- Post
- #1168504
- Topic
- Han - Solo Movie ** Spoilers **
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1168504/action/topic#1168504
- Time
The new Spock doesn’t work. He’s meant to be an emotionless Vulcan but actually translates onscreen to being a constantly grumpy and irritated dude. You also have no reason to believe he would become best friends with the new Kirk who is basically boiled down to being a jock flyboy who’s main thing is just to disobey every order.
TLDR: The new Star Trek movies minus Beyond (which is delightful) are dumb action movies with poorly written characters.
I agree with all of this (Beyond is the best)
Leonard Nimoy maintained that while his iconic character may have been seen as cold and unemotional, he always played him as “a guy trying to keep his emotions in check.”
Yeah, Nimoy played him as a levelheaded person that every now and then would slip up. Quinto’s portrayal was that of an ever irritated grump. None of the cast of nuTrek really nailed their character except for Bones and to a lesser extent Kirk. Though Kirk suffered the most from being written as a pop culture stereotype of the character.
As for the topic at hand, I’m a big believer in being able to recast an iconic role. But whoever is cast has to be able to capture the spirit of that character. Sean Patrick Flanery was a great young Indy in The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles because he understood that. The jury is still out on Ehrenreich’s Solo but so far the prognosis is not good.