logo Sign In

Tyrphanax

User Group
Members
Join date
2-Nov-2010
Last activity
14-May-2024
Posts
6,821

Post History

Post
#522665
Topic
What do you LIKE about the EU?
Time

It could also just be that Traviss is an idiot and it just seems disingenuous coming from her. My anger isn't towards putting gay people in Star Wars or the Mandalorians, I guess, so much as I don't like her so it rubs me the wrong way that she did it. =P

 

She did handle it well, though, it wasn't like a "HEY LOOK I PUT THE GAYS IN STAR WARS EVERYONE!" moment. She just put in two guys who were married and that was it, everyone in the book accepted it as fine. It was only when she was asked about it that she outright said they were gay. So I was glad she didn't make a huge deal about it at least.

Post
#522663
Topic
What did you like.......about the '97 Special Editions?
Time

Yub Nub is a terrible song. It really completely devalues the somber but hopeful ending of ROTJ for me. It's way too campy. Maybe it would work in another situation, but the SE music is far superior for conveying a bittersweet victory with a lot of work ahead for the Rebels.

Generally, the best changes in the SE are ones you don't really notice as much. Cleanup work and the like. I also liked the dewbacks and such, though they were too noisy (LOOK OVER HERE I'M NEW). The droids and rontos were too much. The lead-in to the cantina wasn't bad. I liked most of the stuff in ESB. Cloud City really lends itself to the more open style, though it was sometimes subconsciously distracting (which is my general complaint for most of the SE changes).

I honestly can't remember many of the ROTJ ones off the top of my head.

Post
#522649
Topic
What do you LIKE about the EU?
Time

theprequelsrule said:

Gay Mandalorians are definitely the highlight of the EU. I can't wait for the movies.

As much as I'm cool with the gays, this bothers me. Why even put that in there? Maybe it's just my straight white male viewpoint that's wrong, but it always seems like pandering when people do that.

And to the Mandalorians, no less. "Hey, let's take a group that's known for extreme violence bordering on genocidal bloodlust and go out of our way to make them seem as touchy-feely and inclusive and accepting as possible."

 

I'm cool with there being more Mandalorians than just Boba and Jango, for the record, because there's a lot of Mandalorian EU (going back to the Marvel comics in the 80s) that's really great and I think they add a lot to the Star Wars galaxy, but they really put it in the hands of the worst writer ever when they let Travissty do her "magic." I'm just glad that her chapter is over that that the damage she did can be undone. I just hope Lucas doesn't screw me over with his Neo-Mandalorian Pacifist stuff.

I'm okay with it for now, like I've said before, because it's not a huge stretch to imagine that Satine swooped in after the massacre at Galidraan and was able to garner pacifist support (not too hard considering that almost all the warriors of the group had died). What would be a huge stretch for me would be if they, due to Lucas, remained pacifist and were able to beat down the Death Watch and have everything end happily ever after. I'm hoping that with these newer, darker seasons of The Clone Wars, we'll get to see Satine assassinated and the Mandalorians return to their warlike ways to show how hopeless things are leading up to the rise of the Empire.

I have faith in Dave Filoni to do the right thing, but in the end, he'll always do what Lucas says.

Post
#522336
Topic
What do you LIKE about the EU?
Time

Well look at it this way: All the pre-Traviss Mandalorian stuff is like the OT, right? It's awesome, intriguing, interesting, exciting, and all that. Then along she comes and she makes a "Special Edition" of the pre-established continuity, changing a lot of it to the very core. Then she goes on to take this new retcon and design another series around those changes.

Then, a new generation of fans comes up, having been raised on this retconned universe, and that's all you see. It's like talking to SE or PT gushers; they just take the word of this author as true because it's been made accessible to them and ignore all the stuff that made the Mandalorians great in the first place.

Post
#522319
Topic
Star Wars Inconsistencies
Time

Obi-Wan's lightsaber shorts out when he gets it wet in the swamp after escaping his landing craft. Lightsabers require special modifications, or else they don't work underwater, this is an established EU fact.

This is the reason he is running from the STAPs and why Qui-Gon has to rescue him. I feel like I've seen a deleted scene with this in it, but it may just be that the scene has been described in other sources.