doubleofive

packersfan said:

I know suggestions are closed.  I recall that you are making the TIE Fighters blue.  What is your reasoning behind that?  I never liked the blue TIEs...but if you have a good explanation and reason for it, then I can get on board with it.

TV's Frink said:

You did a podcast on Gargoyles?

http://www.trek.fm/standard-orbit/61

There's my podcast on this whole thing.

Um, DrCrow, I'm pretty sure the things you just flipped out about are because my friend took pictures of his TV in a dark room.

However:



These are direct from my just purchased discs. Check out not only the tint (that you can't tell if you're watching the movie without comparing them like this), but there's a lens flare on the 2D version. Very interesting stuff. I'm hoping that James Gunn will comment on this on Twitter.

Thanks for the heads up Harmy, I was able to play my 3D disc just using my external Blu-ray drive and the cheap Blu-ray software I bought for my Mac. Fantastic.

Hal 9000 said:

Almost any PT edit will rattle its continuity with EU material. A radical edit like Adywan's all the moreso. 

For my own prequel edits, I need to occasionally remember slight differences when I read novels. In Luceno's "Dark Lord," Bail Organa's wife takes care of Leia, since Padme had died in childbirth. Because my edit of Ep3 has her survive to raise Padme on Alderaan, that doesn't mean I can't enjoy the book. It doesn't align perfectly with my edit, but I have no problem acknowledging this as I read and enjoy it. (Just hope future episodic films don't directly reference Padme's death on the operating table.)

TV's Frink said:

Mainly for 005:

We should get back on-topic as soon as sandwichly possible.

jedimasterobiwan said:

adywan is there a way to edit the cartoons to fit at all with you edit if not the original series at least the cgi one? you see i'm a big fan of the clone wars.

Harmy said:

So, I just bought the Czech BD 3D set and can confirm, that the 2D disc has the tint too :-(

Luckily, I watch most of my BDs through my computer, so I can watch the 3D disc in 2D or adjust the colors of the 2D BD on the run.

So there's an open matte version of DoFP floating around out there?

dvdmike said:

In my looking for Skyfall, I found this

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/103899

jedimasterobiwan said:

when he's done with the prequels edit can someone maybe figure out a way to get both clone wars series to fit with the edit or adjust the edit to fit with both the clone wars series?

It seems to be the same thing with the variable aspect MI Ghost Protocol. Lost to time....

Ryan McAvoy said:

doubleofive said:

So have we compared the UK 3D with the UK 2D? I think we may have some kind of international screw-up.

I don't have a 3D setup so no. That disc from my GOTG set is just a handy place to rest my coffee cup ;-)

I'm hoping another European country has a better 2D transfer but I'd only find that out by randomly ordering them and comparing.

So have we compared the UK 3D with the UK 2D? I think we may have some kind of international screw-up.

Gaffer is still posting Dragon Ball videos and updating his Facebook, so he's fine. Just irregular.

I wonder if anyone preserved that....

People are worried about if they throw out the current script that they won't get a new one in time to start shooting for a 2016 release. I'm pretty sure that every writer in Hollywood has a Trek spec script, and if they didn't, they've written one since Friday.

My co-host and I talk about our thoughts on this whole business in next week's podcast. I'll post a link when it's up.

dvdmike said:

I was under the impression it was open matte on Netflix.

My mistake, it was 1.85:1 on Sky in the UK

Yeah, I was going back and forth on the open matte stuff. The point of the list theoretically is to chart the different releases and what the director prefers. The asterisks are a work in progress as well.

Yeah, Star Trek 6 is weird:





This is a comparison of one of my friend's 70mm film cells with the same frame on the DVD and the Blu-ray.

http://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10_7PPKaPMITk7pchLEU3GHTadeVdiINZXPmtYuocyA0/edit?usp=sharing

Started a Google doc with some friends of the various aspect ratios / dimensions of films and what the director's preferred AR/dimension is.

If anyone has any suggestions/proof of director's preference, let me know.

Boba won't be a clone and it will be established that the Fett helmets have voice modulators built in.

As for ESBR, Boba will have the original theatrical voice.

So I'm alone in my like of the trailer? It looks like stupid fun, like Terminator 3. I hated Salvation. Ugh.

If you don't like interlacing it is.

I assume TMBTM has a usable filter, due to the extra dialog in The War Of The Stars. Maybe he can help you out.

Hal 9000 said:

^Or that could replace the "Nooooo."

Ryan McAvoy said:

Currently editing Star Trek:TMP