logo Sign In

Spartacus01

User Group
Members
Join date
22-Nov-2022
Last activity
8-Nov-2026
Posts
399

Post History

Post
#1691104
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Yes, Attack of the Clones should have spent a little more time developing the relationship between Anakin and Owen. A couple of scenes showing them interacting would have been more than enough to establish Owen’s perspective and make his attitude toward Anakin more understandable. However, I’ve never considered it a particularly major problem.

Personally, I’ve always interpreted Obi-Wan’s line, “He thought he should have stayed here and not gotten involved,” as referring to something Owen had told him at some point between Episode III and Episode IV. To me, it makes perfect sense that Owen would have told Obi-Wan that Anakin should have stayed on Tatooine instead of becoming a Jedi, especially if Obi-Wan had told him that Anakin died during the Jedi Purge (since I doubt he would have told Owen the truth).

After all, A New Hope implicitly establishes that Owen and Obi-Wan had a history of interacting before the events of the movie. The fact that they had crossed paths several times, and had even argued on occasion during the years between the rise of the Empire and the beginning of A New Hope, is already part of the continuity established by the OT itself.

Post
#1690820
Topic
The Star Wars Prequel Trilogy: Special Editions. New fan edits with a different approach
Time

Octorox said:

DWN-016 said:

Octorox said:

Thank you for the feedback. Not sure I’ll be able to get to the novelization but I’ll definitely check out the video you mentioned.

I’ll keep playing with the Tusken confession scene but I think we just fundamentally disagree. Padme has always been characterized in other media as someone who fights for the rights of the downtrodden and sees the humanity in everyone. There’s even a deleted scene from this movie where she volunteers with alien children. I just don’t believe she would react that way to Anakin admitting to killing children, even if the Tuskens are stigmatized as a savage/monstrous race.

That’s fair; I think the intent back then was probably more to portray the Tuskens as wild animals more than intelligent beings, but I won’t argue if it still reads weird regardless.
Ultimately though, the specific scene isn’t as important as the wider point I was trying to make, which is that for even the most seemingly-inarguable thing you’re gonna have differing perspectives. That’s why I’m hoping for an AotC fanedit that wouldn’t be trying to alter the text of the film at all. I feel we have enough fanedits trying to, effectively, rewrite the prequels by trimming or cutting scenes. Effectively, I want a version of “what would AotC look like if Lucasfilm had gotten an extra couple months to do another editing pass”. To the best of my knowledge, nobody has ever really attempted that.

All I really want out of an AotC edit is one that portrays the film’s contents as they already are, but adjusts the pacing and exposition, so that it isn’t expecting the viewer to juggle tons of info for multiple plotlines throughout the entire 2hr+ runtime lol. Again, that’s something I really like Caleb Gamman’s edit for, it really streamlined the experience; I just disliked when it started cutting things that fell into subjectivity, or diluted the George Lucas-y personality of the action scenes. He uploaded a few short videos on YT detailing his editing process, which I recommend also giving a look for sure!

I get what your saying, but I think there will always be some amount of subjectivity to a fan edit. We can apply certain principles to our decision making, but they will always be filtered through how we interpret those principles. In this case, I feel like the way Anakin emphasizes killing “not just the men, but the women and children too” is clearly intended to communicate that he’s crossed a line, and Padme’s reaction feels less like an intentional choice by the filmmakers, and more that the hadn’t considered her interiority as a character outside of how she supports Anakin’s story. You might disagree and that’s also a subjective interpretation. Ultimately, the official cut is George Lucas’s cut. I don’t really get a sense that he was rushed or didn’t get to fully execute on his ideas. This fan edit attempts to preserve more of the spirit of George Lucas than most, but it’s still ultimately filtered through my feelings on how to best communicate the narrative he was trying to tell. It’s okay if ends up not being for you, but I appreciate your feedback.

And to add to what Jar Jar Bricks said: Yes, consistency with current canon is also a goal of this edit, and everything we know about Padme from other sources (and even other parts of this film) kind of conflicts with her reaction here. Notably, I’m not actually changing the intent or outcome of the scene, just softening it a bit so her reaction feels a bit less out of character. If I really wanted to change things, I’d copy the Hal9000 approach of cutting the scene entirely, but I do think it has value for Anakin’s character development.

I think there might actually be a way to keep the scene without having to explain why Padmé doesn’t react more strongly or seem frightened by Anakin’s behavior: replacing Padmé with Palpatine.

if you could use AI to create a convincing hologram of Palpatine, you could rework the scene so that Anakin contacts him and, when Palpatine’s hologram appears, Anakin starts delivering the lines we already know: “Life is simpler when you can fix things. I’m good at fixing things, always was,” and so on.

In their current form, the Prequels make it seem almost like all the grooming happened in Revenge of the Sith. But we know that’s not the case. We know Palpatine started manipulating and grooming Anakin when he was a child. And Attack of the Clones has always needed precisely that: a few more moments of Palpatine grooming Anakin and encouraging his darker tendencies. Replacing Padmé with Palpatine would give the movie exactly what it needs. It would also tie directly into what Palpatine says to Anakin in Revenge of the Sith: “Do you remember what you told me about your mother and the sand people?”

The only problem is that you’d obviously need some pretty convincing AI work to pull this off.

Post
#1690286
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

RangerofAquilae said:

Spartacus01 said:

RangerofAquilae said:

For example, being part of, and supporting, a genocidal regime is not necessarily the same as committing genocide oneself. (Just as aiding and abetting a violent crime can be distinguished from the violent crime itself.) Sure it’s bad, but not as bad. When it comes to the destruction of Alderaan, Tarkin was the far worse actor.

In the Original Trilogy, Obi-Wan tells us that Vader helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights. In other words, he didn’t just support the Jedi purge, he actively participated in it and killed an unspecified number of Jedi. So the fact that he participated in a genocide is something that was already established by the Original Trilogy, from the very first movie no less.

I conceded this point, after a fashion, in an exchange with Dagenspear above:

RangerofAquilae said:

Dagenspear said:
It was specifically said he’d helped the empire to hunt down and destroy the Jedi. Did you think he had no hand in the genocide at all?

My mention of genocide was in reference to the destruction of Alderaan, which you mentioned in your post. I didn’t have the extermination of the Jedi in mind, but I can see how one could think of it in that way.

But even so: hunting down and killing extremely dangerous combatants who are well trained, armed, and capable of fighting back is much less despicable than destroying an entire civilian population (as in the case of the destruction of Alderaan) or murdering defenseless young children.

At least to my moral sensibilities (as someone who’s read Anscombe). YMMV!

Sorry, I missed that part.

In any case, I don’t agree with your take. Personally, I think the Anakin we got in the Prequels works pretty well. I would only tone down some of his reactions in Attack of the Clones, so they don’t come across as quite so over the top. But aside from that, I’m fine with the Anakin we have now.

That being said, I respect your opinion, and I’m glad you managed to write a rewrite of the Prequels you’re happy with. That way, if you don’t like the Prequels as they are, you can always treat your rewrite as your own headcanon.

Post
#1690283
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

RangerofAquilae said:

For example, being part of, and supporting, a genocidal regime is not necessarily the same as committing genocide oneself. (Just as aiding and abetting a violent crime can be distinguished from the violent crime itself.) Sure it’s bad, but not as bad. When it comes to the destruction of Alderaan, Tarkin was the far worse actor.

In the Original Trilogy, Obi-Wan tells us that Vader helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights. In other words, he didn’t just support the Jedi purge, he actively participated in it and killed an unspecified number of Jedi. So the fact that he participated in a genocide is something that was already established by the Original Trilogy, from the very first movie no less.

Post
#1688492
Topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Time

I’ve been thinking that, now that AI makes it possible to convincingly redub scenes, it might be possible to edit the Prequel Trilogy to remove all references to the midi-chlorians while still keeping the Chosen One prophecy intact.

For example, in The Phantom Menace, during the scene where Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan speak before the Jedi Council, you could slightly change Qui-Gon’s dialogue with AI. Instead of saying that Anakin was conceived by the midi-chlorians, he could simply say that Anakin was conceived by the Force. I don’t think that would require a huge change, and it would let you preserve the prophecy without the whole midi-chlorian concept.

As odd as it might sound, I’ve actually seen quite a few people who like the idea of the Chosen One prophecy and Anakin being destined to destroy the Sith and bring balance back to the galaxy, but who really dislike the midi-chlorians. An edit like that could satisfy both camps by keeping the prophecy while completely removing the midi-chlorians from the story.

Post
#1682300
Topic
Star Wars FILMS RANKED (ORIGINAL AND PREQUELS ONLY)
Time

Broom Kid said:

Tier 1:

  1. The Empire Strikes Back
  2. The Last Jedi
  3. Star Wars

Tier 2:
4) The Force Awakens
5) Return of the Jedi

Tier 3:
6) Revenge of the Sith
7) The Phantom Menace

Tier 4:
8) Attack of the Clones
9) The Rise of Skywalker

The Sequel Trilogy wasn’t supposed to be included. Like OP said, this is supposed to be a ranking of the original 6 films.

In any case, I have two separate rankings: one for the objective quality of the movies, and one for subjective personal enjoyment.

Objective quality ranking:

  1. The Empire Strikes Back
  2. A New Hope
  3. Revenge of the Sith
  4. Return of the Jedi
  5. The Phantom Menace
  6. Attack of the Clones

Personal enjoyment ranking:

  1. Revenge of the Sith
  2. Attack of the Clones
  3. A New Hope
  4. The Phantom Menace
  5. Return of the Jedi
  6. The Empire Strikes Back
Post
#1681654
Topic
Poor quality CGI and CGI-affected shots &amp; scenes in the <strong>Prequel Trilogy</strong> films…
Time

I’m not going to pretend the Prequel Trilogy didn’t rely too heavily on CGI or that there weren’t some pretty obvious misses in that department. We all agree on that point.

But honestly, this thread feels like it was designed just to slowly post every single frame from the trilogy one by one, nitpick something in each of them, keep going until there are no frames left, and then say, “See? We checked every frame and none of them are good. That proves that the Prequels suck.”

I genuinely don’t see what the point of this thread is supposed to be beyond that.

Post
#1675694
Topic
What Do YOU Think Star Wars Should Do Next?
Time

Broom Kid said:

You know what I think would be hilarious:

If they put Filoni in charge precisely because after the 50th anniversary, they already know they’re going to reboot the whole thing. Especially if Kinberg’s trilogy comes out the gate and faceplants (which it will, Kinberg is… bad at movies.)

It’s increasingly becoming apparent to basically everyone who has been saying stuff like “it’s a rich, fertile ground for all sorts of stories…” that it’s actually not. All people seem to like and/or respond to, is stuff that ties into the Original Trilogy, and that’s probably because Star Wars isn’t a setting, not for the people who have, generation after generation, made it popular and lucrative a thousand times over. Star Wars isn’t a blank canvas for myriad different kinds of stories. Star Wars is Luke Skywalker and Darth Vader and Han Solo and Princess Leia and unless your Star War has some sort of link BACK to that, nobody really cares. Hell, even if you DO have some sort of link back to it, half the time people aren’t going to care.

I honestly think, after the Original Versions finally get a full-blown restoration and exhibition in 2027, it’s just going to become even more obvious that “Star Wars” means, to basically everyone who loves it, STAR WARS

It’s a limited story, with a limited scope, and the more people say it could and should spread out, the more we find out the people who hold that view are niche, comparatively. IT’s good for tie-in merch novels and tie-in merch games, sure. But the setting doesn’t really resonate with anyone without a tie back to the Skywalker saga.

It feels more and more likely to me that, eventually they’re going to give up on wrangling this continuity, like they gave up on wrangling it once already, once upon a sale. I think it’d be funny if the guy who only has the gig he’s got because he positioned himself within the company as George’s first/best protege (after chucking Tartakovsky out a window), is given the keys to the company solely to rewrite his old mentor, so that the Skywalker Saga maybe has more GOOD movies in it than bad ones for the first time. He’s the safe, standard choice. He’s Lucas-esque, they think. Is he really? No. But he’s close enough, and he’ll do for marketing purposes.

I honestly think the scenario you’re describing is extremely unlikely.

A full reboot that keeps only the Original Trilogy and wipes everything else is basically a non-starter. There are a lot of fans who genuinely like the Prequel Trilogy, The Clone Wars, Rebels, and related material. You might personally dislike them, but in terms of audience size, merchandise, and long-term engagement, those stories are vital. If Disney/Lucasfilm were to nuke everything except the OT, they’d alienate a massive chunk of the fandom overnight. That would be an incredibly self-destructive move, and whatever else you think about Disney, they’re not that stupid.

​A reboot in the 2014 sense is much more plausible. By that, I mean keeping Lucas’s six films and The Clone Wars as the foundation, then quietly reshuffling or overwriting some of the post-ROTJ canon that hasn’t landed well. That’s something I could see happening eventually. But a hard reset where Star Wars is reduced to just 1977-1983 and everything else gets tossed has no chance of happening.

​There’s also a very practical reason this won’t happen. George Lucas’s films, including the Prequels, are contractually protected. Disney cannot just decide to erase or overwrite them. If they tried something like that, Lucas would absolutely lose his mind, and he’d be legally in the right to do so.

Post
#1669066
Topic
Are you glad Lucas sold Lucasfilm to Disney or do you wish he hadn’t?
Time

Sremrofsnart said:

I can understand many of your points very well, and yes, I also admit that I might be a bit too critical of Andor in some aspects. But for me personally, it unfortunately crossed a few lines that simply weren’t crossed before (keyword: attempted rape of Bix). I absolutely don’t deny that such themes exist in Star Wars and have always been there (Leia and Jabba, for example), but for me it was simply too much in terms of tone and especially the explicitness of the scene, which was extremely brutal by Star Wars standards. Unfortunately, you could really tell that this was deliberately incorporated into Bix’s story because apparently she hadn’t suffered enough yet, and with Season 2 they clearly wanted to consciously test all the boundaries they had – and that’s exactly what didn’t sit well with me, at least.

I get why that scene might cross a line for you, but it honestly doesn’t bother me that much. At the end of the day, it’s just one scene, and it’s not like there have never been dark moments in live-action Star Wars prior to Andor. I mean, in Revenge of the Sith there’s a scene where the corpses of the younglings Anakin killed are clearly visible. Sure, you don’t see Anakin actually killing them, but you do see him about to do it, and the next time we’re in the Temple, the kids are lying there on the floor. At the time, this was unthinkable because Star Wars had never been that dark before, and many fans criticized it for going too far. Yet now the scene exists and most fans have come to accept it. So again, I totally understand why some people think this scene crosses a line, but to me it’s really not a big deal. It’s just one scene, and it’s not like there have never been dark moments in live-action Star Wars before.

Another thing that needs to be mentioned here is that I think it’s also a problem that a dark series like Andor appeared right in the middle of many non-dark Disney products and series, and I think that’s why it feels so out of place, at least for me. It feels like a 180-degree turn – first you have shows like Skeleton Crew which was simply made for a younger audience, and then BAM, you have Andor which is clearly intended for an older audience. They’ve clearly lost their course regarding tonality. If Star Wars had been taken more seriously by Disney from the beginning, and if Disney hadn’t maneuvered the franchise too much into the younger target demographic with all their merch and series – then Andor would have landed much better tonally. And that’s actually the tragic thing about it, because Andor is actually a very good series, and yes, I can absolutely understand why the series is so popular – because it finally shows Star Wars seriously again, away from all the fanservice etc. But you simply have to note that Andor unfortunately appeared a bit too late, because now we have a completely confusing mess of Star Wars products, and even though there were already clear differences in the old EU – there’s still a big difference between whether you do this in book or comic form or in live-action series form.

I get why that could feel out of place for someone who watched all the series as they were released. But for me personally, it’s not really an issue, for a couple of reasons. First, by the time the second season of Andor came out, I had already stopped keeping up with all the other Star Wars series. Kenobi had disappointed me so much that as soon as I finished it, I decided I wasn’t going to watch any more Star Wars series or movies unless they were genuinely something new we hadn’t seen before, or unless I was actually interested in them. So when Season 2 of Andor dropped, I hadn’t seen The Mandalorian Season 3, Tales of the Jedi, Tales of the Empire, Skeleton Crew, or the Ahsoka series. The only thing I had been keeping up with since Kenobi was Andor itself, so the tonal shift you mentioned didn’t affect me at all. Second, even if I had been following everything, I’m the kind of person who can compartmentalize each series and product and enjoy them on their own, so I don’t let what I’ve seen before or after in other series influence how I experience each one.

Post
#1668983
Topic
Are you glad Lucas sold Lucasfilm to Disney or do you wish he hadn’t?
Time

Sremrofsnart said:

The answer is very clear in my eyes… It’s not HIS Star Wars anymore, not his vision, not the franchise he wanted it to be… To put it somewhat bluntly here: In my view, with Andor, Star Wars has now officially lost everything that once made it so great and DIFFERENT from other franchises. Star Wars was never intended to be that gritty, dark, and realistic – in fact, Star Wars was always meant to be a space opera fairy tale that EVERYONE could enjoy. And that’s absolutely nowhere to be seen anymore in anything Disney Star Wars produces.

Why do I address Andor so fiercely here? The point is that the other stuff on Disney+ consists of Star Wars shows that were mainly in my eyes bad fan service and all used the same nostalgia-bait tactics instead of giving us something truly new (like the Prequels back in the day – they weren’t perfect, but they were something completely NEW to the franchise). But through all the instrumentalization of the shows and the deliberate merchandising product placement (Baby Yoda/Grogu… now we have everything with Grogu), all these shows NEVER crossed a certain line – and those lines were absolutely broken with Andor. In my opinion, Andor is NOT Star Wars… not in the slightest way George Lucas wanted it to be (yes, I know that some early concepts of The Star Wars were also darker, but there was a REASON why George changed it into the movie that started it all).

I respectfully disagree. Maybe it’s because I’ve always loved the old Expanded Universe, which could get pretty gritty, realistic, and dark when it wanted to. But honestly, I’ve never bought into the idea that Star Wars needs to stick to one specific tone or genre, or that every new project has to imitate George Lucas in style or mood. To me, that completely misses the point.

Star Wars is huge. We’re talking about a galaxy with billions of worlds, millions of species, and basically infinite scenarios. The whole appeal is that it can go in a thousand different directions. If every story felt exactly the same, the franchise would be incredibly boring. That’s why the old EU was so great. You had stories that tried to echo Lucas’s writing style and tone, stories that leaned hard into realism and grit, stories that lived somewhere in the middle, and even stories that barely felt like they belonged to Star Wars at all. That variety made the universe feel alive.

The problem with Disney Star Wars isn’t that the authors aren’t able to match Lucas’s writing style, it’s that they often don’t know how to craft solid stories in the first place. When they want to, they can. We saw it with Rogue One, with Andor, and with some of the books and comics. There are releases that are genuinely well written, but they’re the exception instead of the rule. And to me, that’s the real problem.

Post
#1665322
Topic
UFO's &amp; other anomalies ... do you believe?
Time

CIA’s UFO Explanation Is Preposterous

by Bruce Maccabee, 2000

Original source: https://web.archive.org/web/20040604192621/https://brumac.8k.com/cia\_explaination.html


In 1997, the CIA published an article that describes its involvement in the history of UFO phenomena. (The article is published in the unclassified version of Studies in Intelligence, a twice-yearly CIA journal. It’s available at the CIA website.) According to historian and author Jerry Haines, the CIA believed that, when the U-2 high-altitude spy plane began flying in early August 1955, “commercial pilots and air traffic controllers began reporting a large increase in UFO sightings.”

The U-2 is the high-altitude spy plane made famous by the 1960 shootdown of Gary Powers, as he flew over the Soviet Union, and by photos of Russian missile sites in Cuba during the “Cuban Missile Crisis.” Mr. Haines has written,

“According to later estimates from CIA officials who worked on the U-2 project and the OXCART (SR-71 or Blackbird) project, over half of all UFO reports from the late 1950s through the 1960s were accounted for by manned reconnaissance flights (namely the U-2) over the United States. This led the Air Force to make misleading and deceptive statements to the public in order to allay public fears and to protect an extraordinarily sensitive national security project. While perhaps justified, this deception added fuel to the later conspiracy theories and the coverup controversy of the 1970s. The percentage of what the Air Force considered unexplained UFO sightings fell to 5.9 percent in 1955 and to 4 percent in 1956.”

This explanation for many (“over half of all”) UFO reports is new, in the sense that it’s never before been publicized. It was not contained within documents released by the CIA in December 1978, after a lawsuit filed under the Freedom of Information and Privacy Act (FOIPA) by Ground Saucer Watch, a civilian UFO organization which closed in the early 1980s. According to Mr. Haines, the U-2 was reported as a UFO because:

“The early U-2s were silver (they were later painted black) and reflected the rays of the sun, especially at sunrise and sunset. They often appeared as fiery objects to observers below. Air Force Blue Book investigators, aware of the secret U-2 flights, tried to explain away such sightings by linking them to natural phenomena, such as ice crystals and temperature inversions. By checking with the Agency’s U-2 Project Staff in Washington, Blue Book investigators were able to attribute many UFO sightings to U-2 flights. They were careful, however, not to reveal the true cause of the sighting to the public.”

Project Blue Book was the publicly known Air Force effort to collect UFO sightings and explain, or at least categorize, them as explainable or unexplainable. Project Blue Book ran from early 1951 through 1969. When it closed, Blue Book and its predecessors (Project Sign, 1948 and Project Grudge, 1949-1951) had collected about 13,000 sightings, of which about 700 were left unexplained.

The claim that the U-2 caused “over half of all UFO reports from the late 1950s through the 1960s” is, to put it gently, preposterous. The U-2, with its 80-foot-long by 6-foot-wide (front to back) wingspan, flew at 60,000-70,000 feet and, at that altitude, was essentially invisible during the day.

It created no contrail because of the lack of moisture at that altitude. It was, after all, intended to be invisible! During the hour before sunrise and the hour following sunset, it would be possible for an unpainted aircraft to reflect the sun enough to be visible, perhaps with a reddish glow resulting from the reddening of sunlight (caused by passage of the sunlight through the atmosphere, which acts like a filter that removes blue and green relative to red). High-altitude balloons (e.g., Project Skyhook) did cause some UFO reports during these times of day and were so identified by the Air Force and civilian investigators. However, only a small fraction of sightings occur during these times. The largest fraction of sightings is at night, when the U-2 can’t be seen, and the next largest fraction is during the daytime.

A check of the Project Blue Book sighting statistics, which includes sightings by pilots and air traffic controllers as well as by military personnel and civilians, shows the following: for July 1955 there were 89 reports, and for August there were 67. These numbers are the sum of explained and unexplained sightings and so, presumably, include U-2 sightings, if any. These numbers show that the sighting rate diminished just as the U-2 started flying. The Blue Book record shows about 316 sightings in the six months before the U-2 and about 326 in the six months afterward. Not much change over this longer time period. Mr. Haines has pointed out that the percent unexplained fell from 5.9% in 1955 to 4% in 1956, with the implication that this decrease was a result of more explained U-2 sightings. If we assume that the increase in sightings from 316 to 326, mentioned above, was caused by the U-2, then the U-2 could account for about 100 x (10/320) = 3% of the sightings in the six months following. Hence, these statistics don’t bear out the claim that there was a large increase in sightings by any segment of the population, pilots and air traffic controllers included, once the U-2 aircraft started flying.

Statistics based on a different set of data are contained within the “U Database” of over 14,000 sightings by Larry Hatch (Larry Hatch Software, 142 Jeter St., Redwood City, CA 94025-1957). This excellent PC-based software provides statistics that are based on unexplained sightings recorded by Project Blue Book and by other organizations (civilian UFO groups). If Project Blue Book investigators explained some sightings as the U-2, these sightings would not appear in the list of unexplained Blue Book sightings and, hence, would not be included in this database. On the other hand, the far larger collection of non-Blue Book sightings in this database could include U-2 sightings, if the CIA is correct, that were not identified by civilian investigators who were unaware of the U-2’s existence; and hence, a comparison of the sighting statistics before and after U-2 flights started could provide evidence that the U-2 was being reported as a UFO. In this database, I find the following:

YEAR/MONTH Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec TOTAL
1953 188
1954 13 13 12 17 25 28 18 14 18 4 15 10 187
1955 11 8 9 4 12 11 30 29 12 13 12 6 157
1956 10 11 7 5 13 20 33 43 9 6 12 3 174
1957 3 6 7 3 6 5 12 7 9 10 110 11 189
1958 5 0 4 8 3 5 2 8 4 12 6 1 58

As one can see from the above table, there is scant evidence of a jump in sighting rate following the first flight of the U-2 on Aug. 1, 1955. The surprising jump in November 1957 is coincident with the “Sputnik flap,” which occurred just after Sputnik 2 was launched. (This flap is noted for the large number of close-range, car-stopping events. Most of the sightings were not sightings of Sputnik itself.)

An even more telling set of statistics uses the sightings which occurred near sunrise or sunset when, according to Mr. Haines, the U-2 would’ve appeared as a shiny or fiery bright spot in the sky. TIME 0400 to 0700 (which encompasses the time before sunrise). (With a time window this wide, we get an overestimate of the number of sightings just before sunrise, since the time of sunrise varies during the year.) August 1955 is noted by "_*.

YEAR/MONTH Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec TOTAL
1953 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 5
1954 0 0 1 0 0 2 1 1 2 0 0 0 7
1955 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 * 2 * 1 1 1 0 7
1956 0 1 0 1 1 2 6 2 1 0 1 0 15
1957 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 13 1 19
1958 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1

TIME 1700 to 2100 (which encompasses the time after sunset). (With a time window this wide, we get an overestimate of the number of sightings just after sunset, since local sunset time varies during the year.)

YEAR/MONTH Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec TOTAL
1953 9 3 2 1 2 3 2 4 6 2 7 3 44
1954 3 2 0 5 5 8 5 2 4 2 4 0 40
1955 5 3 3 0 5 0 10 7 2 4 5 2 46
1956 5 1 2 2 2 2 6 12 2 0 3 0 37
1957 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 3 1 2 26 3 38
1958 1 0 1 2 1 0 1 1 2 0 1 0 10

Clearly, there’s no statistical support for a sudden increase in the number of sightings at sunrise or sunset when the U-2 started flying. In fact, the number of sightings in August 1955 was lower than during the previous month.

In the early 1960s, many of the U-2s were painted black or other camouflage colors, thus reducing the number of U-2s that could potentially be seen by glint reflection from the sun. Aside from the statistics, it should be pointed out that many unexplained sightings involved relatively nearby, structured objects, not nearly invisible, distant points of reflected light. These objects were reported to move rapidly at speeds that would far exceed, in apparent speed, that of the U-2, flying at about 500 mph at 70,000 ft (the U-2 would’ve seemed to move slowly, if seen at all).

The documented history of the agency involvement has been known to ufologists since late 1978, when the CIA released documents (900 pages) after an FOIPA lawsuit. The history has been published in Clear Intent by Larry Fawcett and Barry Greenwood, in Above Top Secret by Timothy Good, and, most recently, in The FBI-UFO Connection: The Real X-Files by Bruce Maccabee, published by Llewelyn Pub. Co. (available at Amazon.com and Barnes and Noble). There’s little not previously known in the new, official CIA history.

The CIA history is available on the web page of the Center for the Study of Intelligence at www.odci.gov/csi (where odci = Office of the Director of Central Intelligence… shudder!).

Post
#1662552
Topic
UFO's &amp; other anomalies ... do you believe?
Time

Restoring Public Trust through UAP Transparency and Whistleblower Protection - An Analysis

by Kevin Randle, published on September 10, 2025

Original Source: https://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2025/09/restoring-public-trust-through-uap.html?m=1


Well, that was a colossal waste of time. There was nothing there that we haven’t seen before. Oh, don’t get me wrong, a few nuggets dropped, but I don’t think many picked them up.

I’m talking about the “Restoring Public Trust through UAP Transparency and Whistleblower Protection” hearing. That long title tells us little about what we witnessed as congressional representatives, led by Anna Paulina Luna, talked about the importance of transparency and the courage of those who had come forward to tell tales that are basically unsupported by additional witnesses or by evidence gathered through instrumentation, such as radar and other sensor arrays.

Just last week, I reported on a man who appeared in the documentary Age of Disclosure. He said that he had seen non-human craft and non-human bodies. One of the representatives at this meeting, Eric Burlison, was so unimpressed by this revelation that he mentioned he wasn’t interested in talking with Jay Stratton. I believed that when it was announced that first-hand witnesses would be interrogated at this hearing, we would hear from other first-hand sources about their encounters with those non-human aliens and descriptions of close-up examinations of those non-human craft.

After listening to the opening statements by Luna and Representative Jasmine Crockett, which said more about Crockett’s political bias than about alien visitation, we got down to the witnesses. Not one of them talked about first-hand experiences involving those non-human aliens. They didn’t talk about seeing the bodies rumored to have been stored at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base or at the now-closed Lowry Air Force Base near Denver. Instead, they described personal sightings or government-related experiences involving whistleblowers or George Knapp, who reportedly saw Soviet and, more recently, Russian files on their UFO investigations.

I will note that Representative Luna was not overly impressed with the former head of AARO, Sean Kirkpatrick. She called him a documented liar and said he dismissed evidence that might suggest UFOs were nothing more than Earth-based technology or misidentifications without properly investigating. In other arenas, she said he blocked information and discredited witnesses. She was responding to Kirkpatrick’s remark that the hearings were a parade of “charlatans and grifters.” That suggested a somewhat open hostility by Kirkpatrick to the idea of alien visitation, which was the problem with Project Blue Book until it was closed in 1969. A long list of those in charge of Blue Book rejected the idea of alien visitation out of hand with no regard for evidence presented to the contrary.

At this latest hearing there was Jeff Nuccetelli, an Air Force veteran who had a role in the investigation of mass UFO sightings at Vandenberg Air Force Base beginning in 2003. Yes, he saw a strange craft, and he spoke with the witnesses and gathered evidence of the sightings. His sighting wasn’t particularly impressive, but it was a first-hand account.

Alexandro Wiggins, a former Navy chief petty officer, talked about his sighting on the USS Jackson in 2023 that involved various forms of instrumentation. He saw four glowing objects come out of the ocean and take off into the sky without breaking formation. It was a somewhat better documented case, but it didn’t involve a close-up view of alien bodies or of the craft that emerged from the ocean.

Dylan Borland, who told us about harassment by government officials, including the loss of his job as a Geospatial Intelligence Analyst for the Air Force. That was a result of his sighting of a glowing triangle that took off from Langley AFB. Although there were no other witnesses because of the late hour, the close approach of the UFO caused his cell phone to fail. After he reported his sighting, his life and career took a dramatic turn. He lost his job and cannot find another in his field of expertise. For those paying attention, apparently his unemployment benefits are going to expire in just a few weeks.

And then there was Joe Spielberger, described as the Senior Policy Counsel with the Project on Government Oversight, known as POGO. He was not there to talk about a first-hand UFO sighting or an observation of those rumored alien bodies, but to talk about whistleblowers and how the government operates when dealing with them. If he had any first-hand knowledge of UFOs (like Representative Burkett, I don’t like UAP), he never mentioned it.

Here is where the hearing, at least for me, slipped off the rails. Not one of the witnesses had any first-hand knowledge of alien creatures. Those who had seen craft were talking about watching something anomalous in the atmosphere and not the remains of a wrecked flying saucer. They were witnesses to their own sightings, often without the benefit, for the most part, of corroborating witnesses or electronic data.

It was George Knapp’s discussion of his investigations in Russia that caught my attention. I’m not sure if others caught it, but he talked of a Russian colonel who told him about an intrusion at a Russian missile base that knocked out the base’s ability to respond, if necessary, to an attack by another nation. I found this interesting because of the 1967 intrusion on one of the missile fields controlled by Malmstrom Air Force Base. A large glowing disc seemed to knock out one and possibly two flights of missiles. According to the theory of the time, an outside force taking the missiles offline was supposed to be impossible. Our Air Force claimed that it was some sort of technical glitch such as an EMP, but that would have taken out more than just the missiles. Knapp did mention that the Russians didn’t offer the EMP excuse to him as the source of the problem. It was something off-world.

For those who might be interested in more about the Malmstrom Air Force Base intrusion, see:

https://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2020/12/coast-to-coast-belt-montana-ufo-sighting.html

https://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2025/06/aaro-uap-wall-street-journal-somewhat.html

There is some duplication of information in these two postings, but they provide a good analysis of those sightings and the activity around Belt, Montana at the time. There are other links embedded in those articles.

The other point is that each of the men telling their whistleblower tales talked about harassment by government officials, careers that were derailed, loss of security clearances and therefore income, and reputations that now suggest they are less than reliable, keeping them from finding other work.

Okay, much of that was somewhat interesting, but we have heard all this before from others. We have heard impressive first-hand reports of UFOs and we have heard about the suppression of the information. Just watch Close Encounters of the Third Kind when the air traffic controllers ask the pilots of an airliner if they want to report their UFO sighting. They say, “No,” telling us that there is a price to pay for saying they have seen a UFO. I could list several pilots who have found themselves grounded after reporting UFOs and few returned to the cockpit. Just ask Captain Kenju Terauchi of JAL 1628 about his experiences after reporting a UFO.

We were shown another video of what has been called a drone flying near US naval vessels. That drone was attacked by a Hellfire missile and we see the impact, but moments later the drone, apparently undamaged, flies away at high speed. It is an interesting bit of video that was kept under wraps for months and tends to support the theory of alien technology. This was not the first report of an attempted intercept that failed. At one point, orders had been issued to fighter pilots to shoot down a UFO.

Even with that video, I was disappointed because I thought we might learn who some of those first-hand witnesses to alien bodies might be. David Grusch talked about them months ago, but we still don’t know who they are. (I was going to say that we have no clue, but I believe I do have clues about who they are.) You can see my long list of Grusch’s sources here:

https://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2024/04/david-grusch-and-his-ufo-crashes.html

I will note one other thing. I reported last week on Coast-to-Coast AM that Eric Burlison was unimpressed with Jay Stratton, who claimed to have seen non-human bodies. Burlison made a couple of comments that suggested he was pretending to have an open mind on the subject, but it was clear to me he was on the far side of the fence. Apparently he didn’t want someone who would claim to have seen non-human bodies to testify before a congressional committee. That might be a reason the Roswell case was ignored.

And I can’t close this rather limited and quick analysis without making one other comment: Roswell. Here is the case that would break this all wide open. Don Schmitt, Tom Carey and I have spoken with many first-hand witnesses to the alien nature of the crash. We have gathered some interesting written evidence and have statements from the children of the witnesses, including Jesse Marcel Jr., whose father was the Air Intelligence Officer at the Roswell Army Air Field during those days in early July 1947. That’s not to mention that Marcel had talks with his father about what he had seen. Jesse Jr. also handled some of that strange metallic debris collected by his father. Yes, those witnesses have passed, but we have written, audio and videotaped interviews with those claiming first-hand knowledge of non-human entities and craft.

My takeaway from this hearing was that nothing has changed. Here we are, years down the road, and while Congress is expressing an interest in the topic, they have yet to get to the heart of the matter. Sightings by sincere witnesses who have nothing other than their tales of seeing unusual craft. Stories of government harassment to keep them quiet and a still somewhat skeptical press that refuses to spend time digging for more information. Sorry, George, I don’t include you among those who wink at the tales of alien visitation. You have put in the work.

The point is we are now decades down this road and we are doing the same thing we have done before. We even had a “scientific” study of UFOs by scientists at the University of Colorado, who fifty years ago told us there was nothing to UFO sightings and it was a waste of time and money to continue the investigations. This was accepted as gospel. This latest round of interest in UFOs proves that their conclusions were wrong.

How long will this charade last? Are we really on the road to Disclosure, or are we being set up for another eventual conclusion that there is nothing alien about UFO sightings? We can then spend another fifty years wondering about the truth because we don’t have it yet.


NOTE: Since I don’t think the Roswell incident was the result of the crash of an extraterrestrial spacecraft, I don’t agree with what Randle said in the article when he brought up Roswell. However, I’m on board with everything else he wrote.

Post
#1662162
Topic
Religion
Time

When Was the Quran Collected and Standardized and Who Did It?

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicQuran/comments/1bdh9v1/when_was_the_quran_collected_and_standardized_and/?share_id=CVgDdR5_XLEdXGcPf79E6&utm_content=2&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1


Although the standard story of the collection and standardization of the text of the Koran maintains it occurred primarily under the Caliph Uthman (644-656 A.D.), here the contrarian view is asserted that this process actually occurred almost entirely under Caliph al-Malik (685-705) of the Uymayyad dynasty, with the crucial assistance of his right-hand man, al-Hajjajj. The main (secondary) source for this thesis, and this entire post, is Stephen J. Shoemaker’s “Creating the Qur’an: A Historical-Critical Study,” which cites the necessary and relevant primary sources to support it. The intention of the first part of this text will deal with why the standard Sunni story of the Quran’s compilation, as told by Bukhari that focuses on the role of Uthman in standardizing its text, simply isn’t true. Then I’ll give some evidence that al-Malik, with the able if ruthless assistance of al-Hajjajj, did this instead.

A standard common claim of Muslims is that the text of the Quran has absolutely no errors or variations in it. However, when the actual history of the Quran’s transmission, collection, and standardization is examined in reasonably contemporaneous primary sources, it’s obvious that it had many, many variations and different regional text types before al-Malik (r. 685-705) and al-Hajjajj used their imperial authority to forcibly standardize the “received text” of the Quran out of these sources. The standard story of the standardization of the Quran’s text appears in Bukhari’s important collection of hadith (sayings/teachings attributed to Muhammad), which the Sunni sect of Islam upholds and many Western historians uncritically have signed off on (i.e., the “Noldekean-Schwallian” paradigm, as Shoemaker labels it). In this telling, Abu Bakr (632-34), the first caliph and Muhammad’s right-hand man, was asked by the man who would succeed him, Umar (634-644), to collect together the recitations of the Quran together because many of those with knowledge of what Muhammad had said recently had died in battle, thus taking their memories to the grave. Abu Bakr initially objected, by saying if Muhammad hadn’t told his fellow Muslims to do this during his lifetime, why do it now? However, Umar persisted, and Abu Bakr said it was fine to do so and that the services of the scribe Zayd b. Thabit should be used for assembling the text of the Quran together. Oddly enough, Zayd made the same objection that Abu Bakr did, but Umar prevailed with him as well. So then, Zayd went to work looking for various fragments of Muhammad’s revelations as they were preserved in various ways, including stones, palm branches, camel bones, and “in the hearts of men.” Then Zayd gave the sheets of paper resulting from this project to Abu Bakr, who later at his death passed them along to Umar. After Umar died, he left these sheets with his daughter Hafsa, who had been a wife of Muhammad. Then roughly 20 years later, the Caliph Uthman (644-656) towards the end of his reign became concerned about the various differing renditions of the Quran in circulation among Muslims. One of his top generals, Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman, told Uthman that in Iraq and Syria significantly different versions of the Quran were in circulation. He was troubled because Muslims would eventually become divided over which version was the best. Uthman acted on Hudhayfa’s concerns by getting the sheets that Hafsa had kept, which became the basis for an official version of the Quran that a group of scribes under the direction of Zayd produced. Then Uthman sent out copies of this official text to the major cities of his realm (Kufa, Mecca, Basra, and Damascus). He also directed that all the other defective versions of Quran should be gathered up and destroyed. So then, since these final events took place around 650 A.D, Muslims will claim that the Quran has no textual variations.

But is the mainstream Sunni story of the Quran’s compilation historically true? Even in this account, the Quran’s assembly and production was haphazardly performed. Furthermore, Sunni coercive imperial authority was applied very early on to the promulgation of a standardized text. There was no “bottom up” consensus of believers involved in this process, nor did the Muslim scribes have available the knowledge of the techniques and processes of textual reconstruction (as part of “lower criticism”) that the Christian West’s scholars eventually developed. (By contrast, no Christians had such coercive authority over the New Testament’s text for its first 200 years because they were a persecuted religious minority under the pagan Roman government’s watchful eye). When Uthman ordered the destruction of the alternative regional variations of the Quran, how did he know that they were wrong in all cases and that his was right?

Furthermore, there’s no unanimity in the primary Islamic sources supporting the story of the Quran’s standardization by Uthman. There are at least three other accounts of Umar’s or Abu Bakr’s involvement that don’t agree with Buhkari’s version as retold above. One version says that Umar did the work of collecting the Quran from disparate media without the involvement of Abu Bakr at all. Another rendition says that Abu Bakr ordered Zayd to write Muhammad’s recitations on palm branches, shoulder bones, and leather before Umar later had Zayd write these down into one document. Another telling of the story has Abu Bakr fully refuse Umar’s request to have the Quran written down. So when Umar became caliph, only then he had the Quran written down on leaves. Then there’s in both Shiite and Sunni sources the claim that Ali, who was Muhammad’s son-in-law and cousin, was the first one to collect the Quran together. There’s one account that Salim b. Ma’qil supposedly assembled the text right after Muhammad died. Another report says that Aisha, Muhammad’s favorite wife, had a copy of the Quran in the form of a codex. The rival regional versions of the Quran before Uthman supposedly had its text standardized have been called “the companion codices.” Purportedly four early followers of Muhammad were respectively responsible for them: Abd Allah ibn Mas‘ud’s version (in Kufa), Miqdad b. al-Aswad (in Hims), and Ubayy b. K’ab (in Syria), and Abu Musa al-Ash’ari (Basra). There’s hardly any unanimity in the tradition about how the Quran’s text was collected in the primary sources of Islam when other primary sources outside of Bukhari’s own harmonized story are examined. (See generally Shoemaker, “Creating the Qur’an,” pp. 24-25).

In other early Islamic historical works, outside of the hadith, more inconsistencies about how the Quran was compiled arise. Ibn Shabba (d. 876) in his “History of Medina,” has a collection of accounts about how the Quran came together, but surprisingly none of them mention Abu Bakr’s role. One report here says that Umar had begun collecting the Quran’s text together, but was assassinated before the job was done. Another tradition, by contrast, says that Umar owned a codex of the Quran. Yet another story says that Umar had disagreements with the version of the text that Ubayy b. Ka’b had collected. One report says that Zayd and Umar proofed a version of the Quran of Ubayy and routinely edited it based on the authority of Zayd. As one reads over the stories of Umar’s involvement in the collecting of the Quran, he actually wasn’t trying to compile the Quran but was trying to support the authority of one version among several that had already been collected together. According to Ibn Shabba, by the time Umar had become the caliph, several versions of the Quran had already been independently compiled, with each having its supporters in different areas. Umar wanted to assert the authority of the version of the Quran found in Medina against the versions enjoying favor in Iraq and Syria. Ibn Shabba dedicates an entire long chapter to the traditions about the efforts of Uthman’s compilation of the Quran. Besides the version of the story that Bukhari preserved, he gives a number of other accounts about Uthman’s participation in standardizing the text of the Quran. But much like the stories about Umar, Uthman wasn’t collecting the text from scratch, but rather was trying to correct versions of the Quran that were already in circulation to fit in with his caliphate’s preferred rendition. (See generally Shoemaker, “Creating the Quran,” pp. 25-26).

A somewhat earlier primary source than Ibn Sa’d’s is “Kitab al-tabaqat al-kahib” of Ibn Sa’d (d. 845), which is made up of biographies of the early caliphs and of Muhammad himself. He provides a wealth of reports about how the Quran was gathered together, which are hardly unanimous about how the process occurred. As de Premere writes about Ibn Sa’d’s perspective in the early ninth century, “the real history of the Qur’anic corpus seemed blurry and the identity of its architects uncertain.” Like Ibn Shabba, he says nothing about Abu Bakr’s supposed role in assembling the Quran together. Most interestingly, when focusing on the rule of Uthman himself, Ibn Sa’d says nothing about Uthman’s supposed role in compiling the Quran, which makes for a major inconsistency with Bukhari’s standard story. Even more surprisingly, in Zayd’s biography, Ibn Sa’d’s omits any mention of Zayd’s efforts to collect the Quran. Ibn Sa’d doesn’t make any mention of the sheets that Hafsa supposedly had, which were supposedly used to create the canonical version of the Quran that Uthman commanded to have made. In yet another account, Uthman indeed did command the Quran to be compiled, but his order went to Ubayy instead of to Zayd.

One problem in examining the accounts of the Quran’s collection concerns the ambiguity of the Arabic word “jama’a,” which can mean both “to memorize” and “to collect.” This makes the accounts of whether anyone wrote down anything Muhammad said during his lifetime unclear, since it could have meant the “memorization” of what he said, not its “collection.” In these reports, two men stand out, who were already mentioned above repeatedly, Zayd b. Thabit and Ubayy b. Ka’b, which later traditions say they were Muhammad’s scribes. Ibn Sa’d has contradictory reports about Umar’s role in compiling the Quran: One report says that Umar was the first to collect the Quran on sheets, but another says Umar was assassinated before he could compile the Quran together. Sa’d clearly didn’t know anything about the standard canonical story of Bukhari’s about Uthman, Zayd, and Hafsa’s sheets at the beginning of the ninth century. As de Premare observes, the silences and inconsistencies of Sa’d are disturbing about the real support that Bukhari’s story actually has in the primary sources. There’s no uniformity or unanimity in the relevant sources about how the Quran was compiled. (See Shoemaker, pp. 26-28).

A somewhat earlier version about the collection of the Quran appears in “Book of the Conquests,” by Sayf ibn ‘Umar (d. 796-797). In one key regard, his report agrees with Bukhari’s version in describing the general Hudhayfa’s sense of consternation about the different renditions of the Quran in use by Muslims in different areas of Uthman’s domain. In one regard, the reported conflicts were worse, however, since rival groups of believers were proclaiming the cases for their preferred versions of the Quran while condemning those found elsewhere. Since Hudhayfa was greatly distressed about these sharp disputes and major variations in the text of the Quran, he told Uthman in Mecca about this serious problem. To summarize the situation regionally, the Kufans favored the codex of Abd Allah ibn Mas’ud, the Syrians preferred that of Miqdad b. Al-Aswad (and seemingly Salim), and the Basran’s liked the rendition of Abu Musa al-Ash’ari. Oddly, the version of Ubayy b. Ka’b receives no mention in this source. Uthman commanded the partisans of each of these versions of the Quran to appear before him in order to make the case for their respective summary of the words of Muhammad. These are clearly discordant books in dispute, since Sayf ibn ‘Umar’s account identifies these productions as “codexes.” So clearly, from the bottom up, rival groups of Muslims in different geographical areas had written down what they believed were Muhammad’s words. Confronted with this mess, Uthman’s solution wasn’t to create a new collection of the Quran, but to take the version available in Medina, of which he had copies made and then he had them sent out to these other areas of his realm. He ordered that all the other versions should be destroyed. It’s not clear that his commands were followed or that he had the effective political/police power to enforce his decisions on this matter on believers who lived far from the Hejaz. So in the earliest account that we have of the Quran’s compilation in Islamic primary sources, Uthman made no effort to textually reconstruct the “best” version of the Quran out of various regional versions. There is no primary source before the ninth century that confirms that Uthman and the scribes he directed engaged in any kind of careful systematic process of textual reconstruction. (See Shoemaker, pp. 28-30).

One problem that also arises in the efforts to trace back the earliest version of the Quran as a text concerns the original ambiguities between what are now called “hadith” or the sayings/teachings attributes to Muhammad, and the Quran’s text, which purports to only be the words of God Himself. There clearly was confusion about how to make a distinction between these two kinds of records. For example, in an early letter said to have been written by Zayd ibn Ali (695-740), two of the hadith quoted are almost identical to what’s in the Quran (5:56; 21:24). Ibn Sa’d relays Salima b. Jarmi’s assertion that he has gathered “many qurans” from Muhammad together, which presumably were his teachings or hadith, not reports of direct revelations from God. So then, given these stories about how the Quran was collected by Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Zayd, Ubayy, etc. they may not have been able in their time to make the clear distinctions that later Sunni scholarship made between the Quran (i.e., divine revelation) and the hadith (i.e., teachings/sayings of Muhammad). These regional versions of the Quran may well have been hadith to one degree or another. (See Shoemaker, p.30).

So when all these conflicting stories examined in the early primary Islamic historical sources about the Quran’s original compilation, it becomes obvious that that the standard Bukhari story, which the mainstream Sunni tradition has endorsed, is much too simplistic. The key error of many Western historians, such as those who endorse the generally reigning “Noldekean-Schwallian” paradigm, has been to uncritically endorse and support the mainstream Sunni viewpoint when it simply isn’t well supported in the primary historical sources. As Shoemaker quotes Burton as summarizing the relevant primary sources about the Quran’s compilation: “The reports are a mass of confusions, contradictions, and inconsistencies. By their nature, they represent the product of a lengthy process of evolution, accretion and ‘improvement.’ They were framed in response to a wide variety of progressing needs. . . . The existence of such reports makes it clear that the Muslims were confused. The earliest stage of the traditions on the collection of the Qur’an did consist in incompatible attributions of the first collection to Abu Bakr, to ‘Umar, to ‘Uthman.” De Premare somewhat cynically observes: “such variation among the reports [indicates] that each one seems to reflect later circumstances rather than the fact that it is alleged to relate.” (See Shoemaker, pp. 30-31).

The Muslims’ standard claims that there are no variations in the Koran’s text are simply not true. Most significantly, the variations that still are known to exist are those that survived the ruthless standardization process of the Quran during the reign of Abd al-Malik (685-705). Abu Hayyan al-Gharnait, who has been an important collector of the Quran’s textual variants, has explicitly noted that he has deliberately not gathered “those variants where there is too wide a divergence from the standard text of ‘Uthman.’” (See Shoemaker, p. 33). The Quranic inscriptions found in the Dome on the Rock on Jerusalem’s Temple Mount area are among the oldest in existence. (Since Jerusalem was mainly a Christian city at the time, these inscriptions often bore witness against Christian teachings and beliefs). However, as Shoemaker notes, these inscriptions, placed by the caliph Abd al-Malik (685-705 A.D.) “are our earliest surviving evidence for the text of the Qur’an, and yet they different from the now canonical version of the Qur’an.” He asked how this could be possible, if the text of the Quran had been standardized some 40 years earlier in the time of Uthman. (Shoemaker, p. 64).

One of the oldest Qurans, the Sanaa manuscript of the eighth century, has actually two differing texts. The newer one, dating to the middle eighth century, was written over an erased version that dates to the early eighth century. So why would the same folio pages have two different Qurans laboriously handwritten on them? Well, the older erased “palimpsest” version varies regularly from the newer “Uthmanic” rendition. In this case, it’s obvious that that when the newer standardized text of the Quran was promulgated throughout the caliphate of Abd al-Malik, the older version was erased from this particular manuscript’s pages. What was erased, however, is still recoverable and legible. It indicates that at least until 700 A.D. or later, non-canonical versions of the Quran were still being copied, which is long past the dates of Uthman’s reign (644-656 A.D.) (See Shoemaker, p. 77). Most likely the great majority of the variants that existed in the regional codexes of Ubayy b. Ka’b, Abd Allah ibn Mas’ud, Abu Musa al-Ash’ ari, and Miqdad b. Al-Aswad were totally destroyed; what has been preserved is a feeble remnant. So then, how do we know what was preserved is really what Muhammad allegedly heard from God as opposed to what was destroyed? Ha

Another interesting set of witnesses about the Quran’s formation comes from early Shiite witnesses from the first three centuries of Islamic history. The partisans of Ali as the legitimate caliph opposed the rendition of the Quran that mainstream Sunni tradition attributed especially to Uthman’s efforts. According to the Shiites, it was Ali, not Abu Bakr, Umar, or Uthman, who first gathered together the Quran’s text shortly after Muhammad’s death. However, the Shiites maintain that Ali’s version of the Quran was much longer than Uthman’s rendition. The first three caliphs that the Sunnis recognize (Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman) twisted and falsified what Ali had compiled. For obvious political reasons, the Shiites asserted, these caliphs deleted the section that clearly named Ali as Muhammad’s legitimate political heir. So the Quranic text traditionally attributed to Uthman is a distorted version designed to promote the religious and political program of the first three Sunni caliphs, according to the early Shiite writers.

It’s true, however, that starting in the tenth century Shiite scholars of the “Twelver” tradition began to repudiate their sect’s earlier witness and began to embrace the Uthman text such as it is. Because it had become very dangerous to cast doubt on the Quran by this time, they had obvious motives of self-preservation to change their opinions. Although mainstream Western scholarship has generally arbitrarily rejected the oldest Shiite viewpoint on the development of the Quran’s text, this decision to embrace the Sunni viewpoint has to be regarded as prejudiced. As already related above, the Sunni primary sources are full of inconsistencies and contradictions, so why should they deemed to be automatically reliable compared to the Shiite viewpoint by impartial historians? The Shiite viewpoint also has the advantage of being the “minority” viewpoint that lost, which may be all the more valuable since it reports details and has a general perspective that the (Sunni) victors have ignored, twisted, or censored. Interestingly enough, two of the discordant regional texts of the Quran were developed in southern Iraq, where Ali’s support was at its strongest, such as in Kufa and Basra. Indeed, Kufa was briefly the capital of Ali’s short-lived caliphate. (See Shoemaker, p. 40).

In this context, it’s important to realize how violently the Ummayyads persecuted and quelled the partisans of Ali’s cause in their realm. Unlike the case for the orthodox Catholics who counter-attacked the Gnostic Christians in the second and third centuries A.D., who were armed only with the power of the pen, the Sunni caliphs had authority over the sword and willingly wielded it to favor their cause. Amir-Moezzi explains the power of the Umayyad caliphs to impose their political and religious will on their opponents: “In an attempt to justify these measures [that distorted records of the past], caliphal power set up a complex system of propaganda, censorship, and historical falsification. First it altered the text of the Qur’an and forged an entire body of traditions falsely ascribed to the Prophet, drawing great scholars, judges, jurists, preachers, and historians into its service—all this within a policy of repression that was as savage as it was methodical, aimed at its opponents at large, but at Alids in particular.” (As quoted by Shoemaker, p. 37). The standardized text of the Quran is actually, according to Michael Cook, “a remarkable testimony to the authority of the early Islamic state.” The imperial efforts to find and destroy dissident Qurans were especially aimed at the proto-Shiites of southern Iraq. They were so successful, according to Omar Hamdan, “that one could only wonder in disbelief . . . if any remnant of a differing recension [of the Qur’an] were to come to light. Therefore, given the power of the Sunni caliphs by the eighth century, they easily could have thoroughly censored the viewpoint of Ali’s partisans from the historical sources that they controlled, in a manner bordering upon the fictional Ingsoc’s in Orwell’s novel “ 1984.” (See generally Shoemaker, pp. 35-38).

However, it’s unlikely that much of what Muhammad said was written down during his lifetime because the small, poor communities of Mecca and Medina were made up of people for whom the spoken word was primary and few were literate in a broader sense. Shoemaker spends a good amount of space making the case that those living in the Hejaz in Muhammad’s time in these communities wouldn’t have been able to write a complex text like the Quran; most of their writings are short personal messages placed on rocks that are the equivalent of “Kilroy was here.” He also makes a detailed case against any idea that Mecca was important in the spice trade, in the mining of minerals, or as a pilgrimage site. Patricia Crone’s work has been particularly devastating against any idea that Mecca was a thriving center of an international spice trade. Mecca, being a community incapable of growing crops, unlike Medina, was functionally the local version of an almost entirely non-literate, uncultured, impoverished “Gopher Prairie;” Medina wasn’t much better off despite it could irrigate some crops. Given this realistic portrayal of cultural and economic conditions in the Hejaz, it’s fully believable that Muhammad was indeed illiterate, much like many others in his community. (See Shoemaker generally, pp. 96-133).

Working from a skeptical, naturalistic perspective, Shoemaker and others who have examined the history of the development of religions and their texts find the standard Sunni Bukhari/Uthman story of the compilation and standardization of the Quran’s text to be exceedingly implausible. It would have happened way too quickly. Chase Robinson explains why this standard tradition of how the Quran’s text was collected is so unlikely (as quoted in Shoemaker, pp. 38-39): “The complicated and protracted processes that generated monotheist scripture in antiquity and late antiquity are generally measured in centuries or at least several decades; the [Sunni] tradition would have us believe that in the case of Islam they were telescoped into about twenty years. Are we really to think that within a single generation God’s word moved from individual lines and chapters scribbled on camel shoulder-blades and rocks to complete, single, fixed and authoritative text on papyrus or vellum? It would be virtually unprecedented. It is furthermore unlikely in the light of what we know of early Arabic: the nature of early Arabic scripture, which only imperfectly described vowels and consonants, and conventions of memorization and reading, which often privileged memory over written text, would militate against the very rapid production of the fixed and authoritative text that the tradition describes.” Here a strong contrast arises with the environment in which the New Testament was produced, which had much more widespread literacy, including the Founder’s own literacy (i.e., Luke 4:16), among Jewish people and also the educated gentiles with whom the likes of Paul rubbed shoulders, unlike the case for c. 700 A.D. Hejaz. The Old Testament was already a long standardized text upon which the earliest Jewish Christians would have found to serve as the obvious model to base their own faith upon when the Gospels were written down in Greek after a certain period of oral transmission in (mainly) Aramaic. The story of the transmission of Paul’s letters in this regard was simpler, however, since they started their lives as written text. As already surveyed above and as Shoemaker observes (p. 39), the primary sources that portray situation in which the Muslims received and produced the Quran have so many inconsistencies and contradictions demonstrates that historians shouldn’t mechanically place their faith in the standard Sunni Bukhari/Uthman story.

Another factor that likely retarded the collection and standardization of the Quran was the great authority given to the early caliphs over the community of Muslim believers. They were treated almost like vicars of God on earth functionally, because of the power they had to determine the beliefs and practices of the Muslim community, which was over and above their martial powers to wage war and to administer the law. As a result, the Quran itself gets very little attention from believers until the end of the eight century. Shoemaker explains the consequences of this dynamic (p. 41, italics removed): “This dynamic of a gradual shift from the caliphs’ direct authority as deputies of God to recognizing instead the authority of Muhammad’s teachings as remembers by the members of the ‘ulama also goes a long way toward explaining the Qur’an’s apparent absence from the Believers’ faith until the end of the seventh century, as evidenced by both the Islamic tradition itself and the various contemporary reports from writers outside of the community of the Believers.” Most strikingly, Muhammad isn’t mentioned at all by the early Muslim governmental authorities before the time of the Caliph Marwan I (684-85). According to Shoemaker (p. 41), the founder of Islam “is not named by any one of the papyri, inscriptions, or coins from this period.” However, by the time Abd al-Malik becomes caliph, Marwan I’s son, a pronounced shift occurs: Now the authority of Muhammad and the Quran are often publicly proclaimed to the Muslim community and to the wider world, when they had been neglected for 50 or 75 years by the Umayyad governmental authorities. A related reason why Uthman wouldn’t have been important in standardizing the Quran stems from his personal unpopularity and the weakness of the governmental apparatus at his command to coerce obedience in matters of faith at a distance from the Hejaz. He may have chosen a regional version of the Quran, such as that of Mecca or Medina, and then tried to impose its text on others, but lacked success in doing so. (See Shoemaker, pp. 40-41). Much like the standard weakness of the rabbinical sources making up the Mishna and the Talmud, who often projected earlier in time practices and institutions that actually came later, it’s overwhelmingly likely the same problem in reconstruction the past occurred here, in which what al-Malik actually did was projected onto Uthman and the earlier caliphs, who were seen as having more historical legitimacy since they lived and ruled in time closer to Muhammad.

At this point, let’s turn to presenting the evidence that Caliph al-Malik (685-705) and his right-hand man, al-Hajjajj compiled and edited the Quran. Although Muslims at times will admit that they had some influence on the text of the Quran, they attempt to limit those changes to minor amendments, such as the addition of diacritical marks and standardized spellings. However, many manuscripts copied after the early eighth century still lacked these features while others clearly did, which proves the falsity of this attempt to minimize al-Malik’s role in substantially producing the text of the Quran as we have it today. Francois Deroche perceives the problem with this kind of analysis (italics omitted): “If we turn to the reports stating that the diacritics were introduced in the course of al-Hajjajj’s ‘Masahif project’ and that ta and ya were selected in order to distinguish between the second and third person of some verbal forms, we have to admit that the manuscript evidence says otherwise.” However, these modest concessions to al-Malik’s role appear to be an attempt to arbitrarily harmonize the historical primary sources, which also mention the (supposed) roles of Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman as well.

Let’s examine some of the primary sources that attribute major roles to al-Malik and/or al-Hajjajj in editing and compiling the text of the Quran. One tradition attributes says that al-Malik said that he feared death in the month of Ramadan because (italics omitted), “That is the month in which I was born, it is the month in which I was weaned, it is the month in which I gathered together the Qur’an [jama’tu l-Qur’an], and it is the month in which I was sworn allegiance [as the caliph].” Another tradition maintain that al-Hajjajj sent codices with the new text of the Quran to all the major centers of the imperial realm, such as Medina, Kufa, Mecca, Basra, Damascus, and Egypt, with the goal of its replacing the local versions of the Quran then in use. In some cases, it was said that he was not only the first one to sent official codices to all the important cities of his master’s realm, but also he was the one who created the practice of having the Qur’an read aloud in mosques. He also instructed that all the older, local versions of the Quran should be collected and destroyed, much like it was said that Uthman had done in the official Sunni/Bukhari story. All the privately owned manuscripts of the Quran with the wrong text were to be seized and disposed of after paying the owners 60 dirham each. The Islamic governor of Egypt, confronted with al-Hajjajj’s order to accept the new text of the Quran, regarded his command as presumptuous, since he was of the same rank as al-Hajjajj. He replied that al-Hajjajj “permits himself to send a mushaf [codex] to the very military district [jund] where I am serving, me!” The Egyptian governor then responded by making his own edition of the Qur’an. This story completely undermines the standard Sunni narrative of Bukhari, which maintains Uthman’s efforts standardized the Quran’s text, since it indicates it didn’t exist in Egypt at the time al-Malik ruled. In Medina around this time, Uthman’s own family objected to al-Hajjajj’s edition of the Quran, according to Ibn Shabba. The people of Mecca were said to have asked Uthman’s family to produce a copy of the Quran of Uthman’s so they may read it. Uthman’s family responded to this request by saying that it had been destroyed on the same day when Uthman had been assassinated. (See Shoemaker, pp. 44-46).

Stephen J. Shoemaker, “Creating the Qur’an: A Historical-Critical Study,” is available for a free download at the University of California’s Luminos Web site, which provides Open Access to academic books. Click here for the details: https://luminosoa.org/site/books/m/10.1525/luminos.128/

Post
#1661148
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

JadedSkywalker said:

I think Anakin would have worked better if he was portrayed differently. He is so unlikable. So unrelatable. A problem of the prequel is there no Luke Skywalker to latch onto. No real central protagonist, even though Anakin is supposed to be that. Is he supposed to be an Anti-hero? Lucas didn’t seem to know where he wanted to go with the character.

Hayden acts like he is portraying dark and conflicted/selfish and arrogant. But where is the good friend and star pilot. Damn fool who follows old Obi-Wan on an idealistic quest.

I agree that Anakin was portrayed as too unlikeable, especially in Attack of the Clones, but at the same time I think making him too likeable would’ve been a mistake as well. If you make Anakin too likeable, it becomes almost impossible to believe that this same person could eventually turn into Darth Vader. That’s one of the issues I have with The Clone Wars, for example. In TCW, Anakin is so likeable that you never really think of him as the guy who’s going to become Darth Vader.

So yeah, toning down Anakin’s unlikeability in the Prequels makes sense, but going too far in the other direction doesn’t work either. For me, the Anakin we see in the first half of Revenge of the Sith is likeable, and I think that works well. The only real problem is Attack of the Clones. I think that movie needs some cleanup. In that context it makes sense that Anakin is more impulsive and rebellious than he is in the first half of ROTS, but Lucas overdid it and made him way too unlikeable. I feel like if you just trim some dialogue and cut a couple of scenes, the problem would already be fixed.

JadedSkywalker said:

You don’t have a believable through line of the Anakin who wants to use power to restore order to the galaxy, because he has zeal for justice, but the ends justify the means. And the more he uses the dark side, the more he digs himself into a place where he can’t escape and The Emperor is waiting to grab a hold of him.

That is what I wanted to see the Shaw Anakin become Darth Vader. The Horror Gargoyle in the Mask, the machine man.

That kind of gradual, slow transformation is impossible to pull off in just three movies, mainly because of limited screen time. Three films just don’t give you enough space to make it work. To really show that kind of gradual and slow change, the Prequels would’ve needed to be a live-action series with at least six seasons of twenty episodes each. Otherwise, it just doesn’t work the way you want it to.

Post
#1660211
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Vladius said:

Dagenspear said:

Vladius said:

I wasn’t talking about you.

But I’m questioning why it matters that other people think these things about it.

Because it shows how the prequels failed to communicate the story, and why their legacy continues to make the setting worse. This mainstream interpretation of events is directly responsible for The Last Jedi and The Acolyte and lots of other bad EU stories, and like I’ve been saying, retroactively damages the original trilogy. I think it has some real life consequences as well but I won’t get into that.

Actually, the core message of The Last Jedi is that all of Luke’s criticisms of the Jedi were wrong. Luke is supposed to go through a redemption arc in the film. He eventually realizes that hiding was a mistake, that not confronting Kylo was a mistake, and that everything he said about the Jedi was nonsense. By the end, he even says he won’t be the last Jedi, which implies that he has realized he was mistaken about the Jedi. The problem is that the movie is so poorly written, and Rian Johnson did such a bad job, that Luke’s entire redemption arc barely comes across.

As for the old EU, most of the stories set in the Prequel era portray the Jedi as heroic and noble. At worst, you might find the occasional criticism of the no-marriage rule, but overall the picture you get is of the Jedi being selfless and admirable, even during the Prequel era. In fact, the EU fandom is full of people who share that view of the Jedi, precisely because most of the stories from that period tend to present them as fundamentally good people. The only real exception would be the Republic Commando novels, but those books were never particularly popular outside of hardcore Mandalorian fans.

Post
#1659735
Topic
UFO's &amp; other anomalies ... do you believe?
Time

Drones: My Estimate of the Situation

by Kevin Randle, published on December 14, 2024

Source: https://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2024/12/drones-my-estimate-of-situation.html?m=1


For the last several days, we have been talking about drones. At this point, it seems that we are relying more on rumor, speculation, and misinformation. There have been several people interviewed, and official spokespeople have been saying things, sometimes in direct contradiction of each other.

For some perspective on this, I will note that dozens, if not hundreds, of drones have been seen over New Jersey, and now those sightings have slipped into Pennsylvania and New York. There are several military installations in that general area. There are many videos of the drones seen in both daylight and at night. There are descriptions of drones that are relatively small; some are described as six feet in diameter, while others are said to be the size of SUVs.

You might say this began with the incursions around Langley Air Force Base recently and has now migrated into other areas of the United States. The Pentagon just reported that the drones, whatever they are, do not come from any of our adversaries in today’s world, and they are not part of the US military.

After the incursions around Langley in December 2023, Christopher Mellon wrote an article wondering who was operating those mysterious drones that have been seen over Navy military exercises, around nuclear plants, and other critical operations. He mentioned that these intrusions by drones got so bad around Langley AFB that, in response to the drones, aircraft at the base were moved to other, more secure locations. Mellon wrote, “Our government has had no success in determining where they are coming from or who is operating them. It is also surprising that not a single one has malfunctioned and been recovered despite extensive operations by large numbers of them over extended periods of time.”

Air Force General Mark Kelly told reporters for the Wall Street Journal that one drone was “roughly 20 feet long and flying at more than 100 miles an hour, at an altitude of roughly 3,000 to 4,000 feet.” Other drones followed, one by one, sounding in the distance like a parade of lawnmowers.

Adding to this, U.S.-Canadian North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD) Air Force Gen. Gregory M. Guillot told The War Zone that the Langley AFB incursions were just some of the more than 600 incursions reported over military installations in 2022. He also said two other interesting things. One was that he didn’t know if the drones had been tracked back to their recovery point or whether they could have been launched by a vessel off the coast. And two, he saw that NORAD’s responsibility for countering UAS was very limited to something that would be an attack of national consequence. He added that NORTHCOM had no responsibility or authority to take action, meaning they wouldn’t be intercepting them or trying to down one. He was saying that it was somebody else’s responsibility.

Surprisingly, he told The War Zone that all this activity led to the creation of a counter-drone experiment this week called Falcon Peak 2025, in which several companies will offer their solutions to counter these incursions. Which I found interesting because, according to Mellon, these incursions had something of a history beginning in late February to early March 2019. He mentioned, specifically, drones displaying bright spotlights that were seen repeatedly over Anderson Air Force Base on Guam. It seemed these drones were interested in a newly installed anti-ballistic missile system.

There is some indication that the Chinese might have been interested in learning about this system, but there is no direct evidence of them deploying drones. The real problem with that is that none of the drones were brought down by American defensive systems. In other words, they operated with impunity.

There is, of course, proof of Chinese interest in what is happening in Canada and the United States. In February 2023, there was the great balloon flight that crossed parts of Alaska, Canada, and the US. It was finally intercepted over the Atlantic Ocean and brought down. I often wondered why it wasn’t intercepted over some of the wide-open spaces in Canada or in the western and central parts of the US. It was apparently allowed to complete its mission, whatever that mission was, before it was destroyed.

And, not to put too fine a point on it, these drone incursions have been going on since, at least, 2019, and now, they have come up with a program that, apparently, will begin in 2025. Nothing like jumping on the problem and solving it in a timely manner.

But Guam and Anderson AFB were not the only targets in 2019. In September, swarms of these drones were around the Palo Verde Nuclear Power Plant. The drones had flashing red and white lights. Again, these drones flew without hindrance or restriction, and no identification was made. Robert Hastings, in his book UFOs and Nukes, made a study of these sorts of incursions in which security forces were unable to identify or down the objects flying over both military bases where atomic weapons were stored and the power plants that used atomic power.

In the latest go-around, we learned there is a report of a large drone, flying above 8,000 feet, in violation of FAA rules and regulations. Drones have also been reported at altitudes between 24,000 and 28,000 feet. An orb was chased by an F-16 over a sensitive military base in New Jersey. That object vanished at an estimated Mach 3, and I will note that it was an estimate of its speed. These reports certainly are a threat to aerial navigation and to national security, but all we are hearing is talk about what they can do.

In fact, there seem to be laws or regulations that prevent any attempt to bring one down unless there is a threat. I’m not sure why there is talk of that. I would think that the drones operating above 400 feet would be a fair target since it is in violation of FAA regulations and is, therefore, a threat to aerial navigation.

I’ll note here that the US military has drones that can operate at tens of thousands of feet above the ground. The Predator drone can hover high over the battlefield for hours and is virtually invisible from the ground. It is large enough to carry Hellfire Missiles and can be controlled from bases inside the United States while flying over targets on other continents. It is so quiet that it can’t be heard on the ground. In other words, we have the technology to do some of the things that the drones over New Jersey are reported to have done.

Given the growing concern over the drone flights that are now reported in New York, as well as New Jersey and Pennsylvania, members of Congress were given a classified briefing on the ongoing problem with UAP, once widely known as UFOs. These drones are classified as UAP. Following that meeting, Congresswoman Nancy Mace said: "We talked about several different UAPs that have been in the press or leaked. Most of those have been explained, but there are ones that we discussed that are unexplained, and they have a plan, they say, to disclose and declassify how they came to that conclusion and why they’re still objects that are unanswered. There are certain shapes that are unexplained, that are in the air. I’m in a classified setting. I don’t wanna cross over and disclose classified information, but there are certain shapes consistently that are unexplained. Which is fascinating.”

The Pentagon was pushing back on the idea that some of the reports relate to off-world technology. Sabrina Singh, the DoD Deputy Press Secretary, said, “To date, the department has discovered no verifiable evidence of extraterrestrial beings, activities, or technology.” This is, of course, the same song and dance that we have heard since 1947, when flying saucers entered the public consciousness. There were classified investigations and a near-constant claim about the lack of crash-recovered debris, which would answer some of the questions.

In contrast to that bleak statement, AARO’s director, Dr. Jon Kosloski, has said, “There are interesting cases that I, with my physics and engineering background and time in the intelligence community, do not understand, and I don’t know anybody else who understands.”

There have been more statements by officials that tell us nothing, other than to suggest that there is no reason for concern. One Pentagon spokesman said that many of the drone sightings were actually commercial and private aircraft that have been misidentified as drones. Of course, there are videos and photographs that prove that many of the reports of drones are actually drones, and many are flying in violation of the FAA regulations about drones. And we have the report of 600 sightings made over several months.

We now learn that California and Oregon have had their own troubles with these incursions. You can listen to one pilot’s report of seeing something strange here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UppitJ6E9tM&t=21s

I could go on, but I think the point is made. These sorts of activities have been going on for years, with no real governmental or official response. There has been little in the way of investigation or interception of them. I’m not sure why the Pentagon has been unable to bring down some samples of these drones. All they do is tell us that these flights are not controlled by our adversaries in the world, they have suggested that they can’t jam the radio frequencies being used by the drones, and they seem to be able to evade our attempts to get our hands on one. This strikes me as another indication of our inability to properly respond to what is an obvious threat to our national security. We talk, we worry, but we do nothing other than provide weak statements suggesting there is nothing to worry about.

Given the response of the government, it is possible to believe that they do know what is going on. They tell us that it is of no importance to national security, which makes no sense, unless they understand what is happening and actually do know the source of the drones. Their response screams that they do have the answers. It’s just that they can’t do anything about it, or maybe that they don’t want to. Getting a drone would generate more questions, and it is clear to me, they simply don’t want to answer any of them.

Post
#1659614
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

As far as we saw Anakin never pursued seeking to visit his mom in the movies, until he thought she was suffering. This could be an interesting thing to build around, and I think the movie doesn’t do that, and it’s a flaw in the movies that we don’t see it be brought up. This is among the kind of thing that I think for me could have filled out the story more.

Anakin never went to see his mother before Attack of the Clones because the films heavily imply that the Jedi weren’t allowing him to. You can say whatever you want about Anakin, but one thing we know for sure is that he’s impulsive, rebellious, and doesn’t hesitate to take risks or rush to save the people he cares about. That’s his core trait and also his biggest flaw. If he had been physically able to visit his mother whenever he wanted, and if the Jedi really weren’t stopping him, then you’d expect him to go see her every chance he got. And as soon as he started having those nightmares, he would have immediately run to check on her. The fact that he didn’t, even while being haunted by those visions, means that something was holding him back. And since he was part of the Jedi Order, it makes sense to conclude that it was the Jedi themselves who were preventing him from going.

for both things Anakin could quit and do what he wanted. He’s not coerced. It’s suggested in AOTC that quitting is an option.

Yes, it’s true that Anakin could technically have walked away from the Jedi Order whenever he wanted. But it’s not that simple. If he’d left before Attack of the Clones, he’d basically be on the streets. Everything he owned belonged to the Order, so leaving would mean giving all of that up. He’d end up wandering the lower levels of Coruscant, trying to scrape together some crappy job just to survive. And if he’d left after marrying Padmé, sure, he could’ve lived with her, but Anakin wasn’t the kind of guy to sit around doing nothing all day. He’d still need a purpose, something meaningful to do, a goal to chase, and that’s not something you just figure out overnight. After spending over a decade in an institution that gave him structure and something to focus on, walking away wasn’t exactly simple.

Post
#1659496
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Dagenspear said:

The Jedi didn’t get mad when Anakin wanted to have a girlfriend or rescue his mom, so I don’t think it does any of that.

I agree with you when you say that the Jedi were right about Anakin letting his emotions control him. But it’s not true that they weren’t upset about him wanting to have a girlfriend or wanting to save his mother.

Anakin had been having nightmares about his mother for a long time, and he told Obi-Wan about them. All Obi-Wan said was “Dreams pass in time.” So when it comes to his mother, it’s not like Anakin never talked to the Jedi about what was going on. He did, and they gave him bad advice.

This whole thing could’ve been solved so easily by just letting Anakin visit his mother to make sure she was okay. I mean, yeah, you shouldn’t let your emotions take over. But if you’re someone with Force abilities who starts having prophetic dreams about your mother suffering, it’s only natural to wonder if something bad is actually happening, and it’s only reasonable to check if everything’s fine. If you found out there’d been an explosion in your mom’s neighborhood, wouldn’t you call her or go see her to make sure she’s okay? It’s not even about letting your emotions control you, it’s just about having compassion for your mother.

And when it comes to Anakin having a girlfriend, the Jedi explicitly forbade romantic relationships, which is something Obi-Wan reminded Anakin of when Anakin told him that being around Padmé was intoxicating. So they didn’t approve the idea of him having a girlfriend.

Post
#1659283
Topic
What do you think of The Prequel Trilogy? A general discussion.
Time

Superweapon VII said:

Spartacus01 said:

Vladius said:

JadedSkywalker said:

I don’t believe in the doctrine of attachment it was made up on the prequel. It exists literally nowhere in the original trilogy or the expanded universe before episode II. In fact Luke wins because he doesn’t follow what Ben and Yoda told him, his attachment to his father turns the tide of the war bringing Anakin back to the light.

You’re correct that it was made up in 2002 for Attack of the Clones. But nothing about what Obi Wan or Yoda told Luke in the OT applies to it either.

Personally, I like the way the old EU handled it. There was a time when Jedi were totally free to get married and have families. Then, somewhere between Tales of the Jedi and the KOTOR comics, the no-marriage rule was introduced. But later on, Luke got rid of that rule when he started his own Jedi Order. I think this kind of development adds depth to the lore, and makes the Jedi feel more organic and grounded. It shows that the Order evolved over time, made mistakes, and tried to learn from them.

Children of the Jedi heavily implied that the Jedi during the Clone Wars/Great Jedi Purge were allowed to have romantic partners and children.

I feel the best way to have incorporated a forbidden romance into the PT without overturning previously established EU lore would’ve been to have made the prequel-era Jedi endogamous.

Children of the Jedi is a terrible book anyway, so who cares?

Post
#1658940
Topic
What is your personal Star Trek canon?
Time

One thing I’ve always forgotten to mention in this thread is my personal head-canon about the creation of the Terran Empire in the Mirror Universe.

In my head-canon, the Tunguska event of 1908 occurred over Washington, D.C. instead of Siberia. Since the explosion destroyed the entire city and wiped out the government, the United States fell into chaos. Seeing an opportunity, the U.S. military, backed by the biggest corporations, staged a coup and suspended the Constitution in order to “restore order.” Eventually, they transformed the United States into a corporatist and hyper-militaristic dictatorship fueled by paranoia, terror, and expansionism. Over the following decades, the American Empire used its resources to wage wars against other nations until it united the entire planet. The Terran Empire was proclaimed in 1950, with Douglas MacArthur as its first Emperor.