logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Members
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#678517
Topic
What do you HATE about the EU?
Time

Tack said:

The only thing I hate about the EU are the forced ties between the OT and PT. Granted, some things deserve exploration (Leia's relationship with Bail Organa), but some later books have contradictory stuff just to give the OT a closer tie to the prequels. For instance, there exists one EU novel out there where it's stated that R2 recorded that conversation Anakin and Padme had about his nightmares, and then he plays it for Luke. 

R2's kind of nosey, if that's true. I mean, unnecessarily recording a private conversation? That's kinda weird.

 Was Artoo even present when that scene took place?

Post
#678241
Topic
Bring Back Ric!
Time

Alas, mods are not omniscient. If anyone has proof Mr. Olie the 2nd is a sock, kindly provide it to the mods. Anybody maintaining a sock account at this point is taking a calculated risk. Is it really worth it?

AFAIK, nobody was given special permission for anything, certainly not from me. Joke socks were likely tolerated so long as they were obvious, and didn't stink up serious threads. It takes just one or two people to piss in the pool and ruin it for everyone.

Post
#678160
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

Bingowings said:

Coraline (2009).

It's inevitably not an accurate depiction of the darkness of the source material but it's still pretty dark stuff for an animated film primarily aimed at children.

The voice acting is good and the animation style is bold.

If you want explain Gnosticism to your kids it's probably the easiest way.

4 Balls.

 Definitely the darkest plot twist I've ever seen in a kid's movie. And the main reason I scream hysterically when a commercial comes on for those creepy button eyed dolls. ;)

Why the heck haven't I bought this on Blu Ray yet?

Post
#677970
Topic
A Christmas Carol Adaptation Discussion Thread
Time

Tried watching a little bit of the Carrey version on ABC family tonight, but the creepy dead eyed CGI characters are just as unsettling as they were in The Polar Express. When is Robert Zemeckis going to get off this motion capture zombie kick?

That sound you hear is Mr. Dickens rotating in his coffin...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2hfre4eBCY8

Although, if ACC was under copyright, someone else would be pimping it out some other way.

Post
#677829
Topic
A Christmas Carol Adaptation Discussion Thread
Time

Never even heard of the 2001 version. (And I've seen a lot of obscure versions.) How does the George C. Scott version rate for accuracy?

The 1970 musical Scrooge gets extra points from me for Alec Guinness as Marley, and Ebeneezer's brief visit to his own personal hell. Although I think someone involved in the production was projecting their personal kinks just a tad...

The Mickey Mouse version gets a little disturbing, since the Little Pigs are in the cast, yet a roast pig is seen in a holiday feast. What the hell?