logo Sign In

Sluggo

User Group
Members
Join date
29-Sep-2004
Last activity
24-Jun-2018
Posts
6,820

Post History

Post
#215730
Topic
The legendary "Starkiller Ranch" Thread
Time
HOLY CRAP!! that would rock!!

*deep breath*

One of the things I would like to see with such a project (aside from its own thread) is a detailed commentary track explaining why perhaps why you went with certain creative decisions and maybe a special feature with side by side Episode 3 shots and any any corrosponding 40's and 50's noir/serial feature shots. Mostly, I just would like to see this often influence on the Star Wars movies paid its due instead of largly ignored. Maybe that's just me. Or maybe this is too much. Eep.
Post
#214402
Topic
The legendary "Starkiller Ranch" Thread
Time
CC: The films already open with sequential Star Destroyer scenes. Opening with 2 DS shots doesn't seem like a big deal. Besides, It could create a bit more urgency for the Rebellion. I have always thought the DS was way underplayed in ROTJ. The idea in the Novel of the DS destroying Endor pretty cool. I guess I'm one of those who see the parallelism between the films as poetic rather than pointless.

I like Guy's idea of the DS protecting the capitol.
Post
#212635
Topic
Star Wars: George's Original Vision (The Lost Cut)
Time
this is turning into the Starkiller Ranch. And I'm dang sure the Death Star battle was originally part of George's original plan. The line gets blurred because Fox executives were pushing George to drop the battle as the film was already overbudget without it.

Anyways...

I am looking forward to this edit. I have always wanted an edit based on the book or shooting script. This edit looks to be the closest so far (excepting Deleted Magic of course). One of the scenes I've always been curious about is a small fragment from the published draft of the script.

INT. SANDCRAWLER - HOLD AREA

It is dim inside the hold area of the Sandcrawler. Artoo switches on a small floodlight on his forehead and stumbles around the scrap heap. The narrow beam swings across rusty metal rocket parts and an array of grotesquely twisted and maimed astro-robots. He lets out a pathetic electronic whimper and stumbles off toward what appears to be a door at the end of the chamber.


INT. SANDCRAWLER - PRISON AREA

Artoo enters a wide room with a four-foot ceiling. In the middle of the scrap heap sit a dozen or so robots of various shapes and sizes. Some are engaged in electronic conversation, while others simply mill about. A voice of recognition calls out from the gloom.

THREEPIO
Artoo-Detoo! It's you! It's you!

A battered Threepio scrambles up to Artoo and embraces him.



The script has 2 rooms in the sandcrawler, but the final edit has one. It would be interested to see if this footage could be seperated. I tried to get Garrett to look into this shot for Deleted Magic, but it never happened.
Post
#208817
Topic
Star Wars DVD Covers
Time
Was there new art for the '05 set? I never bothered to find out.

I figure they might add some new covers since these have some kind of insignificant bonus disc that some fans might be interested in. Besides, they need to give the completists something to live for. And really, new covers can only be a good thing. Like they could get any worse.