logo Sign In

Sluggo

User Group
Members
Join date
29-Sep-2004
Last activity
24-Jun-2018
Posts
6,820

Post History

Post
#299936
Topic
Would you give up ESB in exchange for...?
Time
I couldn't decide. This is hypothetical time machine stuff. The problem is that now I have read way too many crappy EU novels and seen the prequels that I can't judge accurately.

The tough thing is, Empire is a wonderful, brilliant film and a worthy sequel. The problem is that Star Wars (as it was envisioned and filmed in '77) is too self contained for a sequel. Making Vader into Luke's father was a necessary change to make a sequel (at least to make it interesting, at any rate) but it did so at the cost of changing the original story.
Post
#299914
Topic
How did you envision the prequels?
Time
Someone named borgmatrix summarized the problem of time wasted in the prequels quite nicely:

Lucas could have done better service to the material if he would have found a way to increase the Anakin/Obi-wan screentime.

Look at ROTS. There's a lot of stuff he had cut/dropped in order to give the needed to time to Anakin and his fall. He could have lessened the time devoted to Anakin's fall in order to incorporate more Padme scenes, or to develop the Rebellion subplot, or get Boba Fett in there, or whatever. But he didn't, and ROTS was about as good as it could have been given the time contraints. He gave focus to what mattered most.

Now, if only he would have done that with the TPM and AOTC. Lucas himself has admitted that about 60% of the prequel story he had envisioned was in ROTS and only about 20% each over TPM and AOTC. By his own account TPM and AOTC are each about 80% filler. Because of that, ROTS was harder for him than he'd initially thought. He had less time to fit in everything he would have wanted. If he would have approached TPM and AOTC with more urgency and tried to make the best use of the time and space he had to tell the prequel story, these movies would have been better for it, including ROTS.

By doing more with the Anakin/Obi-wan relationship over TPM and AOTC, he would have saved himself the need to play catch-up in ROTS and given himself (and the movie) more breathing room. All three movies would have been more balanced and complete if he'd spread the plot out more evenly between them.
Post
#299906
Topic
SW fonts
Time
I don't know about the end credits yet (specifically),,,

But this was used in the early ads and logos, particularly the first trailer for Star Wars:
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a117/Sluggomatic2000/Fonts/77trailer.jpg

Infact, when Suzy Rice was designing the now familiar Star Wars logo, she based it on the Helvetica Black font.

Oh, and here's what Times New Roman looks like. It is close to the Jedi logo, but not quite.
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a117/Sluggomatic2000/Fonts/TimesNewRoman.jpg
Post
#299779
Topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 <strong>REVISITED</strong> ADYWAN *<em>1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION</em>
Time
Ady, that is a crazy amount of work shown there.

A quick question...

I don't know if it is a continuity error or something else, but it appears that there is a discrepency in the grime and dirt on the panel where the restraining bolt is attached to R2. The Tantive IV shots show R2 with a relatively clean panel. The Tatooine footage has the panel much darker with a spot already wiped off for the bolt even before he is captured by the Jawas. More of me being nit-picky, but is seems that the wiped of area shouldn't appear until after he gets the bolt. This make sense? I'm not at home so I can't post any screencaps.
Post
#299664
Topic
anyone reading the eu novel death star?
Time
The Sifo-Dyas issue is the EU writers having to clean up what George messed up. IIRC, the character was originally named Sido-Dyas, and would have been Darth Sidious posing as a Jedi Council Member to order the army. But this might have too obvious to the Jedi or the audience, so George made some changes and Sido was changed to Sifo. Jango was then introduced into the mix as being recruited by Tyrannus on the moons of Bogden to account for the creation of the clones and to legitimize the newly created character of Sifo-Dyas, who was now a legitimate Jedi who still might have ordered the clones and [insert murky plot here].

This created the biggest plot-hole of episodes 2 &3. By the middle of AOTC, Obi-wan Kenobi knew that Jango Fett was affilliated with both the cloners of Kamino as well as the makers of the droid armies of Geonosis. And that doesn't sound suspicious to anyone?
Post
#298795
Topic
Anything? Anything At All? (that is remotely positive or good about the SE and PT?)
Time
The inclusion of 'monomix' elements was pretty cool.

I did like how they attempted to clean up some of the original effects. Too bad the matte lines were still there on a lot of space shots and some of the snowspeeder cockpits were still transparent.

The Falcon blasting out of Docking bay 94 was something I enjoyed. The new sandcrawler footage was cool too.
I liked seeing a bit more of the Slave 1 in Empire.
And I was thrilled to hear no more of the 'yub-nub' song in Jedi. The end of the coolest movies ever and we get singing teddy bears. I've always hated that.

The rest of the changes were either a distraction or just different (and therefore unnecessary) from the original.