Superweapon VII

Tobar said:

My apparently unpopular opinion judging by past reactions:

I think they should have used Kyle Katarn and Jan Ors in Shadows of the Empire instead of creating Dash Rendar and Leebo. Kyle and Jan were already mercenaries working for the Rebellion with big accomplishments under their belts and they were active during that period. Instead we got a Han Solo wannabe that was as interesting as a slice of bread.

I think that’s an unfair analogy. A slice of bread can be quite interesting depending on the type.

“Are you wearing mascara?”

“Uh, it’s eye paint for men!”

The Water of Life makes terrible lube for triple anal.

This is getting out of hand! Now there are two of them!

Anakin has a doctorate in Darth Plagueis the Wise Studies

“That’s never going to heal if you don’t stop picking.”

That trailer is a nice showcase of everything I dislike about Force-based characters and modern fight choreography/cinematography. Hard pass.

Gandalf the Cyan said:

The Ewoks in ROTJ were descended from the survivors of a ship that crashed on Endor millenia ago, hence why they speak a “primitive dialect” of an existing language. They’ve been there so long that the story of how they got to Endor has become mythology, rather than history, to them; for example, the ship had a protocol droid onboard which survived but later “died”, who has been glorified as a kind of god.

Shut up and take my credits.

Didn’t Kershner go on record disparaging the philosophy of TESB, though? Saying words to the effect of “it seems deeper than it really is”?

Part of me wants to object, but I never even finished TLJ, so who am I to claim otherwise?

I certainly agree ROTJ’s weak. I don’t even enjoy watching it anymore. Everything between the sail barge showdown and the lightsaber duel cures me of insomnia.

Apparently the theatrical poster for A Nightmare on Elm Street 3 used in Ghana:

“Is that you, John Wayne? Is this me?”

I like the silliness/cheesiness of the old Marvel comics. Like you said, it’s a big galaxy; lots of room for different styles and sensibilities.

I used to be lukewarm towards Star Trek IV, though my appreciation’s definitely grown in recent years. Thank you, Kurtzman, for unwittingly providing some perspective.

Definitely the first three films, though I pretend Temple is set in 1937 instead of '35, as it doesn’t work at all as a prequel to Raiders (Indy’s a skeptic in the first film, which makes no sense if just the year before he experienced first-hand the magic of Mola Ram and the Sankara Stones). I also include most of the comics. That’s about it.

timdiggerm said:

you have to trust Villeneuve to know what he’s doing.

Or do I?

*dramatic sound effect*

Nicole Kidman

Why she chose to flatten and fry her hair with bleach, I’ll never understand.

I figured the Jedi Council would get eliminated and the Jedi Temple razed in Episode III, but that the Purge would otherwise occur offscreen between the trilogies with the details to be filled in by EU writers. I was immensely dissatisfied with how it actually went down.

Gandalf the Cyan said:

I must be experiencing Star Wars fatigue (at least for brand-new content) right now. I have no interest whatsoever in this show, despite all signs pointing to it being technically good.

Really, I think the issue is just that all the new content is just too run-of-the-mill. I’d like them to make something imaginative for once.

My issue is that I have zero interest in any stories pertaining to Jedi anymore. Between Filoni and Abrams, the Jedi have been thoroughly ruined in all eras.

Channel72 said:

I do remember assuming the Prequels would be much closer aesthetically/stylistically to the OT.

Same, only everything was cleaner/newer. I also imagined Alderaan with a more soft-focus fantasy aesthetic, with gleaming white Romanesque architecture.

TIE Advanced x1 is my first choice. The Scimitar would be my second.

Channel72 said:

As for Lucas, he’s actually covered with a mountain of cash, not poop.

And just like that, this scene from The Gate II comes to mind unbidden:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6GJyJVklvw

fmalover said:

If there’s one Special Edition Trilogy change I could keep in the OT, it would be the extra shots of the Wampa in TESB. I never liked the fact that we never get a clear look at the Wampa, only brief glimpses. Another thing I like is that it’s a guy in a costume, a practical effect, so it blends well with the rest of the movie.

One of the least offensive alterations to be sure. Lucas should’ve used the opportunity to give the wampa a consistent appearance, though.

I probably don’t prefer one over the other. Some aspects of the former are better than the latter and vice-versa. I know I prefer Ventress’ backstory in the Multimedia Project over the convoluted Nightsister nonsense.