logo Sign In

TavorX

User Group
Members
Join date
14-Jul-2012
Last activity
7-Mar-2020
Posts
633

Post History

Post
#895717
Topic
If you need to B*tch about something... this is the place
Time

Possessed said:

I’d like tobitch about how with the new forum software I can’t find some of the stuff in the “classic lol moments” thread on account of if they link to a specific post it doesn’t show it in the context of the thread.

This bugs me as well. Still probably worth mentioning to Jay in that thread. In a polite manner of course.

Post
#895713
Topic
The Force Awakens: Official Review Thread - ** SPOILERS **
Time

Lord Haseo said:

Regardless of what you feel about TFA you should try to make time to watch this video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbaliPyihCY

Saw that in my subscription box and definitely watched it!

It’s mind boggling to me though as a late generation SW fan, that ESB was viewed as unoriginal. I could understand the audience feeling let down by the ending though. Back when fans weren’t sure if Lucas could pull through and release a third installment. In their minds basically, they probably thought, “Shit, this movie isn’t as good as STAR WARS, and this latest film brings up too many questions than answers that NEED answers, and now… now we might be stuck with only two films if this one doesn’t sell well!”
Long winded I know, but I’m just trying to imagine myself in their shoes if Star Wars was this new thing. For me growing up, I never had this fear since Star Wars was already so massive in culture. After Attack of the Clones, I thought, “Of course Episode III will happen! It’s a nobrainer!”

Post
#895711
Topic
ROTJ is the best Star Wars film... discuss!
Time

I kinda think it’s mainly an issue with the Emperor. As Luke points out, the Emperor’s overconfidence is his weakness. Plus, he failed to sense Luke was on Endor too. The old man was just waning from old age combined with his complacent view of his Empire that was falling apart.

Or, buy my conspriacy theory that the old coot was digging his own grave: Emperor, Endor, Ewoks. EEE. Triple E = 666 in Star Wars confirmed!

Post
#895312
Topic
Ranking the Star Wars films
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

joefavs said:

C-3PO’s barrage of one-liners spoken to no one, the sudden appearance of R2-D2’s rockets, and the notion that every single droid head is totally interchangeable coming in the span of five minutes are all much harder for me to swallow.

Don’t forget to include Threepio’s head magically being able to operate independent of a body when it was established in TESB that it couldn’t.

Damn, that detail never occurred to me. Nice observation!

Post
#895303
Topic
ROTJ is the best Star Wars film... discuss!
Time

It’s a fair point in some regard. However, you could show that diversity in the universe via the Rebel fleet pilots. That would give more weight to the Rebel Alliance to show how this isn’t just a human fight for freedom, but every alien’s fight too.

Chewie would have something more to do as well in the story. Perhaps it doesn’t have to be a Wookiee planet, but a place where many Wookiee slaves are imprisoned there by the Empire, so with Chewie’s help, frees them and overruns the Imperials there. Introducing Ewoks in one and only movie has that issue of trying to tell their own story, their culture, etc when there’s so much already going on and slows down the movie too.

Post
#895294
Topic
ROTJ is the best Star Wars film... discuss!
Time

I’ve come to terms with Ewoks ever since I read these points:

-Endor is the Ewok’s home turf
-They are savages (they will try to burn live bodies and probably consume them)
-They ARE warriors and trappers (all those log contraptions were probably originally made for bigger game that lurk in the forest)
-They are difficult targets to spot (they’re short so they blend better with the ground, and they can attack easily from treetops as well)

With that aside, while I don’t have issue with how ‘teddy bears’ defeat a garrison of Stormtroopers/AT-ST’s, I do take issue to even have them in the first place. Mostly because I found the wookiee army more intriguing of an idea.

Post
#895264
Topic
What didn't you like about TFA? <em>SPOILERS</em>
Time

hydrospanner said:

Why did the stormtroopers kill the jawas and then make it look like the sand people did it?

Huh? Luke assumed sandpeople did it. Then Obi-Wan said that sandpeople walk in single file to cover their numbers, and that the track in the sand are shown side by side, aka Stormtroopers.* The Stormtroopers didn’t even try to make it seem as if sandpeople did it. Luke only assumed that since it’s implied Jawa’s and sandpeople don’t get along.

*I probably am not relaying the words accurately, but regardless, Obi-Wan pointed out how sandpeople walk differently compared to Stormtroopers.

Post
#895246
Topic
The Force Awakens : Fan Edit Ideas
Time

Luke Skywalker has vanished.
In his absence, the sinister
FIRST ORDER has risen
from the ashes of the Empire
and will not rest until Skywalker, the last Jedi,
has been destroyed.

General Leia Organa, leader of the RESISTANCE,
struggles to gain support from the REPUBLIC
to oppose those that seek chaos.
Fearing the fate of the galaxy,
she is desperate to find Luke in order to restore peace and justice.

Ace pilot of the Resistance, Poe Dameron, is sent on
a secret mission to Jakku, where an old ally
has discovered the possible whereabouts of
the last Jedi . . . .

Bolded parts are the lines I changed. The original crawl had too much “Luke”, it should had made clearer that the Republic isn’t really being supportive of Leia’s Resistance, and it was lackluster in some areas. With this crawl, I wanted more impact and tension expressed. For one, I put “the last Jedi” at the end for more impact and leaves more surprise/shock that Luke is the last Jedi afterall (since one would assume that Luke would had trained Jedi during these 30 years); thus it’s the last line. To limit some redundant names in the crawl, I took out Leia sending a daring pilot and instead just threw in Poe.
For adding some spice, Leia is in desperate need of help, so in order to express that, I removed “With the support of the REPUBLIC” since that implies Leia is backed up with some major help. I’m not sure why the original crawl says the Republic is supporting the Resistance if Leia states in the movie how the Republic’s senate is too slow to get anything done and even sent a negotiator in hopes to convince the Republic to send its fleet for aid.
Overall, my aim was to trim, make some things clearer, and add more tension.

Thoughts?

Post
#895214
Topic
What didn't you like about TFA? <em>SPOILERS</em>
Time

Lord Haseo said:
Why does the escape pod look like it’s in freefall? Also why did it crash in the middle of nowhere (albeit conveniently in walking/riding distance from both Luke and Ben) and not somewhere closer to Obi-Wan if R2 knew where he was?

“Artoo has been known to make mistakes… from time to time.”

Sorry, couldn’t resist 😛

Edit: Also, to be fair, I think if say R2 did intentionally want the pod to land where it did, it was a smart move. If he had landed way too close to Obi-wan, then the Imperials would be RED hot on his trail. So instead, R2 made enough distance to get to Obi-Wan in a timely manner while also throwing off the Imperials temporarily.

Post
#895092
Topic
The Force Awakens: Official Review Thread - ** SPOILERS **
Time

I know disliking Starkiller for obvious reasons has been stated over and over, but it sorta hit me that if someone is marathoning Star Wars, there’s really no breather for when you see RotJ and then see TFA. Two mega laser stations getting blown consecutively up really does feel excessive. I still stand by my claims in previous posts that I think Starkiller made a significant stride over two Death Stars though.

Post
#894943
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Triangle 8/10

A mind bending fun film! It gets points for keeping things vague enough to leave the audience with their own theories. The only thing I disliked was that it had some of those horror cliches where some characters are bred to be that asshole for the sake of being an asshole. Why not make them more likable? Other than that, I recommend it.