logo Sign In

g-force

User Group
Members
Join date
24-Sep-2004
Last activity
16-Jul-2020
Posts
662

Post History

Post
#309873
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time
Originally posted by: Oldschooljedi
Ok, now it works. I just finished another encoding.

Did you download your needed .dll's here:

http://avisynth.org.ru/

??


Whew! Great! How does it look compared to the original?

avisynth.org.ru is where I got all my DePan stuff.

So I've been trying different techniques and settings to get the back and forth wobble out when R2 rocks back and forth (like around frames 26950-27000). Everying I do destroys the improvements in stabilization that I've made in the other parts of the film though. So I think I'm going to have to identify all the problem scenes and switch back to the unstabilized version for those clips. I've tried MVDePan, DePanEstimate, and playing around with all the variables in those as well as my script. Any other ideas?

-G
Post
#309777
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time
Originally posted by: Oldschooljedi
Oops, now I have this error again and need a little help. I did upload a little clip of my encodings:

Link

Could you take a look at it?



I'll have to wait until I get home from work to look at the clip, but a couple ideas come to mind.
1. try resizing to NTSC resolution before the script (just so everything is the same) and then run my script.
2. I know that there are a few different revisions of the DePan and DePanEstimate tools out there. Make sure they are the most recent ones from: http://avisynth.org.ru/depan/depan.html
This sounds very much like what would happen if there was a bug in the dymax not being set to 0 in DePanEstimate.

-G
Post
#309682
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time
Originally posted by: Oldschooljedi
g-force,

Did you use the NTSC or the PAL DVD as source?
Was your script modified for your encodings or did you use the script as posted above?

I'm doing some testencodings at the moment but it looks different to your encoding.

I used the NTSC version. The script is exactly as above, except that I resized it to non-anamorphic at the end, added the original to the bottom of the screen, resized and showed the frame number. How does yours look different?

if you add this to the bottom of the script, you will have exactly what I used to encode.


tv=Lanczos4Resize(720,360) #see what it will really look like on TV
StackVertical(tv,orig)
addborders(120,3,120,3)
Lanczos4Resize(720,480)
ShowFrameNumber

trim(500,-350)+trim(4290,-200)+trim(10900,-300)+trim(26790,-130)+trim(70800,-200)+trim(133550,-60)


If your test encodings look too "tall", that's because the script is streched for anamorphic.

-G

Post
#309622
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time
Originally posted by: eros
Are these scripts good for the whole trilogy or just star wars

Not sure yet. I hope they will work with all of them with some minor tweaking.

Originally posted by: Arnie.d
Do you know what "align=true" does in the crop function? I read a frame can sometimes be placed unaligned in memory after cropping. But I don't known what it means if a frame is unaligned and exactly when it happens. Is it just to improve speed?


I stole that one from Moth3r. I think you're right though.

So I have encoded a one minute clip that I now need to upload to Rapidshare or something. I'll update soon. BTW, the script is going to need some more tweaking, there are a couple scenes where R2 is rocking back and forth that throw a wrench in the algorithm.

-G
Post
#309515
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time
Originally posted by: pittrek
Screenshots would be nice


I know! I just didn't think screenshots would do justice to the wobble, so I really want to post some clips. I started to encode some last night, but the script runs too slow due to the fact that in my last script I'm doing a lot of stuff inside the doubled frame size of eedi(2). I have re-arranged the script so it works must faster now. I will update the posted script after work and start encoding.

-G
Post
#309478
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time

#######################################################################################
#################### GOUT Filter By G-force V.15.00 USE ONLY ON ANH ###################
#######################################################################################

########## setup
episode = 4
Mpeg2Source("C:\Documents and Settings\Owner\Desktop\AviSynth Scripts\VTS_03_1.d2v") # <-----Set path

########## cut off some of the black bars for faster processing (but keep mod 16)
Crop(0,96,0,-96,align=true)

########## black level/gamma, hue
Levels(10,1.08,255,0,255).Tweak(hue=-3)

########## de-ring
pm = last
h4 = pm.RemoveGrain(4,-1)
Median1(pm,  MT_Convolution(horizontal="1",vertical="  0 0 0 1 0 .1 -.1"  ,chroma="copy first"),h4,Chroma="copy first")
Median1(last,MT_Convolution(horizontal="1",vertical="0 0 0 0 1 0 0 .1 -.1",chroma="copy first"),h4,Chroma="copy first")
Contra(last,pm)

########## global motion stabilization
orig = last
temp = orig.TemporalSoften(3,255,255,25,2)
int  = Interleave(temp.Repair(orig),orig)
DePan(int,data=DePanEstimate(int,trust=0,dxmax=1,dymax=0),offset=-1)
SelectEvery(2,0)

episode==5 ? last.Trim(0,92103)++orig.Trim(92104,93601)++last.Trim(93602,0) : last

########## local motion stabilization/degrain stage
source  = last
sigma   = 5
fft     = source.FFT3dFilter(sigma=sigma,sigma2=sigma*.75,sigma3=sigma*.5,sigma4=sigma*.25)

fft.Clense(grey=true)
filt    = Contra(last.Repair(fft,2,-1),last).MergeChroma(source)

idx1    = filt.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1)
bw_vec1 = MAnalyse(idx1,isb=true, delta=1,overlap=4,plevel=0,dct=1)
fw_vec1 = MAnalyse(idx1,isb=false,delta=1,overlap=4,plevel=0,dct=1)

idx2    = source.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1,levels=1,chroma=false)
pcorr   = source.MDegrain1(idx2,bw_vec1,fw_vec1,thSAD=800,thSCD1=150,thSCD2=75,plane=0)
corr1   = Median1(source,pcorr,filt,chroma="copy first")

idx3    = corr1.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1,levels=1,chroma=false)
corr1.MDegrain1(idx3,bw_vec1,fw_vec1,thSAD=400,thSCD1=150,thSCD2=75,plane=0)

Median1(corr1,last,filt,chroma="copy first")

Contra(last,source)

########## restore stars
prest = last
prest.MT_Binarize(threshold=20,upper=true,chroma="copy first").MT_Expand(chroma="copy first")
MT_Merge(prest,source,last,chroma="copy first")

########## additional "Lucasfilm" and "Along time ago..." stabilization
prest.Trim(0,265)++prest.Trim(266,687).TemporalSoften(3,255,255,25,2)++last.Trim(688,0)

########## anti-alias
NNEDI2(dh=true, field=0)
NNEDI2(dh=false,field=1)

########## resize to 16x9 AR, remove sides, add borders
Spline16Resize(728,388).Crop(8,10,-4,-14,align=true).AddBorders(2,58,2,58)

########## subtitle
episode==4 ? ANH(last) : episode==6 ? ROTJ(last) : last

#######################################################################################
Function ANH(clip input)
{input

f     = "Franklin Gothic Medium Cond"
f_col = $EEEEEE
f_wid = 9
f_pos = 464
f_siz = 36

Subtitle ("Going somewhere, Solo?",
\ -1,f_pos,70663,70698,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("It’s too late. You should have paid him when you had the chance.",
\ -1,f_pos,70825,70931,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Jabba’s put a price on your head so large...",
\ -1,f_pos,70940,71005,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("...every bounty hunter in the galaxy will be looking for you.",
\ -1,f_pos,71014,71088,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I’m lucky I found you first.",
\ -1,f_pos,71098,71137,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("If you give it to me, I might forget I found you.",
\ -1,f_pos,71203,71282,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Jabba’s through with you.",
\ -1,f_pos,71365,71406,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("He has no time for smugglers...",
\ -1,f_pos,71435,71489,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("...who drop their shipments at the first sign of an Imperial cruiser.",
\ -1,f_pos,71498,71595,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("You can tell that to Jabba. He may only take your ship.",
\ -1,f_pos,71656,71748,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("That’s the idea.",
\ -1,f_pos,71806,71833,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I’ve been looking forward to this for a long time.",
\ -1,f_pos,71843,71931,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)

Return(last)
}

#######################################################################################
Function Contra(clip denoised, clip orig)
{# re-write of Didée's contra sharpening routine from TemporalDegrain.avs

rg12d = MT_MakeDiff(denoised,denoised.RemoveGrain(12,-1))
rg12d.Repair(MT_MakeDiff(orig,denoised),9,-1).MT_LUTxy(rg12d,"x 128 - abs y 128 - abs < x y ?")

denoised.MT_AddDiff(last,chroma="copy first")

Return(last)
}

#######################################################################################
Function Median1(clip input_1, clip input_2, clip input_3, string "chroma")
{# median of 3 clips from Helpers.avs by G-force

chroma = Default(chroma,"process") #default is "process". Alternates: "copy first" or "copy second"

Interleave(input_1,input_2,input_3)
chroma == "process" ? Clense(reduceflicker=false) : Clense(reduceflicker=false,grey=true)
SelectEvery(3,1)

chroma == "copy first" ? last.MergeChroma(input_1) : chroma == "copy second" ? last.MergeChroma(input_2) : last

Return(last)
}

#######################################################################################
########################## GOUT Filter By G-force V.15.01 ESB #########################
#######################################################################################

########## setup
Mpeg2Source("C:\Documents and Settings\Owner\Desktop\AviSynth Scripts\VTS_ESB.d2v") # <-----Set path

########## cut off some of the black bars for faster processing (but keep mod 16)
Crop(0,96,0,-96,align=true)

########## black level/gamma, hue
Levels(10,1.08,255,0,255).Tweak(hue=-3)

########## de-ring
drng = last.MT_Convolution(horizontal="1",vertical="-.085 .165 -.185 1 -.185 .165 -.085",chroma="copy first")
drng.MT_Convolution(horizontal="1",vertical="-.1 1 -.1",chroma="copy first")
drng.Trim(0,687)++last.Trim(688,2801)++drng.Trim(2802,0)

########## global motion stabilization
orig = last
temp = orig.TemporalSoften(3,255,255,25,2)
int  = Interleave(temp.Repair(orig),orig)
DePan(int,data=DePanEstimate(int,trust=0,dxmax=1,dymax=0),offset=-1)
SelectEvery(2,0)

last.Trim(0,92103)++orig.Trim(92104,93601)++last.Trim(93602,0)

########## local motion stabilization/degrain stage
source  = last
fft     = source.FFT3dFilter(sigma=5,plane=4)

fft.Clense()
filt    = Contra(last.Repair(fft),last)

idx1    = filt.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1)
bw_vec1 = MAnalyse(idx1,isb=true, delta=1,overlap=4,plevel=0,dct=1)
fw_vec1 = MAnalyse(idx1,isb=false,delta=1,overlap=4,plevel=0,dct=1)

idx2    = source.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1,levels=1)
pcorr   = source.MDegrain1(idx2,bw_vec1,fw_vec1,thSAD=800,thSCD1=150,thSCD2=75)
corr1   = Median1(source,pcorr,filt,chroma="process")

idx3    = corr1.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1,levels=1)
corr1.MDegrain1(idx3,bw_vec1,fw_vec1,thSAD=400,thSCD1=150,thSCD2=75)

Median1(corr1,last,filt,chroma="process")

Contra(last,source)

########## restore stars
prest = last
prest.MT_Binarize(threshold=20,upper=true,chroma="copy first").MT_Expand(chroma="copy first")
MT_Merge(prest,source,last,chroma="copy first")

########## additional "Lucasfilm" and "Along time ago..." stabilization
prest.Trim(0,265)++prest.Trim(266,687).TemporalSoften(3,255,255,25,2)++last.Trim(688,0)

########## anti-alias
NNEDI2(dh=true, field=0)
NNEDI2(dh=false,field=1)

########## resize to 16x9 AR, remove sides, add borders
Spline16Resize(728,388).Crop(8,14,-6,-10,align=true).AddBorders(3,58,3,58)

 


#######################################################################################
Function Contra(clip denoised, clip orig)
{# re-write of Didée's contra sharpening routine from TemporalDegrain.avs

MT_MakeDiff(denoised,denoised.RemoveGrain(12,-1)).Repair(MT_MakeDiff(orig,denoised),9,-1)

denoised.MT_AddDiff(last,chroma="copy first")

Return(last)
}

#######################################################################################
Function Median1(clip input_1, clip input_2, clip input_3, string "chroma")
{# median of 3 clips from Helpers.avs by G-force

chroma = Default(chroma,"process") #default is "process". Alternates: "copy first" or "copy second"

Interleave(input_1,input_2,input_3)
chroma == "process" ? Clense(reduceflicker=false) : Clense(reduceflicker=false,grey=true)
SelectEvery(3,1)

chroma == "copy first" ? last.MergeChroma(input_1) : chroma == "copy second" ? last.MergeChroma(input_2) : last

Return(last)

#######################################################################################
################### GOUT Filter By G-force V.15.03 PAL ROTJ to NTSC ###################
#######################################################################################

########## setup
Mpeg2Source("C:\Users\Garica\Desktop\VTS_01_1.d2v") # <-----Set path

########## change framereate (PAL to NTSC)
AssumeFPS(24000,1001)

########## cut off some of the black bars for faster processing (but keep mod 16)
Crop(0,112,0,-112,align=true).AddBorders(8,0,8,0)

########## black level/gamma, hue
Levels(10,1.08,255,0,255).Tweak(hue=-3)

########## global motion stabilization
orig = last
temp = orig.TemporalSoften(3,255,255,25,2)
int  = Interleave(temp.Repair(orig),orig)
DePan(int,data=DePanEstimate(int,trust=0,dxmax=1,dymax=0),offset=-1)
SelectEvery(2,0)

last.Trim(0,92103)++orig.Trim(92104,93601)++last.Trim(93602,0)

########## local motion stabilization/degrain stage
source  = last
fft     = source.FFT3dFilter(sigma=5,plane=4)

fft.Clense()
filt    = Contra(last.Repair(fft),last)

idx1    = filt.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1)
bw_vec1 = MAnalyse(idx1,isb=true, delta=1,overlap=4,plevel=0,dct=1)
fw_vec1 = MAnalyse(idx1,isb=false,delta=1,overlap=4,plevel=0,dct=1)

idx2    = source.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1,levels=1)
pcorr   = source.MDegrain1(idx2,bw_vec1,fw_vec1,thSAD=800,thSCD1=150,thSCD2=75)
corr1   = Median1(source,pcorr,filt,chroma="process")

idx3    = corr1.MSuper(pel=2,sharp=1,levels=1)
corr1.MDegrain1(idx3,bw_vec1,fw_vec1,thSAD=400,thSCD1=150,thSCD2=75)

Median1(corr1,last,filt,chroma="process")

Contra(last,source)

########## restore stars
prest = last
prest.MT_Binarize(threshold=20,upper=true,chroma="copy first").MT_Expand(chroma="copy first")
MT_Merge(prest,source,last,chroma="copy first")

########## additional "Lucasfilm" and "Along time ago..." stabilization
prest.Trim(0,265)++prest.Trim(266,687).TemporalSoften(3,255,255,25,2)++last.Trim(688,0)

########## anti-alias
NNEDI2(dh=true, field=0)
NNEDI2(dh=false,field=1)

########## resize to 16x9 AR, remove sides, add borders
Spline16Resize(744,396).Crop(18,16,-12,-16,align=true).AddBorders(3,58,3,58)

########## subtitle
f     = "Franklin Gothic Medium Cond"
f_col = $EEEEEE
f_wid = 9
f_pos = 465
f_siz = 36

Subtitle ("There will be no bargain.",
\ -1,f_pos,14382,14476,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I will not give up my favorite decoration.",
\ -1,f_pos,14538,14706,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I like Captain Solo where he is.",
\ -1,f_pos,14741,14824,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I have come for the bounty on this Wookiee.",
\ -1,f_pos,20524,20626,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("At last we have the mighty Chewbacca.",
\ -1,f_pos,20774,20886,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I want fifty thousand. No less.",
\ -1,f_pos,21502,21553,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("This bounty hunter is my kind of scum...",
\ -1,f_pos,22554,22663,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("...fearless and inventive.",
\ -1,f_pos,22685,22753,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("It's too late for that, Solo.",
\ -1,f_pos,28765,28856,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("You may have been a good smuggler...",
\ -1,f_pos,28857,28972,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("...but now you're Bantha fodder.",
\ -1,f_pos,28973,29058,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Take him away.",
\ -1,f_pos,29224,29273,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Bring her to me.",
\ -1,f_pos,29449,29503,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I'm sure.",
\ -1,f_pos,29750,29796,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I told you not to admit him.",
\ -1,f_pos,33466,33568,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("He must be allowed to speak.",
\ -1,f_pos,33615,33684,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("You weak-minded fool!",
\ -1,f_pos,33703,33774,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("He's using an old Jedi mind trick.",
\ -1,f_pos,33821,33927,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Your mind powers will not work on me, boy.",
\ -1,f_pos,34154,34280,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("There will be no bargain, young Jedi.",
\ -1,f_pos,34685,34795,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("I shall enjoy watching you die.",
\ -1,f_pos,34824,34910,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Bring me Solo and the Wookiee.",
\ -1,f_pos,39727,39816,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("They will all suffer for this outrage.",
\ -1,f_pos,39817,39920,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Soon you will learn to appreciate me.",
\ -1,f_pos,43151,43304,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Move him into position.",
\ -1,f_pos,45220,45288,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)
Subtitle ("Put him in.",
\ -1,f_pos,45866,45922,f,f_siz,f_col,font_width=f_wid)


#######################################################################################
Function Contra(clip denoised, clip orig)
{# re-write of Didée's contra sharpening routine from TemporalDegrain.avs

MT_MakeDiff(denoised,denoised.RemoveGrain(12,-1)).Repair(MT_MakeDiff(orig,denoised),9,-1)

denoised.MT_AddDiff(last,chroma="copy first")

Return(last)
}

#######################################################################################
Function Median1(clip input_1, clip input_2, clip input_3, string "chroma")
{# median of 3 clips from Helpers.avs by G-force

chroma = Default(chroma,"process") #default is "process". Alternates: "copy first" or "copy second"

Interleave(input_1,input_2,input_3)
chroma == "process" ? Clense(reduceflicker=false) : Clense(reduceflicker=false,grey=true)
SelectEvery(3,1)

chroma == "copy first" ? last.MergeChroma(input_1) : chroma == "copy second" ? last.MergeChroma(input_2) : last

Return(last)
}

Post
#309418
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time
Originally posted by: Arnie.d
I don't have the files on my PC right now so I can't try your script.

By the image shake do you mean the left-right shake of the entire frame or the movement that sometimes occurs very locally within a frame? Also, do you plan to use it for certain scenes only or do you use it on the entire film? Did you notice any bad side effect?


This takes care of the left-right shake of the entire frame. Maybe some subsequent filtering will help with the local shake/distortion. The only bad effect is that it can't fix scenes with static backgrounds and large moving foregrounds (think close-up of Vader's head moving back and forth with the walls of the Blockade Runner in the corner). Most scenes however look much more stable now. It really is a drastic improvement! I plan to use it in the entire film but maybe shut it off for a select few scenes. Once I get a chance to view the entire film I will make a decision on that.

-G

Post
#309383
Topic
GOUT image stabilization - Released
Time

I’ve been working on trying to get rid of the image shake on the GOUT for quite a while, and I finally got something that works quite well. Here is my Avisynth script so far:

removed preliminary script. see below for updates.

 

I don’t do anything in the y direction because there isn’t that much shake in that direction, and because I don’t want to throw away any more lines due to the borders moving up and down. When I get around to adding borders and resizing for anamorphic, I would also like to add a small amount on the sides for TVs with overscan.

I also plan on adding this to the great work that Arnie.d and Moth3r have already done with anti-aliasing, anamorphic, and subtitles…

I plan on putting up some comparision clips soon, but those of you that can run this script, please let me know what you think!

-G

Post
#308444
Topic
Info: GOUT Anti-aliasing
Time
So, I've been looking for ways to get rid of some jaggies that I was seeing on some frames of the droid purchase scene, and on a whim I tried Arnie.d's EEDI2().TurnRight().EEDI2().TurnLeft(). It turns out that there are some jaggies that are helped by this method of turning the image and doing it again! Here are some comparison shots of EEDI2() (Top image) and EEDI2().TurnRight().EEDI2().TurnLeft() (bottom image)
http://www.wackychimp.com/uploads/EEDI2.jpg
http://www.wackychimp.com/uploads/EEDI2LR.jpg

I've also been playing around with the black level in order to remove some of the garbage mattes. This line added early in the script seems to work well and is just enough to get rid of the worst of the mattes against a black background.

Levels(8, 1, 255, 0, 255) #check with this scene: trim(133550, -60)

also, some DeSpot stuff I've been working on that gets rid of some offensive junk:

DeSpot(sign=1) #sign=1 removes only black spots and keeps fast motion stars
DeSpot(mscene=0) #mscene=0 removes spots only in very static scenes

I'm going to bed now, I'll post more pics if anyone is interested.

-G
Post
#299238
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Originally posted by: eros


And you are?? I was talking to the organ grinder, not the monkey.

Adywan, I'm refering to the cockpit shot side on to luke before he fires at the tie. The stars and planet shouldn't move out of shot as the camera is fixed on Luke, not panning. Just an observation. OK


Ouch! Please feel free to PM people if your comments are not open for discussion.

The stars and planets would move out of shot if Luke was banking left.

-Monkey with Physics degree
Post
#299162
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Originally posted by: Erikstormtrooper
Adywan,
the far off ships seem to recede too slowly, considering that they're going in the opposite direction.

It appears correct to me, seeing as the ships get smaller and smaller.

Originally posted by: NormanS
looks a bit odd. I think it's because it follows the camera as it pans to the right (it's like sticked in the center)


I think it looks right, since the camera is centered on the tie fighter at that point, the explosion would stay centered as well.

Originally posted by: eros
movement between the DS and Yavin? As the planet seems to move with the DS making it look a bit 2 dimensional.


This also looks correct, the DS moves much more quickly than Yavin.

-G
Post
#204892
Topic
***The &quot;Darth Editous&quot; Episode V DVD Info and Feedback Thread*** - a work in progress
Time
Originally posted by: Brimley
I can't stress enough how much I abhore the new Wampa footage. I loved how little you saw of the creature in the original cut of the film, and the newer shots 1) take away the mystery and 2) dillute the tension significantly.

Please please please, cut out these new shots. They are horrid!



agreed!

-G
Post
#204452
Topic
***The &quot;Darth Editous&quot; Episode IV DVD Info and Feedback Thread*** - a partially &quot;de-specialed&quot; DVD
Time
DE,

was watching ESB last weekend, and remembered some of my qualms with it (in addition to what you have already listed)

1. Fireball when the Probe droid crashes into the planet is either too small or moves too fast to look like the probe.
2. I can't stand how different the new Wampa looks from the old one. I would suggest removing the new Wampa all together.
3. The sound of Luke shutting off his lightsaber right after the Wampa scene, but the lightsaber stays on.
4. When the fallen AT-AT gets blown up, the chunks falling into the snow and the way the snow reacts makes it look lika a minature. Maybe slow the falling chunks part down?

just some suggestions.

-G
Post
#171813
Topic
***The &quot;Darth Editous&quot; Episode IV DVD Info and Feedback Thread*** - a partially &quot;de-specialed&quot; DVD
Time
Here is my wish list:

13. I've painted the reappearing red R2 unit green to fix the continuity error.
*I really wish R5 wasn't there at all.

14. There's a bad cut in the music (it completely drops out for a fraction of a second) when we see the Sandpeople mounting their Bantha - fixed.
*still noticable, but better

15. I've edited out the wall hanging/cloak thing behind Luke to fix a continuity error (but in a weird way - more on that later).
*That is weird. It seems to disappear when luke stands up, as if he knocked it down, but then it re-appears in a latter shot.

23. Han fires first!
*wish this was more like the OOT, but it works well just the way it is, and is a huge improvement.

30. Moff Tarkin's line "...then name the system!" has been graphic equalized to mask the poor audio quality.
*Could still be better. I only say this because before the DVDs came out someone posted this as a MP3 clip that I thought I would try to EQ. I think I got it perfect, but yours is still not quite as good as it could be.

42. The line "I had it all under control until you led us down here!" was of particularly bad quality, so I've replaced it with the same line from the SE LD.
*Now Chewie's bark during this line sounds funny

Also, put in newer fanfare during 20th century fox logo at beginning so it doesn't sound so crappy.