logo Sign In

g00b

User Group
Members
Join date
8-Feb-2022
Last activity
30-Jun-2025
Posts
479

Post History

Post
#1654210
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

zebweasel said:

Doesn’t removing the episode Droids in Distress cause a problem with continuity?

I think it’s removal actually helps continuity. That episode makes Kallus an irredeemable monster who ordered a genocide… One that Rebels only dealt with by making him “lie” about that. We still see that Zeb really HATES Kallus and comments that he shouldn’t have the weapon he has (in other episodes) so I actually don’t think we lose anything important believe it or not!

That’s the episode where Zeb finds out agent Kallus has a bo-rifle because he was part of the Lasat massacre.

While this is true, it’s also explored later on in season 2 when they’re both trapped on Geonisis’ moon so it’s not really needed here. In my edit, Zeb obviously hates Kallus, and you can see Kallus has a similar weapon. Its talked about that there aren’t many Lasats. So as the show goes on you get a sense that something horrible happened but don’t have to have it spelled out directly. So again, I don’t think we lose any substance, in fact by cutting this episode I think it improves world building and story telling. 😃

It’s also the episode where Kanan meets Bail Organa, who he later points out meeting before in the season one finale.

That’s right! But seeing them meet Bail isn’t really important. Just like seeing the Rebels meet Lando. They have an history of operation before they get Ezra AND between episodes. So although I cut this meeting, its not important for the story to know HOW they met.

Also, while I know Secret Cargo isn’t the most important episode, it would be cool to still keep now that it has a nice connection to Andor. Plus it shows the different rebel cells finally coming together to form the rebel alliance.

Its connections to Andor are a hindrance now 😂 so the overall story of canon is improved by this episodes exclusion. Why would Mon Mothman not go back with Andor… And instead PUT HERSELF IN A DANGEROUS SITUATION that ALMOST doesn’t go well… Absurd continuity that wasn’t well explained at all 😂 mostly because Rebels just wanted a Mon Mothman cameo episode. While it does show Rebels cells coming together, we do see that all across season 3 and the very beginning of season 4 so I don’t think anything is lost by its exclusion.

Legends of Lasat is also a fan favorite that’s now gone.

Quite frankly, I think the episode sucks. I think it gives Zeb awful characterisation and this episode combined with the epilogue is completely ignored by future projects (Mandoverse). So while there are aspects to enjoy about it. Its a side adventure that has so far never connected to the overall story in anyway.

Maybe you could include a lot of these cut episodes as extra bonus episodes the same way EddieDean has extra episodes in his Clone Wars Refocused edit?

There is the potential I do this, however my main focus at the moment is the core story of the show, not it’s filler episodes 😃

Post
#1653424
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

My current cut of the final film is 2:01:53 (excluding credits and opening logos). I’m VERY happy with how it’s coming together. Still a while off releasing it but I thought I’d share that I’ve got my first complete cut of the film and that it’s got the perfect runtime (over 2 hours)! hahaha

I’ve still got to adjust the shots for the last 40 or so minutes to the new aspect ratio, upscale, review and do the subtitles 😃

Post
#1652434
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

I’m currently mixing in extra lines from both star wars Canon and the old EU into the world between worlds. If you have any suggestions, please give them to me! I’m not sure how many will make it in, but I want to really add to the soundscape here. I also think the World Between Worlds is a great place to join both EU and Canon so all star wars fans can feel validated with what they love! 😄

Post
#1652111
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

aGreatHumanBeing said:

Forgive me if this have been discussed before, but i just say everything that pops into my mind 😃

That’s great! All feedback is useful even if it doesn’t seem like it at first. 😃

Would it be better to have the (Rebels) episode number in the title?
Something like:

"Rebels

^ If I went with a number, I’d put it here, like Rebels Episode 2… I’ll think about it but that also means going back and redoing the crawl for my first movie as well (which I don’t have objections to doing).

Episode X.X
SECRET OF THE TEMPLE"

(I don’t know if it will fit here, bu I like episodes in Star Wars media!)

Should the Emperor, Pryce and Thrawn be capitalized like KANAN JARRUS?

No… well they can be but it’s not always names that get capitalised it’s just names that can be capitalised 😃

The end of the second paragraph seem a bit clunky to me, but then again - I’m not a native English-user, so perhaps it is my language skills that is lacking. There will be better words to use than in the following example, but maybe something like this?

"the Rebellion struggles
to maintain the cohesion to
retake their beloved home world
Lothal, that is relentlessly
shattered by the Empire .

I feel the slight clunk too… although I’m not sure it’s what your version corrects. Some key things I need to differentiate is that the Rebels on Lothal are split from the Rebels on Yavin now (Which is why I’ve said the Lothal Rebellion) BUT I think I do like your sentence structure better for the last part “that is relentlessly shattered by the Empire.”

Perhaps something like this:

The unrest on Lothal continues.
Despite the destruction of the
Imperial TIE Defender factory,
The Emperor secretly continues
his sinister plans.

Reeling from the death of their
close friend and rebel leader,
Jedi Knight KANAN JARRUS,
the Lothal Rebellion struggles
to maintain the cohesion to
retake their home planet which
is relentlessly being ravaged
by the Empire.

Governor Arihnda Pryce has
seized this unique opportunity
to celebrate with a mandated
parade, in the hopes this will
offset the judgment of Imperial
Grand Admiral Thrawn…

Post
#1652018
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

Looking for some help with my next Title crawl. Here the current movie name and my first attempt. I’d love whatever feedback you’ve got for me! 😄

SECRET OF THE TEMPLE

The unrest on Lothal continues.
Despite the destruction of the
Empire’s TIE Defender factory,
the Emperor secretly continues
his sinister plans.

Reeling from the death of their
close friend and leader, the
Jedi Knight KANAN JARRUS,
the Lothal Rebellion struggles
to maintain the cohesion to
retake their beloved home world
from the Empire, who continues
to destroy it.

Governor Arihnda Pryce has
seized this unique opportunity
to celebrate with a mandated
parade, in the hopes this will
offset the judgment of Imperial
Grand Admiral Thrawn…

To get some better feedback, I’ve uploaded the crawl and opening scenes of the movie here

And yes… I have spotted the spelling errors in the crawl… The look of the shots and the music isn’t finalised yet. I just thought it’d be good to see the opening scenes after the crawl 😃

Post
#1651871
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

I’ll be making a start to the final movie (and last 2 episodes) of season 4 soon. I’ve finally worked out how I want the movie to start. I’ve got some work cut out for me as the only footage I’ve got isn’t usable for the start to a star wars movie so I’m going to have to make it myself. My plan is to have a space pan down onto a new shot of lothal and then mask out the opening shot of show with the star destroyers flying into the cameras view (which I had previously cut but it is a good visual). I’ll then look around for some establishing shots to take us from the planet into either the capital city with the Empire organising the parade or I to the Rebels hideout with Hera morning Kanan still.

I’m excited to get the ball rolling on this last ark as once it’s done, all that I need to do for the series is minor polish!!!

Post
#1651828
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

RELEASED S01E06 - Broadcast of Hope V4.3

Downloads

  • 4K recolor: available
  • 1080p recolor: available
  • 1080p: available
  • Subtitles: available

Changes

  • ADD 00:12.00 Extended Introduction text timing.
  • Fixed Audio
  • Amped up the wind SFX in the opening sequence. Everyone’s hair was windy but the SFX for it was a little too weak.
  • Added wildlife SFX
  • Updated subtitle aesthetics.
Post
#1651674
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

RELEASED S01E05 - Trial of the Jedi V4.4

Downloads

  • 4K recolor: available
  • 1080p recolor: available
  • 1080p: available
  • Subtitles: available

Changes

  • ADD 00:12.00 Extended Introduction text timing.
  • Refined the Introduction text
  • Fixed Introduction text font (the last 2 sentences were wrong for some reason).
  • Added wildlife SFX to the episode.
  • ADD 02:02 (06:51:02 - 06:53:04) - This cut just wasn’t working, it makes sense that you can see the door close. I originally just didn’t like Ezra’s extra cartoony reaction and scream which still remain minimised and cut.
  • ADD 04:18 (06:53:03 - 06:57:21) - Added this scene back in for visual continuity between shots.
  • Updated subtitle aesthetics.
Post
#1651475
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

honestabe said:

Are you changing the introduction and audio for every episode of your edit?

Yup! hahaha

More exactly, the audio issues are season 1 through to season 2. I don’t have any audio issues in s3 and s4 (bc I started these from scratch when I revisited them for V4).

Now that I’ve got something that works for an extended time for the introduction text, I think it needs to be across every episode! It’s not too much work to do, it’s just a time consuming process but honestly, that works with my current time access to editing as I can set it up, go parent, come back and upload.

I hope you have plans to complete your edit while you are still alive. Sarcasm aside, the constant improvements are much appreciated.

I’m still young and healthy, so I’ve got time 😉. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, I’m determined to make this edit the best I possibly can! That being said, I think we’re nearing the finish line. From these last episodes rereleased… I don’t see anything I can improve and I haven’t seen any errors to fix! 😃

Post
#1651470
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

RELEASED S01E04 - Empire Day V4.5

Downloads

  • 4K recolor: available
  • 1080p recolor: available
  • 1080p: available
  • Subtitles: available

Changes

  • ADD 00:12.00 Extended Introduction text timing.
  • Rewrote introduction text.
  • Fixed audio
  • Rebalanced audio volume of added dubs and alien SFX. (some lines were too loud before).
  • Rebalanced audio volume for wildlife SFX (it was too loud before).
Post
#1651469
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

Peonthegrate said:

g00b said:

Peonthegrate said:

Maybe I’m crazy, and I wonder if anyone else has noticed. But with headphones on it almost sounds like the right side is louder than the left if that makes sense. I’m wonder if anyone else has noticed anything like that or if I’m just insane. Only tested with Episode 1 as of now.

100% definitely zero audio issues with the newest S01E01 release. Could you check it on your end to see if it’s any better for you?

Yep, seems fixed now from what I can tell, Thanks!

Awesome! Great to hear! 😄

Post
#1651095
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

RELEASED S01E03 - Old Masters V4.5

Downloads

  • 4K recolor: available
  • 1080p recolor: available
  • 1080p: available
  • Subtitles: available

Changes

  • ADD 00:12.00 Extended Introduction text timing.
  • Fixed the audio for good for real this time!
  • Changed the introduction text.
  • Cleaned up and better blended the additional stormtrooper dialogue into the environment.
Post
#1650930
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

Peonthegrate said:

Maybe I’m crazy, and I wonder if anyone else has noticed. But with headphones on it almost sounds like the right side is louder than the left if that makes sense. I’m wonder if anyone else has noticed anything like that or if I’m just insane. Only tested with Episode 1 as of now.

100% definitely zero audio issues with the newest S01E01 release. Could you check it on your end to see if it’s any better for you?

Post
#1650929
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

RELEASED S01E01 - Spark of Rebellion V4.12

Downloads

  • 4K recolor: available
  • 1080p recolor: available
  • 1080p: available
  • Subtitles: available

Changes

  • ADD 00:12.00 Extended Introduction text timing.
  • Updated the Rodian voice line with a better source (instead of EA Battlefront 2 where he’s clearly warning for an ATST, I’ve used clips from SWToR) It’s also lip synced much better then it was prior.
  • Replaced “All troopers focus your fire!” with a new line generated by Elevenlabs so it doesn’t sound like Kallus is cut off. (Thanks AcBagel!)
  • Fixed Audio… same issue as last time. Looks like my “fixed audio” for S1 and the first 4 eps of Season 2 have this same issue… I know how to fix it atleast! 😄
Post
#1650729
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

RELEASED S01E02 - Familial Bonding V4.6

Downloads

  • 4K recolor: available
  • 1080p recolor: available
  • 1080p: available
  • Subtitles: available

Changes

  • ADD 00:12.00 Extended Introduction text timing.
  • Rewrote the introduction text for this episode.
  • Changed audio source for the Rodian Dialogue. It’s lip sync’d much better, sounds more authentic AND I had more control over the dialogue this way. This means I could insert the Rodian Vendors laugh back in! Which is much nicer.
  • Fixed the wildlife sfx (it was too loud)
  • Fixed Audio (It had rendered all the 5.1 tracks as one track across all 6 channels??? No idea what happened here).’
  • Updated Subtitles to be more aesthetically pleasing
Post
#1650482
Topic
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series
Time

Peonthegrate said:

Maybe I’m crazy, and I wonder if anyone else has noticed. But with headphones on it almost sounds like the right side is louder than the left if that makes sense. I’m wonder if anyone else has noticed anything like that or if I’m just insane. Only tested with Episode 1 as of now.

This is a problem later in the series (for S02E05 - S02E10 Only) I’ve examined the audio output visually to make sure and listened to the episode and it’s not doing this to me! Could be your video player or headphones themselves?

Post
#1650270
Topic
The Clone Wars: Refocused [COMPLETE]
Time

Evermorph said:

This is definitely interesting. I’ve seen some film edits of this and that’s great but to redo them as episodes must take a lot of work. How long are they? Some show recuts I’ve seen some other show recuts bump them up to 40-50 minutes. Also what’s the status on subtitles? I saw season two got them.

I’m still working away on the subs! They take some time as I’m pedantic about their timing and translate the alien languages too haha.

I don’t like to give completion timelines for them as I tackle them while I’m still working on other projects (i.e., they’re not CURRENTLY my top priority).

The episodes times for the edit vary as the arks lengths. So sometimes it’ll be 20, other times 40 and in some cases 60 and longer!