I can see you took some inspiration from the clip I put together. Some parts dont feel as natural to me tho. I dont see the link anymore so I half forgot some other details.
Could I see the clip of yours you’re talking about?
I really liked the final battle clip, but If I were you I’d remove Kira because she looks way to young in the clip from Solo. I liked how you had Boba and Mando though.
Is this edit finished? If so I’d like a link, I really enjoyed the other two and would like to finish of the trilogy!
Here’s what I got, but I’m open to feedback:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wJ6tJrSvYTpPJEgRgsqoX-ZhOQ13CgeQ/view?usp=sharing
Sounds great to me, good use of the Bounty Hunter game.
I finally got around to watching this, and just like the last edit, I absolutely loved it! The things that really stuck out as great were the Training montages, music edits, slight tweaks, and giving original scenes entirely new contexts. For example I loved the Order 66 soundtrack you played at the end of the Kylo and Luke Duel, it really fit imo. Giving the guards lightsabers will always be cool, and it fits more in line with Legends materials like The Force Unleashed. The Mandalorian Season 2 soundtrack in the Luke and Leia scene fit perfectly, and I really love how you end Luke’s journey.
There is one complaint I have though, I feel that Rey went from “YOU’RE A MONSTER!” to “There’s good in you” To quickly, I think that would’ve been fixed by adding back the last two Flashback sequences. I can also I understand why you didn’t add them, I personally feel like they show a very Human side to Luke, but I know in this edit you were trying to place the blame more on Kylo and less on Luke.
Other than that I feel like this edit is perfect for my tastes, Green Saber Luke, World between Worlds, and the tease for the next edit at the end are all awesome. I hope to see TROS edit soon!
I think it works pretty well, the Anakin and Sebulba subtitles really sell it too.
This concept is really neat, looking forward to see more of it!
Just created a mockup for a Clone Wars “ending montage” for a potential V.2. It’s very rough and has no sound effect or score, and is more of a proof of concept. It uses clips from the Dark Times and several other cinematics. When V.2 comes around I hope to make my own cinematics to match the aesthetic of the first clip from Dark Times. The purpose is to really cement home the idea that the Galaxy is now engaged in a full-scale war, and to adopt George Lucas’s early ROTS ideas of wanting a montage of the Clone Wars, albeit in a different way.
https://vimeo.com/manage/videos/654684814
Password: fanedit
I like the concept, and I think this could really work within the context of your edit!
I’m just gonna come out and say, I think this is my definitive version of TFA. First off, I really digged how you opened with new Jakku establishing shots then Rey. Your new scene order on Jakku made a lot more sense to me. Your dialoge cuts were seamless in most cases such as the Kylo Poe interactions, and the “Stay Calm” moment. I was happy to see you use so many of NeverarGreat’s brilliant edits such as the Island Sketch, and the Rey dreaming of Ahch-To was awesome! It was a really neat idea to add Vader at the end of Rey’s vision from the Vader V Kylo Fan Film. I really appreciated the edit’s to Han’s comments on the bowcaster to better line up with Legends. Rey’s use of the force to break free was much better in my opinion. The sith eyes on Rey were perfect for that scene and really sold how she could best Kylo. The dream ending was neat, and overall like I said this is my favorite version of TFA now.
Of course man, take your time, good luck finding work.
Are there any updates on the 1080p version?
Can I get a link to both of the Mando edits? Thanks!
Obviously a crappy quality video but it works fine as proof of concept for a totally doable (if time-consuming) change. My question is why you’d give him a lightsaber in the first place, and I think the only answer is to make him a Jedi. That poses the question of how you would achieve that in the rest of the films.
You could do it maybe in one movie that combines and changes the sequels.
This could be really cool!
This sounds really interesting? What are your plans for the Hera stuff?
This is one of the best edits I’ve ever seen. It’s so clean and some cuts are almost impossible too detect unless you’ve seen the original. But there’s one really small nitpick I have, during the Battle of Takodona, I’m pretty sure we hear a Stormtrooper call himself a TK instead of an FN. Like I said it was a very small nitpick because other than that this cut was actually perfect.
Has anyone seen this short clip from Petrovelly?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fp69_iWE_Rw
The second segment is Kylo’s fighter on Mustafar.
I really like how they aged Vader’s castle!
I’m planning on downloading and watching this later today and I was wondering, did you ever end up putting Maz and Leia in Rey’s vision?
I’m so hyped for Version 2, it’s really impressive what everyone’s accomplished in trying to make these movies better!
Has this edit been released, if so can I get a link?
Random, admittedly half-baked idea: turn the TROS scene of Palpatine talking to Pryde into an ANH scene of Palpatine talking to Tarkin. Don’t know how feasible that would be, but it might be a good way of incorporating the Emperor into an alternate version of the only Lucas movie in which he doesn’t appear:
“The princess of Alderaan has disrupted my plan. But her foolish act will be in vain…send the Death Star to a world they know. Let it burn.”
That would be an awesome way of getting some Emperor in ANH!
Have you guys seen this project? He’s got some insane new VFX and a great vision.
Imagine if this played before the opening crawl, I would’ve gotten chills in the theater
I also prefer the shuttle, I find it weird that the TIE Advance was chosen instead of the Shuttle.
Thank you!
In the 1080p version, Boba will appear (though he will not fall into the Sarlacc).
Also, the Throne room will be recolored to remove that over-the-top black and white.
Alright, I can’t wait to see the new version when it comes out.
I really like a lot of things in this edit like the replaced music, especially during the Luke hologram and Vader’s funeral scenes, I loved the color grading on Endor, and the replaced backgrounds looked really nice. I also really liked how you merged the start of the Vader arriving to the Death Star II with the scene of the Emperor arriving. A complaint I have with this edit its the lack of Boba Fett making this version of ROTJ incompatible with Mando season 2, but that doesn’t ruin the edit by any stretch of the imagination I just would’ve preferred for Boba to stay in. Another complaint I had was the coloration in the Throne Room scenes, personally I think it was a little to gray and kind of made some scenes with Vader look like they were in black and white. But overall this edit was fantastic and I will certainly watch this edit again!