Ziz

I think you mixed & matched some of those pairs.

I PM'ed Troy (and he responded to) my standard offer - PayPal me $5 to cover blank discs, paper, labels, disc case, postage and mailing package for one copy of SW:R.

Troy - check your PM's.

Move - did you ever at least start Jedi, like convert and clean up the audio track, at least?  Maybe you could make it available for someone else to follow in your footsteps.

RascalRobot said:

RapidShare doesn't have a "search" option.

Is there any website that I can access ( or an exact link to rapidshare ) that has the ISO image available for download?

www dot rapidlibrary dot com

You can also do a search for a site called LinkTalk.  FanEdit has a whole section there with the RS links to all kinds of stuff, including these.

Shouta, check your PMs.

Oleo said:

Regarding Dooku's reaction to having both hands cut off vs. Luke's reaction in ESB: I would imagine that a screaming Dooku in that scene might have pushed the film into "R" rating territory.

Dooku was shocked that a Jedi would do something so cruel.  He didn't have time to scream in pain because his mind was reeling from the reality of the fact of what just happened.  And then his mind ended up on the floor.

ImperialFighter said:

Ziz -  I don't know if you missed it before, but Ady has previously mentioned that part of the appeal of doing this edit is the fact that he will enjoy making the stuff along the way, himself.  I've come across some shots of his work in the past that he's made, and hope that he will be able do his own stuff for this eventually, if possible.

Not doubting his abilities, just making suggestions on how to ease the workload and free up finances from one area of the project to another.

You could also save some budget by farming out the model work.  I know a few people in the UK who would be willing to build stuff for you or may even have something already made.

Let's just hope Ady doesn't suffer budget cuts and have to use this to replace Death Star shots.

Shouldn't that light be shining that round Imperial logo instead?

Actually, I think that matte was painted for the deleted Sandstorm scene.

And the bit about Luke building his saber with spare parts in Ben's attic explains why his ROTJ saber looks so much like Ben's ANH saber.

Cibernite said:

Is there anyway to fix the scene where Vader talks to The Emperor? I clearly remember seeing him walk off the Bridge to his chamber . But Then when it cuts from Executor exiting the Asteroid Field, It has him walking down the steps like he just rose up from his chamber and walked down.  Could there be like an Audio Que stating to Vader that Executor has cleared the field? How does he know when the ship is clear?  It's just a thought.

That's called "dramatic license".  We don't need the audio cue to tell us that Vader was told the ship is clear.  We see the ship clear, then we see Vader go to talk to Palp.  Why else would he be moving?

A movie isn't a football game where you have to see every fraction of a nano-second documented and re-counted 87 times over before moving on.

So, where the hell is Ady?  When's the last time he checked in here?  Hopefully George's "SE Police" haven't abducted him or anything.

Why'd you change the shuttle element?  I think the original one looks better.

Bingowings said:

Good question (an overbite only a Brit could come up with)

Or Matt Groening.

Do a search for a site called LinkTalk.  They have a section there were FanEdit.org now puts all their RS links.  Look for the Revisited thread in there.

Yeah, I'm sure he loves having his brain twisted into angles and dimensions that only exist in quantum physics.

adywan: when R2 approaches the doorway i will be fixing the issue of it being impossible for him to enter it. as the door is closing the bottom section will rise

Wouldn't it be easier to just shift the whole thing down so that the notches are level with the floor?  Then it's functionally the same style as the giant garage door at Jabba's place.

That explosion in shot 3 looks too big.  Remember the scale of things.  While the SSD is huge, the DS is even huge-r.  An explosion that big would cause chain reactions and destroy the DS right there.

Alternate music track, then?  Something you can switch to by choice.

WHERE did you get that shot of the empty SD hallway?  And can you send it to me or post it without the big "BRIDGE" and arrow on it?

Bingowings said:

Ziz said:

Minor tangent, nothing to do with the visuals, but how do you say "Executor"?  I say it as "Execute-or", as in "capital punishment, killing a prisoner", but a friend of mine says it as "Exec-utor" as in "corporate executive, businessman".

Just curious how many people say it one way vs the other, since it wasn't said on film either way.

It's Exec-cute-or, as in someone who carries out the will of someone else.

Someone who carries out capital punishment is called an executioner (which is arguably a better name for a Star Destroyer).

 

That's what I meant.  I always figured that "Exec-cute-or" was more in keeping with the Empire's mentality.

Minor tangent, nothing to do with the visuals, but how do you say "Executor"?  I say it as "Execute-or", as in "capital punishment, killing a prisoner", but a friend of mine says it as "Exec-utor" as in "corporate executive, businessman".

Just curious how many people say it one way vs the other, since it wasn't said on film either way.

Can you take those 3D models and put the camera in the same positions as in the film and post those shots?  Let's see the comparison.