Seven years is plenty of time for a first-time viewer to become a devoted fan, so yes. Also interesting that it’s the one version never to be released on DVD.
I don’t like it because it meant there couldn’t be more than three prequels.
I don’t think Anakin should have become a ghost at the end. Vader was confused when Obi-Wan became a ghost, so how could Vader possibly become a ghost himself?
Sometimes I call him “Sheev” to be funny.
As for the OT Lucas wanted to wait til the PT was complete before releasing them on DVD. The only reason he caved in 2004 was studio pressure.
I wonder when the OT would have been released on DVD without studio pressure.
I wonder if, before the sale to Disney, Lucas preferred that the Star Wars movies be released to theaters every seven years and never be released on VHS/DVD, but studio pressure got in the way with both formats.
Was the HD format war still a thing maybe? Just guessing they didn’t to create multiple releases.
No HD formats existed until 2006, and HD TVs were rare in 2000.
There were VHS releases of TPM and the OT in 2000, so why no DVD releases at the time?
Highly doubtful you’ll ever see lightsiders wielding red sabers in the new canon given the new canon’s explanation for how they’re created.
Just because “bleeding” them turns them red doesn’t mean they can’t also “naturally” be red.
A sith species invasion motivated by the desire to avenge the sith holocaust is perhaps one of the biggest missed opportunities of the post-ROTJ timeline.
Couldn’t agree more. What better way to cap things off than with the original source of the main evil of the franchise?
Most disappointing: The name “New Republic”.
Most satisfying: A female Jedi in action.
Where did you get this idea from?
Just speculation.
I wonder if Lucas initially meant for there to be more movies in between ANH and the fall of Vader and the Emperor, with Vader serving a different Grand Moff in each movie.
I’m curious as to what fans had in mind for sequel trilogy villains before the Thrawn books or Dark Empire comics existed.
In both canons, the absence of the Empire’s civilian government in stories set after ROTJ. Assassinating a head of state doesn’t cause the civilian government to spontaneously be replaced by a military junta.
Well, Palpatine got rid of the imperial senate during the events of ANH and gave power to all of the Moffs (regional governors), who were the ones who started fighting each other after ROTJ.
Thrawn was an Admiral, not a Moff.
In both canons, the absence of the Empire’s civilian government in stories set after ROTJ. Assassinating a head of state doesn’t cause the civilian government to spontaneously be replaced by a military junta.
I wish the “disney canon” resembled the original Marvel series more and the 1991-2014 canon less. For example, I don’t like the name, “New Republic” nor do I like the idea that the Empire’s civilian government ceased to exist as a result of the events of ROTJ while “the Empire” survives as a military junta.
The Shadow Guard in The Force Unleashed. I wish Snoke, Palpatine, or both used them in Episodes 7-9.
Weren’t they just grey versions of Palpy’s guards?
The First Order uses color-reversed TIE Fighters, so color-reversed guards would fit. The Shadow Guards also use lightsabers and The Force.
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/AllMythsAreTrue
This led to attempts to justify inconsistencies in cases where unreliable narrators would have been a better explanation.
That Bodo Baas and Vima Da-Boda didn’t show up in anything published after Dark Empire.
The Shadow Guard in The Force Unleashed. I wish Snoke, Palpatine, or both used them in Episodes 7-9.
If Luke could see the good in Darth Vader and redeem him, why didn’t he do the same with more bad guys, like the Emperor, Snoke, Jabba the Hutt, etc.?
Whatever he saw in Vader simply wasn’t present in the others you mentioned.
That in Tales of the Jedi: Golden Age of the Sith, the Jedi use corded lightsabers and the Sith don’t use lightsabers at all. Before Golden Age, it was implied that lightsabers hadn’t changed since before the formation of the Sith (it was later made clear both sides did in fact already have modern lightsabers at the time).
That the formation of the Sith was moved from 25,000 years before the movies to 7000 years before the movies. Sith characters in Golden Age of the Sith think that the existence of the Republic is “just a myth”, a bunch of lore had been written and characters created with 25,000 years in mind, and Golden Age refers to the formation of the Sith as the “First Great Schism”.
I suspect that Revan, Malak, and the Mandalorian War talked about in KOTOR were based on how fans imagined the Clone Wars and Obi-Wan and Anakin before the prequels were made.
Mara Jade having a pink lightsaber.
Have Palpatine’s advisors from ROTJ show up.
Instead of TC-14, C-3PO and R2-D2 greet Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan. When Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan leave the ship, 3PO and R2 go with them. This would fit with the early idea of 3PO and R2 starting out as Imperial bureaucrats and when you consider Lucas said that they tell the story, it would be fitting to start the Saga with them meeting the main characters.