I've had great success using Sonic Scenarist to assemble my dvd menus. I've got a semi-complete one burned to dvd and I'm pretty happy with the results. I did a main menu and language submenu for my test disc.
Here are some examples of my latest menu, created with Adobe Premiere Pro and Photoshop:
No offense, but I thought all TFNers (especially those officially involved with anything) were all "OMG, the SE SE is the definitive editions, the originals are unfinished and crappy! You don't really seem to fit with that.
That would of course be your stereotypical TFNer. However, there are those of us who choose to think outside the box...
Mostly because I'm busy right now helping TFN set up their new board software. I haven't had much time to work on the project. I few weeks down the road though, that should change.
Well I just tried to read through this thread full of tech specs and intellectual babling. It appears to me that you guys just aren't on the same page as far as where in the presentation process you're referring. ApolloOne seems to be referring to how anamorphic frames are created for pressing to DVD, whereas MeBeJedi is talking about anamorphic frames being manipulated by a DVD player.
Looking at your two example images above, you can clearly see the difference between how anamorphic dvd frames look compared to letterbox frames. Yes, anamorphic frames have more vertical resolution. It's because the image is meant to be stretched horizontally to the correct aspect ratio on widescreen displays, or shrunk vertically to fit a 4:3 television. Keep in mind that the desired output resolution (square pixels) of an anamorphic video is 864x480, not 720x480. On that note, I'm suprised no one has mentioned pixel sizes yet.
Sonic Scenarist can do both text subtitles as well as the image-style subpictures. This is my dvd author of choice, and I just assumed that all the other programs could do this as well. I guess I was wrong.
I really don't know for sure, Metallaxis. I think I'd like to make the Greedo subtitles a subpicture so to keep it the same familiar font. That's my goal at this point at least.
Following along with his progress and reading on his site about how he's doing things can be just as entertaining. If nothing else, I think it's great to see what flaws Mike points out and how he goes about fixing them.
Jay, you might also want to check out vBulletin boards. I'm currently involved in a project to transfer theforce.net forums (IGN boards) over to vBulletin. They are highly customizable and we are very happy with the results so far. I'm not sure what the cost is vs. Fusetalk, but I think it's worth a look.
I have no plans at all to release anything less than a DVD9. If someone comes along and down-converts it to DVD5 as a torrent, that's their perogative. I'm not going to compromise quality because of simple compatability issues.