logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Members
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#715408
Topic
Practical vs Digital
Time

TheBoost said:

I personally have a preference for practical effects, but always reject the notion that CGI is cheaper, lazier, faster, or somehow requires less artistry or craftsmanship.

 The problem is that the money men in Hollywood see CGI as better, faster, cheaper. Even if it's not actually true in practice, the suits believe it. A portion of Men In Suits covered how many creature performers had a long dry spell when producers saw CGI as the solution to every problem.

Post
#715405
Topic
Practical vs Digital
Time

A bit hard to know if you'll like a movie until you pay to see it though.

The Hobbit conundrum is easily solved by seeing the 24fps version. There still aren't a whole lot of theaters that can show 48fps yet. If Jackson is the only one pushing to shoot in the format, it will end up an interesting footnote in cinema history.

Post
#715347
Topic
So....did Grievous know that Palpatine was Sidious?
Time

brentspender said:

I never thought grevious knew about palpating. I always took him to be like those others dooku manipulated. Just the two who we're sith knew is what I thought. 

 Grevious never struck me as the sharpest knife in the drawer. Smart henchmen who aren't fooled by you wearing a hood and keeping your face in perpetual shadow are too much of a liability anyway.

Not sure I want to know what palpating is. ;)

Post
#715245
Topic
Practical vs Digital
Time

Okay, nobody is on a crusade against Peter Jackson here. We're not all plugged into every aspect of the Hobbit's production.

And speaking as someone with a little costuming experience, if the masks were causing the actors breathing difficulties and safety issues, then they were poorly designed. I'll bet this didn't happen on the LOTR films.

And if you don't understand why some of us have issues with CGI that does convince the eye it's a living breathing creature, you've missed one reason this site even exists.