logo Sign In

Tack

User Group
Members
Join date
14-Aug-2013
Last activity
8-Aug-2025
Posts
874

Post History

Post
#980398
Topic
OT Special Editions to have USA Roadshow Summer '16
Time

Okay, it IS the 2011 master… But it’s a bit more complicated than that.

One, the colors aren’t the same. They’re almost like the colors in the early Despecialized Editions, but a bit sloppier. In my theater, there was no such thing as the color red. However, the rest of the image looked so good, I didn’t complain.

Two, the subtitles were different. Again, almost like the Despecialized subtitles. They use the same typeface as the theatrical subtitles, and have the same timing as the theatrical ones too. No fading in or out.

Three, WAY more grain than the BD’s. Like, certain scenes legitimately looked like early 35mm scans.

I’m not sure what to think.

Post
#973816
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Star Trek Beyond (2016)

As someone who liked the original 2009 Abrams-verse film and not ‘Into Darkness’, this was a pretty good experience for me. While this certainly has the worst villain (or at least worst-developed) of the trilogy, I think this is the best as an overall film. It has some genuine moments of insanity but it just runs with them, and I honestly applaud that. Unlike ‘Into Darkness’, or '09 for that matter, which felt like they were following some sort of screenwriter’s checklist of necessary moments, this one is far more straightforward.

Thumbs up. See it, make up your own damn mind…

Post
#964976
Topic
Despecialized: Burning v2.7 in Toast... Subtitles and Audio?
Time

So, this may be incredibly simple and I’m missing something, but I’m missing it nonetheless.

I finally got Toast 14 Pro, and am wanting to burn the Star Wars Despecialized Edition v2.7. My problem is, I’m not seeing a lot of rather important options; namely, no options to add subtitles, and only 8 of the nearly 30 audio tracks being playable.

Are there any Toast users on here who know how to do this?

Post
#959043
Topic
YouTube/Vimeo/etc... Star Wars video finds
Time

I think it’s new compositions. The orchestra sounds much smaller than in the ‘Star Wars’ sessions they use in that drama. Granted, they do use some interesting alternates of some cues (plus Take 20 of main title, for some reason), but considering how far along in production ‘A New Hope’ was during the sessions in comparison to ‘Empire Strikes Back’, I can’t imagine that beyond some nips and tucks here or there that there was nearly as much cut footage as there clearly was during the ‘Empire Strikes Back’ sessions. Thus, no place for the music in that clip.

Post
#952044
Topic
Donner Cut Vs Lester Cut?
Time

My problem with the Donner Cut is that it feels so fragmented in comparison to the Lester Cut. Some of that’s down to Michael Thau’s editing, but some of it comes to the simple fact that it is two different scripts being butted together.

It feels like such a mixed bag, far more than the original Lester Cut. Lester Cut is a fun, light and well-made Superman romp. The Donner Cut tries to be more than that, but it can’t always be with the footage it’s provided with.

The Brando scenes, the opening, and definitely the ending Superman/Lois scenes seem RIGHT out of the first movie, and definitely show how good the original script would have been if filmed fully.

I almost wish the storyboards had just been mixed with the filmed footage, and the original Baird cut of the Superman II footage was used. It wouldn’t play as a complete movie, sure, but it would be a very good approximation of what we could have gotten.

I do prefer to watch the Lester Cut on most occasions, though. There are way too many negative technical aspects of the Donner Cut for me to justify.

P.S.: The RIC blows them both out of the water, but whatever…

Post
#944053
Topic
Peter Mayhew Tweeting Star Wars "Journal of the Whills" script. "Big announcement" to follow...
Time

lovelikewinter said:

Any indication when Mayhew is going to continue this? I think he’s in the UK at this time, and filming probably ran over.

Actually, I can say firsthand that he’s in Kansas City right now for a convention. I’m meeting him at said convention very soon, in fact!

Post
#943428
Topic
The Empire Strikes Back: Sessions Questions (Two Music Cues In Particular)
Time

I’ve been going through ABC’s Complete Archival Collection, changing the names to reflect Williams’ own archive, playing with the order and so on, in order to attempt a complete archive of this masterpiece of a score (much like what I imagine Intrada would do if they were at all able). I do have a couple of questions, however, about some cues which are mentioned in this article: http://www.jwfan.com/?p=4092 and are rather difficult to find other information about.

First, the Yoda’s Entrance end fix. This seems like a bit of a bear, if you ask me, based on this article, who states the official versions are some sort of amalgam of the original recording and the revised insert. From what I can tell, GoodMusician’s set had this alternate insert in the bonus tracks section. Can anyone confirm this? And, if not, would there be any way to have the two versions presented separately on a collection?

Second, a question about the cue ‘Finale’. According to this article, a discrete version was also considered (which only makes me wonder even more what Williams’ original ‘Finale’ concert suite was supposed to be) and jotted down within the actual score. Which doesn’t surprise me too much; what does surprise me is that he claims it was actually recorded. Not only that, it has appeared on an official product, no less; The Crimson Empire Audiobooks. According to his descriptions, it would have simply held the final note and not transitioned into the ‘End Credits’ score, and simply had a few harp bars play out the ending. If this is on those audiobooks (and in a salvageable form), this would be an amazing thing to include in this compendium. I think it is possible; from the clips of this audiobook that I’ve heard online, it uses a LOT of the ESB score.

Additionally, is it just shoddy mixing or a legitimate alternate recording that presents ‘Darth Vader’s Theme’ the way it is. In every re-recording, and the film itself, there are several pronounced cymbal clashes that are completely absent from the RSO CD and every other source. I SWEAR I hear remnants of them on the original LP, but maybe I’m just going crazy.

If these are all crazy ramblings or old news, my sincere apologies.

Post
#939578
Topic
"Normal" people trying to sound like they are SW experts
Time

I’ve had kids at my various stages of school get things wrong.

A friend of mine mentioned his dad had a huge vintage collection, which he stated was like from the “1950’s or whatever”.

Also, pretty sure I heard a kid call them the first color movies ever. But that was a LONG time ago, so don’t hold it against him.

Now, I’ve got the people in some film classes who say that midi-chlorians (I think that’s the first time I’ve ever actually said or typed that out…) were always an intended part of the mythos. Although he actually came around after I cited some sources…

Post
#930605
Topic
OT Special Editions to have USA Roadshow Summer '16
Time

canofhumdingers said:

Awesome! Didn’t mean to step on your toes, if I did. I just knew my Alamoes (is that proper plural?) have shown both those movies numerous times via DCP. But I’m not surprised at all that an Alamo showed them on film if they had access to prints. I’m rather jealous!

Eh, don’t worry. You guys have reason to suspect otherwise.

I just hope I’m right.

Post
#920927
Topic
The Good The Bad & The Ugly - 35MM IB Tech Preservation! (+ lots of info) (FINISHED)
Time

Lil Brutto said:

Someone over at the Sergio Leone Web Board posted scans (with red reduction) of 35mm elements. Pretty cool to see all this stuff popping up lately!

mike siegel said:

I finally found some time to scan some frames from my 35mm elements (the ‘cannon’ shots are from my trailer). Just as another reference regarding this endless color-debatte probably of some interest for some of you. My prints are slightly more reddish, I reduced the red during scanning. Otherwise the colors are just the way I saw them on the big screen (just 3 years ago I screened a German 35mm at our local cinema.)

http://i953.photobucket.com/albums/ae15/peckinpah69/gbu7axx-kl.jpg

http://i953.photobucket.com/albums/ae15/peckinpah69/gbu7dxx-kl.jpg
Whoa! If I’m not mistaken, aren’t these shots, like, not in any currently available home video version?! This is getting me really excited!