logo Sign In

juicerino

User Group
Members
Join date
28-Nov-2005
Last activity
21-Jun-2006
Posts
67

Post History

Post
#163030
Topic
Why do they go into exile?
Time
i always imagined that uncle owen was not related at all, but just a random guy that obi-wan chose to keep luke, telling him what the deal was with luke just so they'd know what they were dealing with, and basically having him do his best to keep luke in the rural life. but then when obi-wan realizes lukes potential and the certain fate of his adoptive parents, he tells him a fable about his unlce and his father being at odds about involvement in wars, helping luke to side with his adventurous nature. but thats just what i imagined, and it seemed cool.
Post
#162298
Topic
Why do they go into exile?
Time
my guess on the matter, apart from everything that happens in the prequels, is that there was simply no way of mounting an attack on the new empire, even in its infancy. it would seem that the clone wars were so destructive and crushing that yoda and obi-wan may have been lucky to be alive at all. Even Tarkin says in ANH to vader, "you are all thats left." and they are both suprised to see that obi-wan is alive. For yoda, it is clear that he is getting very old, and with his strenghth in the force he may have seen years ago that he was not the person to defeat vader. For obi-wan, his purpose in living on tatoine seems to be for the sole purpose of protecting luke, at a distance, which he succesfully does. in this way we can see that even if obi-wan had been strong enough to attack the emperor and vader, the small possibilty of losing the fight meant that there would be literally no hope for the jedi and the rebellion as there would be no one to train luke and the jedi would be truly extinct. Instead he stays near luke and guides the events as far as he can, and it works out pretty well. i think with all the talk in ESB of seeing the future enough to know whether or not to take a course of action, yoda and obi-wan couldve seen that an attack by them just wouldnt have worked out, and that should wait for the son of skywalker. even the emperor knows what a great threat he would be from the start.
Post
#161918
Topic
Time to grow up.
Time
i dont think arguing is the problem. its arguing that results in people losing their nerve that is the problem. understandably, these movies inspire a great amount of emotion, being good for those of similar opinion and all the more bad for those of differing opinion. i would imagine the webmaster has read some of the altercations here and seen that they're not entirely instigated by that one person we all know, but by others too, and thats why he made this thread. ill certainly do my best to keep awayf from any personal attacks, and hope that the webmaster is able to identify those who simply argue and disagree for the sake of it.
Post
#161582
Topic
hardcore haters only
Time
everything in the prequels is completely bastardized, watered-down, flitered-out, cut and paste, hackneyed, dumbed down, cop out film making. even some of the music. the movies are truly an insult to loyal fans of what Star Wars once was. taking elements of the old trilogy, mutilating them, and using them to achive pseudo continuity and try to hook newcomers on the two trilogies as one whole is but one small example of why people have such hatred for him.
Post
#160710
Topic
THE Most Awesome Scene in Star Wars
Time
Originally posted by: Adamwankenobi
Originally posted by: oojason
Originally posted by: Yoda Is Your Father
I agree. It has to be Yoda raising the X-Wing from the swamp. That scene really captures the mystical element of Star Wars which has been all but destroyed by the SEs and prequels.


Definately m8 - I do wonder over time if scenes from the Prequels will be thought of in the same way?


Yes. Some scenes will be.

Ex. The opening battle of ROTS.



yeah, you mean where anakin pilots that ship to safety with the later half of the ship completely blown off, so that anyone on the ship would have been evaporated upon re-entry, then half and hour of boring fighting that no one cares about? yeah, that'll stand the test of time.
Post
#160448
Topic
Found this quote from Lucas about the Fans from May '05
Time
Originally posted by: Adamwankenobi
TPM and AOTC?!? Fanatical?!? OK, I don't think I would go that far! I like TPM and AOTC, but not like that. What was he thinking? No one is fanatical about TPM and AOTC!


sure they are dude. they're called 10 year old boys. it has become more and more clear. the original star wars appealed to many different age groups, with boys from 13 to 21 being a great portion. these new films are geared for younger kids, and that is a great inherent flaw. its easy for little kids to just love the ships and effects and not even worry about the lack in all other departments, where as 18 year old dudes will pick apart a movie and make sure they know why they like it. that is why you fail George Lucas.