logo Sign In

WitchDR

User Group
Members
Join date
29-Aug-2018
Last activity
27-Apr-2025
Posts
288

Post History

Post
#1486869
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

Vladius said:
I want to believe that this can be cut down into a good movie. There are certainly enough good things in it, it’s just that they’re surrounded by inquisitors (which I have never liked,) repetitive dialogue, poor chase scenes, and an overall lack of focus.

I’m just hoping by the end of it, we can reduce the inquisitors to almost non-existent with a fanedit. Reva and the fifth brother both suck and the Grand Inquisitor was completely pointless.

Post
#1486612
Topic
(The Bad Batch) Cinematic Version | A More Mature Edit (On Pause)
Time

Acbagel said:
2. Complete Mandalorian/Book of Boba re-edit, combining both shows into a chronological narrative with a number of scene and story improvements throughout (Completed the first episode clocking in at 2 hours 8 minutes, will create a thread about this project today)

Oooo! Very much interested in this. Been really hoping someone would do a chronological edit of these Post-OT series.

Post
#1486609
Topic
<em><strong>ANDOR</strong></em> - Disney+ Series - A General Discussion Thread
Time

This has been the series I’ve been most excited about. I’d rather Disney mess with their own characters, then continue their bad track record with the legacy ones. Rogue One has been the only really great thing I’ve liked that has come out of Disney Star Wars. Only gripe I had with it was the characters not quite being built up enough, which this series should greatly improve. By the end of it, I’m hoping we can fanedit a great middle trilogy between the prequels and the OT.

Post
#1486588
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

jedi_bendu said:

I regret to report that certain people are being racist knobs towards a black actor in Star Wars. Again.

Yep Disney’s doing that thing where they call fans a bunch of “-ism’s” and “-phobe’s” because they criticize one of their characters or movies. All so tiring. Singling out a few trolls that are saying racist things to get a reaction, while the overwhelming response from fans has been about her terrible acting. Has absolutely nothing to do with skin color. The fact they put those articles out beforehand warning Moses Ingram of “racist” comments from fans, tells me they knew the character was bad and going to cause issues, and are now going to use race to shield it from any criticism.

It’d be great if Disney and Lucasfilm would stop intentionally causing riffs in this fandom. I felt the fandom was starting to come together again after the sequel trilogy debacle. But here we go again.

Post
#1486095
Topic
KENOBI: A STAR WARS STORY [The Radical &quot;Help Me Obi-Wan Kenobi&quot; Cut]
Time

After doing rewatch… I wonder if it would be doable to have Reva’s first appearance be as the hologram to “Flea’s” character after they kidnap Leia. This way you could remove all the inquisitor nonsense from the first episode. Have her be a character we don’t know about yet, then properly introduce the inquisitors in the second episode. Depending on what happens with the Grand Inquisitor, I could see this working in a way. We’ll have to see!

Post
#1485983
Topic
KENOBI: A STAR WARS STORY [The Radical &quot;Help Me Obi-Wan Kenobi&quot; Cut]
Time

I’m hoping by the end of this series, the inquisitors can just be entirely removed.

Episode 1 - Remove the inquisitors scenes on Tatoonie, remove the Jedi that finds Obi-Wan on Tatooine, remove Leia being captured (keep all her other scenes on Alderaan)

You could essentially remove episode 2 entirely with this… depending on how the show continues to play out.

But going off a more realistic approach, I do think toning down the inquisitors will end up being the most feasible. Almost just make them background characters honestly. Cut the Grand Inquisitor and Fifth Brother constantly hammering Reva, which felt so forced. Have them all on the same page…

Yes and for the love of god, just have Obi already know Anakin’s still alive. It’s been 10 years, we can assume he’s heard of things Vader’s done in that timespan.

Post
#1481561
Topic
Mando EP3: A New Path (A Book of Boba Fett Edit) [RELEASED]
Time

Alright here’s a couple of things after watching through your work print!

You’ve done a wonderful job of blending in Din’s plotline throughout. While I found the show to be pretty meh, the Din parts were great. So them being more sprinkled throughout the whole thing definitely improves it.

Din telling the Armorer he got the Beskar Spear from a Jedi creates a plot hole with your second movie edit. You removed Ashoka giving it to him, so now we have to imply that she did that off screen, or Din ran into another Jedi before going to Tython or before he met Ashoka… which obviously doesn’t work. While this isn’t a huge thing, I think removing the line of receiving it from a Jedi is the best option. I could see this causing confusion for someone going in blind and just watching these edits.

I do feel like too much of the Fett flashbacks are cut. We get too little of his life with the Tusken’s to make his connection to them feel real. No build up to the “biker gang” attacking the village also makes it come out of nowhere and makes it feel like we are missing stuff. I’m still on the side of thinking the Fett flashbacks would fit better being in chronological order as a “B” plot in the Mando movies, since I feel they just bog the pacing down of the current plotlines… even in a massively trimmed fashion like this. This would also allow for less “Bacta Boba” scenes sprinkled throughout, which just push that weak Boba Fett angle that the show suffers from.

The cut from Din trying out his new ship is a little rough. I know you have to remove the New Republic X-wing pilots, since you removed most of their plot in your second movie. I’d have to re-look at the original scene… but maybe keep a little bit of Din hovering above the planet, or just cut him climbing the atmosphere all together.

The Cad Bane “Fennec Shand” line is great way to have him acknowledge her which was a problem I had with the edit I posted a few pages back. Glad you decided to make Boba Fett the one to come to the conclusion to not fight instead of Fennec.

I love that you removed the Majordomo negotiation scene all together. Also so happy to see the chase scene gone, I didn’t even notice its absence in the watch trough lol!

Post
#1475524
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

theprequelsrule said:

WitchDR said:

theprequelsrule said:

Let us get back on track before the mods make us shall we?

This show looks like trash, sadly. As an earlier post noted…without the music it would be a really boring trailer. The inquisitor looks like something designed by a Gothic teen that thinks they are edgy.

But honestly, ever since they made Owen and Beru people known to Vader and Tatooine THE PLANET HE WAS BORN AND RASIED ON the whole Obiwan watching over Luke idea from SW77 is incredibly stupid.

I mean, originally Vader was not Luke’s father, Beru and Owen were actually Obi wan’s family etc.

The more Star Wars they make, the dumber it becomes.

They are exploiting us fans. Disney is an unbelievably vile corporation - one of the megacorps that would be featured in dystopian sci-fi movies. Yet people keep feeding this beast. I won’t.

As the kids say; end rant.

I agree it wasn’t really the most exciting trailer. I think the Inquisitors just shouldn’t have been included. We could have just followed both Obi-Wan and Vader separately without them ever intertwining in the plot. But we have to tension for tensions-sake.

That would have been an interesting idea…but only more ruination of Vader would have occurred.

Vader should be very slim screen time. The show should just follow Obi-wan. Have scenes of him grieving, talking with qui-gon, ect. It doesn’t need to be action packed what so ever. Should have been a character piece.

Post
#1475494
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

theprequelsrule said:

Let us get back on track before the mods make us shall we?

This show looks like trash, sadly. As an earlier post noted…without the music it would be a really boring trailer. The inquisitor looks like something designed by a Gothic teen that thinks they are edgy.

But honestly, ever since they made Owen and Beru people known to Vader and Tatooine THE PLANET HE WAS BORN AND RASIED ON the whole Obiwan watching over Luke idea from SW77 is incredibly stupid.

I mean, originally Vader was not Luke’s father, Beru and Owen were actually Obi wan’s family etc.

The more Star Wars they make, the dumber it becomes.

They are exploiting us fans. Disney is an unbelievably vile corporation - one of the megacorps that would be featured in dystopian sci-fi movies. Yet people keep feeding this beast. I won’t.

As the kids say; end rant.

I agree it wasn’t really the most exciting trailer. I think the Inquisitors just shouldn’t have been included. We could have just followed both Obi-Wan and Vader separately without them ever intertwining in the plot. But we have to tension for tensions-sake.

Post
#1475481
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

BedeHistory731 said:

WitchDR said:

WitchDR said:

BedeHistory731 said:

MalaStrana#2 said:

Let’s see if bringing a new inquisitor (and checking all the woke boxes, since USA and western world are now consumed by it)

Anybody who brings up “wokeness” like that deserves a permaban.

How about you allow people to discuss things instead of trying to remove people that have opinions you don’t like?

Well, people who cry out against “wokeness” tend to be racists, homophobes, transphobes, sexists, and a variety of other things. I think it’s easy to disregard people who complain about things being “woke.”

You cry about people using buzzwords like “woke” than go on to use an entire arsenal of buzzwords to demean any criticism - racists, homophobes, transphobes, sexists. You do the exact same thing you claim other people are doing. It’s whatever though, let’s just agree to disagree.

Post
#1475479
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

BedeHistory731 said:

WitchDR said:

BedeHistory731 said:

MalaStrana#2 said:

Let’s see if bringing a new inquisitor (and checking all the woke boxes, since USA and western world are now consumed by it)

Fuck off

Anybody who brings up “wokeness” like that deserves a permaban.

How about you allow people to discuss things instead of trying to remove people that have opinions you don’t like?

“Woke” is a word used by the intolerant to demean attempts at any social progress and to strike out at groups they don’t like.

100% disagree.

Post
#1475478
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

WitchDR said:

BedeHistory731 said:

WitchDR said:

BedeHistory731 said:

MalaStrana#2 said:

Let’s see if bringing a new inquisitor (and checking all the woke boxes, since USA and western world are now consumed by it)

Fuck off

Anybody who brings up “wokeness” like that deserves a permaban.

How about you allow people to discuss things instead of trying to remove people that have opinions you don’t like?

“Woke” is a word used by the intolerant to demean attempts at any social progress and to strike out at groups they don’t like.

Post
#1475477
Topic
The Kenobi <s>Movie</s> Show (Spoilers)
Time

Sirius said:

WitchDR said:

While I agree with you that it is for “woke” reasons, I’m always willing to look past it if the character is done well. I do think your right in your assessment. She’ll be the big hero at the end of it, saving Kenobi or something against Vader. If she’s propped up at the expense of Kenobi, it will be another case of them destroying the legacy characters in favor of propping their own characters up. They did it with Boba and Fennec. Boba was weak and stupid, while the Fennec was the smart and decisive one. I don’t even hate Fennec, but it’s just so obvious in that show.

Totally agree. A “strong female character” is never just a “random strong female character” in Disney Star Wars, we all know this. Rey, Holdo and Fennec (in BOBF) had the power to make men around them seem stupid. This new inquisitor have more screen time than any other character in the trailer. It isn’t a “conspiracy theory”, the concern is real.

It’s happened countless times throughout Disney Star Wars that I don’t get how people don’t see it.