Peonthegrate

Hal 9000 said:

• Anything else we can do about the dagger? And I wonder about reinstating it being depicted as her parents’ murder weapon; it was removed to allow for greater clarity that it can mystically reveal directions to the wayfinder.

I realize this might not be a popular thought, but as I watched Ascendant with a ‘fresh’ mind the other day, I felt that it wasn’t quite clear enough in depicting how the dagger was leading Rey to the Wayfinder unless you were already aware of the behind-the-scenes change made for this edit.

Perhaps if some sort of effect was added to it, especially on Endor / DS2 it could be made more clear what’s happening. In the Clone Wars, when Savage Opress found Darth Maul, the necklace given by Mother Talzin functioned similarly to the way the dagger operates in Ascendant, however it had a clear visual effect on the necklace when he approached Maul.

As seen here - > https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZfwl5VK4Nc

Is there a changelog for Episode 3?

Yes agree, also would love some of those AI lines TBH

Id be very interested in this if persued!

Agree completely

Would love a link!

I absolutely think the movie should explain it, and I love the image in the Jedi Texts and the additional line already done for the snake.

I actually do like that, curious what others think

I’m also a fan for the saber breaking in the vision as others have stated.

Jar Jar Bricks said:

I for one think the only hole that needs patching in TLJ is Holdo. There is a clearly ADR dialog spoken when she says “I’ve dealt with plenty of trigger happy flyboys like you.”

The idea would be to replace that with something like “But there could be a First Order informant on board.”

So the whole thing would go as follows: “Of course you do. I understand. But there could be a First Order informant on board. You’re impulsive, dangerous, and the last thing we need right now. So stick to your post, and follow your orders.”

I do agree with this or atleasy something like this. That holdo is the main thing that needs fixing left in TLJ, though that may be for another edit like Hal said.

I’m a bit fond of it being “struggled with her bloodline”. References the bloodline book which is cannon.

Looks incredible!

Jar Jar Bricks said:

Yeah, so my very crude method of making these tests (just ripping out the relevant portion of the center channel) really shows it’s flaws here. You can hear an audible cutout because her crackling saber in the background goes away. But I’m assuming this wouldn’t be too hard to fix while editing. Here’s a rough test of how this might sound:

https://youtu.be/g3qMrIL_Brk?si=mAzjq88Vrzxdqqy1

Wow I really like this quick simple fix

I like the idea, I would be interested in seeing other ways of wording it though. I wouldn’t know what those other ways would be though lol

I do echo the others in saying I think that keeping more Boba content would be worthwhile as your previous edits had personally.

I personally think the clone line is very necessary for the film for average viewers IMHO.

Would like a new link if possible too! Thanks!

I’m aware, I’m just listing what I viewed as higher priority than the others that are planned.

Well if you’re taking suggestions.

I’d like to see perhaps a few extended versions, those being Umbara, The Death of Obi Wan Kenobi, Slaves of Zygerria, and It may require making an entirely new episode, but I’d love for more Ryloth content as that plotline to me felt the most rushed in the show.

For new episodes (If you’re taking requests) I’d love to see the Younglings Crystal arc in this, and Grevious Intrigue.

Also I could be crazy, but to me it looks like near the end of the S4E05 - Deliverance, that the audio sync is a little off. This could be me taking crazy pills though.

EDIT: If taking episode requests would also enjoy seeing the Zilo Beast (If that’s something you’re interested in)

Looks very interesting! Excited to see the full release of the project when it’s completed!

Jar Jar Bricks said:

EDIT: FINALLY replicated it with the new line - https://youtu.be/4OoYAj4iFcM

This is the best one ive seen so far! I’m no audio editor, but it perhaps could have slightlyyyyyy a bit more of a deeper tone, not sure if this can be done with sperate software or not though.

I think the previous voice sounded better aswell

I realllllyyyy like the line “You’re just a ghost, in a rotting shell” or something very close to that. I think even with the vats of Palpatine clones a line like this is needed.

Would like a link whenever!

Jar Jar Bricks said:

Ah right I’m familiar with that method I mod Skyrim a lot. I think it got a v3 update recently but it’s still noticeably robotic.

same lol