logo Sign In

generalfrevious

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
23-May-2006
Last activity
29-Aug-2017
Posts
2,022

Post History

Post
#259503
Topic
Left-Handed Explanation for accents in the PT
Time
Back to the PT, In TPM there are three alien species that have accents, and only Huttese is spoken as the foreign language within the movie. By AOTC, there is some Geonosian, and by ROTS there is little or no foreign language. So there arent enogh species in the entire PT to justify using (presumably ethnic) accents.

It is interesting to note that Han never speaks aforeign language, but only interprets it.
Post
#259467
Topic
Left-Handed Explanation for accents in the PT
Time
Now this is not to be an official theory; I am not a blind PT fanatic (evident if you have read some of my posts), but want to suggest something.

I think the reason that the aliens have accents in the PT is because the Galactic Republic was more politically cohesive than the Empire, because there was a tighter economic system that reqires a universal language for interplanetary trade, diplomacy, and communication. 35 years later, the EMpire is not capable of maintaining economic stability due to the Rebel Alliance and the Galactic civil war, so there has been a regress into a more localized cultural system in which all social activities are not on a galactic scale.

Or the Occam's razor explanation was to dumb down the film into racist stereotypes by using accents, and make it more marketable to children.
Post
#259462
Topic
Hey guys, Remember when Star wars had writing like this?
Time
The writing went south during the PT because Lucas simple started to take more and more unilateral control in keeping a cohesive film saga. What then happened was that instead fo a stand-alone film or a six hour film trilogy, you have an unwatchable 14-hour film, riddled with as much contradictory statements as there are CGI effects. This is what happens when marketing and narcissism replace actual filmmaking. (And the reason why film is practically dead in the present day)
Post
#257743
Topic
Where do I go from here as a SW fan?
Time
For me , it´s just the situation "It´s bad". Everything can get worse


Oh yeah, that's absolutely right; what's happening to SW is like Michaelangelo burning the sistine chapel because he was originally dissatisfied with his work on the ceiling. Even Uwe Boll isn't forcing us resort to the Black Market to get a decent copy of a movie so we dont have to watch it on some primitive TV set to enjoy it.It will get worse
Post
#257408
Topic
Where do I go from here as a SW fan?
Time
It seems when SW finally get what they wish, it gets horribly distorted in ways no one could ever imagine. And to think a worn out 25-year old VHS tape is 100 times better in quality than the DVD release for the OOT makes you suicidal. To think that this will be the last time ever Lucasfilm will release the Originals in such bad quality is also a fatal blow for all film preservationists everywhere. Believe me, Lucas will keep these films out of public domain for centuries to come; the only solution is to have a DVD recorder in 1977,1980, and 1983 because no fan would have imagined this tragedy of astronomical porortions.
Post
#257186
Topic
Darth Vader's Paternity Test Results
Time
That question is the fault of Lucas redoing the OOT, in which Vader only knows about Luke 90 minutes before the end of ESB.
If you want an answer, according to Lucas revisionist PT story, the name skywalker is a dead giveaway for Vader. Its like if Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky had a child named Bill Clinton jr. and he lived Arkansas with Roger Clinton for the first 20 years of his life.