Siliconmaster482

Sure, sent a pm your way!

wonderwhy said:

I’d appreciate a link to this edit when you have a moment, sounds like the best III out there from the rave reviews!

Link sent, enjoy!

Cinefy said:

C3PO & R2D2 Theme - During memory restoration concept

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymD9W2_XCtA

Aw, I love that!

Love that rearranged opening, though I really wish there were some way to reveal the ships without them magically emerging from the ground. Likewise I’d forgotten how much I immediately facepalm at “Somehow, Palpatine has returned” line, as others have mentioned. Not much possible for either of those I’d guess.

It’s too bad Boolio’s shot is so quick, but I agree it doesn’t make sense to make it awkward, even if that does seem to be the best place to add in some attempts at retconning the fleet.

idir_hh said:

Hello there,
https://vimeo.com/414116878

It’s taken originally from the trailer but I used Samuel Kim’s extended version https://youtu.be/V-O7HXXHcBs

Oh drat, so there’s no second half of the phrase? Well at least it’s an indicator of what sounds like it fits that environment.

Hal 9000 said:

It’s too bad footage had to be reversed in order to get enough room. I think finding some alternate source for a choir belting out those notes, maybe with a little less gusto, would help make it feel diagetic to that moment.

I agree though, it’s a natural idea for that moment.

Absolutely agreed. It’s great to get the full music phrase in there, but the version that General Kenobi posted definitely sounds more diagetic. Perhaps as a result of it sounding like the choir is fully diagetic, and the trumpets sounding like they’re in the soundtrack supporting the in-room choir.

I’m just glad you’ll be around to help wrangle TRoS into something watchable. I got burnt out on my edit and that was only one! You deserve a nice rest after all that you’ve done for the community.

Pm sent!

Done! 😄

Sure, sent you a link!

Pm sent!

Absolutely! Link is in your inbox.

Sure, sent you a link!

PM sent!

Filoni gets huge props for giving us stories that support ROTS so much better than it could ever stand on its own. It definitely helps shift the perspective from “one day things were fine and a few days later everyone was dead” to “the entire galaxy was ready for a governing and power shift, and it’s the events of ROTS that really just push it over the edge.”

With Clone Wars finally complete, it feels like we have a solid setup for the movie.

Watching the last 4 episodes together was absolutely incredible. Best Star Wars experience I’ve had in a long time.

I had to laugh that the one scene where they made a direct ROTS scene connection (the holographic briefing) was one of the scenes that both Hal and I replaced with an earlier deleted scene. So any attempt to use our edits in a broader multi-edit would probably require cutting the initial duplicate ROTS lines and starting right as Ahsoka walks in.

ZaneFlare92 said:

I’m very interested in this.

Sent you a link as well!

I’m guessing the increased interest is due to everyone being stuck inside. Stay safe!

Sure, sent you a pm!

Link is in your inbox!

Sent you a message too! Always happy to share my work.

Sent!

While I can see the merits (and emotional weight) of Obi-Wan welcoming Luke, I felt perfectly satisfied in theaters. Luke has done a 180, faced his demons, used all his force powers to save those he loves, and floats away into the Force he has cut himself off from for so long. Personally I don’t need it spelled out for me, it’s right there to be seen and felt.

Sure, sent you a PM!

Keep the slow mo shot!

That’s pretty goddamned great, nice work!

For me, “at last” would work in the context of “you’ve finally shed your last burdens, snoke is dead, skywalker is dead, and Rey has left you behind.” Personally I can’t quite hear it as it stands (I was going to say it would only work subtly until I realized you’d already put it in there).

However, I’d be fine with this version as is.