Sign In

Peonthegrate

User Group
Members
Join date
3-Mar-2021
Last activity
22-Jan-2022
Posts
95

Post History

Post
#1456511
Topic
The Force Awakens: Starlight (Released)
Time

Absolutely amazing release, and certainly is the best version of TFA I have ever seen by a long shot.
I do have some minor notes/criticisms, which I feel dirty just saying because of how well done this edit is.

  1. You can slightly hear the very end of Hans cut line right at 41:58-41:59 when he previously told Rey and Finn to “get out of there”.

  2. when Kylo is looking at Starkiller base drain the sun at 01:30:11, the reflection of the Sun on his helmet is red, but I feel like it should be more orange, closer to the sun.

  3. I love the added sith whispers to Rey throughout the movie, however I feel that the whispers added to when Rey mindtricks the stormtrooper doesn’t quite work. As it doesn’t seem like she’d be tapping into the darkside there, and feels a little out of place compared to the other whispers added.

  4. This last note contradicts what I said previously about Rey’s Sith eyes months ago, but I think Rey’s sith eyes, while close to perfect, are slightly too brown/dull and could maybe glow slightly more. It’s a hard thing to balance for sure.

Post
#1454640
Topic
The Force Awakens: Starlight (Released)
Time

Amazing job! Like you said, seems like the only thing missing is the ambient sounds. Looking forward to the final product so much!

I know I’ve asked this before, but can’t remember the answer so sorry if you’ve answered it. But has the few “palpatine hints” that are in Hal’s version been added yet? Mainly the palpatine theme and his laugh in the vision sequence.

Post
#1454302
Topic
The Clone Wars: Refocused - RELEASED (to v2.0) up to S02E05. (I'd appreciate feedback on the new S02E02!)
Time

Good episode, however there is definitely some audio sync issues most notably from mouth sync. I believe the most off audio is around the 3:30 mark, you can easily tell that the mouth sync is off during this scene especially.

Another slightly off part of the episode for me was how it feels like the final note before the credits show ends a bit short. I’m not sure if there’s anyway to fix this though.