopping the battle of Geonosis to pieces and working on CC tests.
Still working on this.
I guess I'll have to settle for no feedback for this clip. Moving along....
Well I guess I'm thinking in terms of payoff. If I went this route, how could a proper payoff be achieved?
Thanks. I'd like to get some feedback from people. Maybe someone on here may have an epiphany based on the scene.
greenpenguino said:
How about something like this to make it more OTish? You know, using the OT sfx?
I really liked that! I also liked how Obi-Wan walked away before Anakin caught on fire... Kinda makes him look a tad less cruel of a Jedi.
ben_danger said:
oh yeah, also just food for thought, the star wars soundboards have the lightsaber sfx, and these contain the first few seconds of some key duels, such as mustafar. i have just popped the video and we can glimpse what a music-less duel may look like.
That's pretty cool..
SpenceEdit said:
Is this still on? :)
It's very much still on. =) Just to prove I've been working.... Here is a clip I was playing with.... This is a rough test and still needs some audio issues ironed out. And I will also say this will probably change to just simply the removal of Sith from the scene. I was toying with the idea of giving Qui-Gon more meat, but I don't think it works, and there really isn't a payoff.
ben_danger said:
vaderios said:
Tik Tak :)
Preview time:
Credit to the anonymous contributor :)
-Angel
hehe. funnily enough i was playing around and did this yesterday.
Very cool, indeed.
thejediknighthusezni said:
Hey,
I just wanted to say I think this approach is great. Flashbacks open up a whole wide range of possibilities. I'm looking forward to the edits.
Best of luck!
Thanks so much. I'm just glad I finally found an approach that I'm happy with. So far anyway.
I didn't have a problem with 23... Are you still having issues? I'd try it again.
TV's Frink said:
SilverKey said:
Yep, worth thinking American Hominid. To take your idea a little further: why not use the prequels as flashbacks and integrate them into the OT?
Is it radical if someone is working on it? ;-)
http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Star-Wars-Redemption-Trilogy-New-clips/topic/10028/
Thank ya kind sir!
THAT. EXCITES. ME.
I do like beating people to the punch. For example.
Yes.
Yes, I'm still working on this. =)
I would love to see the Ronto butt in every crucial shot. Maybe when Qui Gon gets stabbed by Maul.
"That's what she said."
Crap, too early! Ugh!
Oooo... a Photo negative edit! ;)
Good man, that Ady. =)
Nice work... As another film brain, I appreciated this.
How's it coming Spence? =)
WAHOO! Maybe I'll be watch ROTJ by saturday or sunday!