Smithers

I love that their Kylo Ren impression sounded like the real thing!

I like the speech scene but the music is a tad too loud making it hard to hear Hux’s voice. Overall very nice 😃

Sounds cool, there was an old fanedit project doing this but it got cancelled😦

Just use the title crawl for the theme, or the opening song of the clone wars show

A few distorted spots but still looking amazing!

I thought you’d like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nFicXlvJBdo

Sheepish said:

It’s funny, I’ve actually been playing with incorporating part of QGJ’s into TPM. Before Anakin shoots the reactor at the end of the film, I have Qui Gon (who is already dead at this point, in my edit) say “Trust your instincts, Anakin”, but then, I’ve been trying to add “A path will be placed before you” from the tone poem. Sort of like my edit’s version of “use the force, Luke”.

If done right, that could work really well!

If you found a convincing way to incorporate Darth Maul’s tone poem, I would very much like to hear it.

You may be able to put parts of it in his scenes where he talks to Darth Sidious

I can’t find it because it was quite a while ago but once there was a “Mace Windu is a sith lord theory” thread and the OP got all upset at us for not taking him seriously.

EDIT: Found it! http://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Mace-Windu-was-probably-evil/id/17364/page/1

The best part is that he still checks the site every once it a while lol http://originaltrilogy.com/user/CARZ/id/16190

This could be a lot of fun if you had quite a few gags, I haven’t seen that many though. Either way I’ll be checking this out.

Are you going to be using the theatrical versions or the special editions? I’d recommend using TN1’s grindhouse/silverscreen versions to better match the outtakes.

Sheepish said:

Smithers said:

I’ve considered changing his sabers to red, I just don’t have the software or skills to rotoscope them 😦

I could do that for you. Would be only fair, after the help you’ve given me 😃

Besides, I was planning on doing it anyway down the road for my Ep3 edit.

Awesome! I’ll send you color-corrected clips.

Darth Lucas said:

I did one for SW:

Would you be willing to do it with high res poster art in the text? It looks really blocky

So recently I’ve started watching my favorite movies with commentary tracks (which I never really cared for before) and I’m shocked to see how many blu-rays and dvds that don’t have commentary tracks! Why aren’t there commentary tracks on so many of the newer releases?! The Martian and The Force Awakens don’t have commentary an neither do a bunch of my older blu-rays. This really irks me

Would you kindly do this to all of the deleted scenes? I’d like to see and extended edition

I’ll splice together some dialogue for you

I’ve considered changing his sabers to red, I just don’t have the software or skills to rotoscope them 😦

Grievous’ eyes will be changed to match maul’s and his plating will be color corrected to a light grey rather than yellow.

Soon I’ll upload preview clips of his new voice, I think it plays very well.

Scott109 said:
Jango Fett is the assassin whom Obi-Wan is seeking in Episode II. If you remove him, would you not have to remove the assassination attempt as well? And if there is no assassination attempt, what is the explanation for why Anakin and Padmé travel to Naboo?

Obi Wan will go to investigate Dooku while Anakin and Padme go into hiding (no speeder chase)

What surprises would removing Yoda from the Star Wars prequels preserve?

In ESB, Yoda is made out to be a great warrior like the other Jedi and the audience is surprised when the little green puupet is revealed to be Yoda himself. Removing yoda from the PT will preserve that reveal.

How will you change General Grievous’ four lightsabers into a single double-sided red lightsaber?

I won’t.

Wouldn’t the contrast between the live action Darth Maul and the CGI Darth Maul be too jarring?

I don’t think so, since they’re a movie apart

Do you intend to remove Darth Maul’s death from Episode I?

No, he will be brought back in Episode 2

What lightsaber fights (other than presumably Yoda’s) would you want to eliminate? What new ending would you have at the end of your second episode?

-both of yoda’s
-anakin and obi wan vs dooku in AOTC
-palpatine vs windu (it’ll be an off screen battle)

If Padmé does not die, why does she willingly part with her son Luke?

she won’t willingly part with her son, i’ll upload a clip of what I’m doing

Scott109 said:

Smithers said:

Bingowings said:

<span style=“font-size: 1.2em; line-height: 1.2em;”> I watched the first trailer for</span> TPM <span style=“font-size: 1.2em; line-height: 1.2em;”>I assumed that the duel with Maul took place on a spaceship and that Padme telling everyone to get to their ships would take place in the same time that the earlier hanger scene took place.</span> TPM <span style=“font-size: 1.2em; line-height: 1.2em;”>(Naboo, Tatooine, Coruscant, Naboo) seems to go around in circles when it really needs to go in a straight line (for me Coruscant, Tatooine, Naboo).</span>

I’m going to play with this idea, I just realized that since the opening will be moved to the third act:

-Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon go to the droid control ship <span style=“line-height: 14.4px;”>undercover at</span> the end and are spotted so they have to fight some droids

-They make their way down to the hangar when Darth Maul shows up

-Meanwhile, Padme and Naboo soldiers battle droids in the palace while there’s a battle outside the droid control ship

-Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan battle Maul in the power generator and it ends with only Obi-Wan escaping alive

-Obi-Wan gets on that red ship (that didn’t get blown up) and destroys the control ship from the inside (instead of Anakin going into a war)

I know this would take some VFX but I think it would work

I like the idea of Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon battling Darth Maul inside the Droid Control Ship. It would be reminiscent of Luke battling Vader and Sidious aboard the second Death Star.

This won’t be happening anymore. The control ship battle will be moved to the beginning.

HansiG said:

Spiderman 3 - 3 stars
The Amazing Spiderman 2 - 2 stars

TASM 2 is by no means a good movie but really? At least TASM 2 had more emotional scenes and better action then spiderman 3

that clip is really good! I’d love to see all of them done. If you do the snow speeder chase, I’ll try to improve the special effects in it and add some music, it could turn out really good

I love what you’re doing with the race but IMO it’s still way too long. I gets bring after about six minutes and drones on too long. Just my thoughts

HansiG said:

https://youtu.be/2Pokq-a_Edw?t=3m19s

I love it!

Sheepish said:

So, I was going to keep this scene a bit under wraps until the release, but I really would like some insight. It’s the full-length podracing sequence. It’s been 100% rescored. The two-headed announcer is gone. Padme’s voice has been pitch-corrected to make her appear slightly younger. Lots of restructuring (too much to list right now).

But the biggest change comes in after the 7 minute mark. I won’t say what it is…just let me know what you think.

This is one of my favorite changes in this edit, and I just want to see what some of you think of it. The SFX needs some polishing (most of it has been recreated), but it’s nearly 100%

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcsiqIzXwx0&feature=youtu.be

The video’s blocked 😦

Try vimeo instead, they never block anything.

So for my edit, since General Grievous will be Darth Maul brought back, his eyes don’t match up wit the previous movie. Is anyone willing to change his eyes in either TPM or ROTS? I think it would look better if his eyes were different in ROTS but it’d probably be easier to do in TPM.

Could you upload a clip of the romance montage? I’ve been working on one myself and I’d like to see what you’ve done.

adywan said:

He did an interview over the phone. He asked me about what i did for a living and i said that i was unemployed due to health reasons. It did seem at times that he was trying to get me to say that it was a disability, but i never said that i was disabled. It was hard to understand him at times

Stuff like this makes me hate the media more and more

CHEWBAKAspelledwrong said:

http://originaltrilogy.com/user/Something-Something/id/26167

Thank god