evansj1983

I love that idea. It’s something I thought should have been the case all along. I hope you can pull it off

It is an odd scene. I actually tried something different when I put together my own personal edit of the movie (a kind of mash-up of various edits I like). I kept the scene, but tried to replace the “NOOOOO!” with some Qui-Gon’s dialogue from the Clone Wars episode ‘Voices.’

It’s the scene where Yoda is in bacta tank and you hear Qui-Gon saying “No… This is not the way.” I placed this over the obnoxious “NOOO!” but I was not at all talented enough to make it work. All I was capable of was reducing the main audio and trying to insert the Clone Wars line, but the background music was just wrong. Plus, the calling out of Anakin’s name was a little too dramatic for the line that followed. I ended up scrapping it and keeping the line as it was but decided on cutting the scene on Mace Windu’s face as the Imperial March is in the background.

But I still I have a weird feeling that with a decent editor it could work. You get some authentic Liam Neeson… you get Qui-Gon seemingly expressing his disappointment in the path that Anakin is taking…