No that would be tonally wrong. There some issues in the movie, but I don’t think all of the darker ideas that were proposed would solve them.
You never saw Aliens? It’s incredible.
Anyway I’ve no time for this show, so I watched the above fan edit. It was pretty dull, but the laughable nonsense everyone got upset about was (mostly) excised. It reminded me of when I saw the Essential Edit of Indiana Jones 4. Less cringe but ultimately not good in any meaningful way.
Would that be with or without the kidnapped and tortured sex worker plots?
That kind of thing was pretty long time ago. They should do a proper discussion in their “re:View” series. Regular guests like Colin Cunningham are VFX artists and have the know-how to talk about stuff like that. Also some years ago they also had the director of People Vs George Lucas in an episode. If structured properly it might have some sort of impact. Then again they’d probably just prefer a drunken round table discussion of trash.
Superweapon VII said:
The OOT. That’s it. If the other stuff piques their interest, they can watch it at a friend’s house.
Harsh, but fair.
The idea that Qui-gon would have been a true mentor, and that whole Dual of the Fates thing, seems like an attempt to make TPM more interesting than it is. At best John Williams, as usual, was trying hard to elevate the material.
Whole thread title kinda speaks for itself I’d say.
Looks more expensive than Obiwan for some reason.
Yes I share your feelings, Ben should have been the one to go into the desert at the end. Since he’s basically the only character with a full arc. Too ambitious for a fan edit though.
Ah why not, I love some wummery occasionally.
Oh I already replied, that’s weird.
Uh, wait what I meant to say is, don’t give in to hate.
Sketched during the movie if I recall. May or may not be a true story of course.
I don’t even want to rewatch Rogue One.
She’s Princess of Alderaan not Princess of the Galaxy.
She tactfully diverted the question so that she could answer it another way, which is part of being an executive with that kind of responsibility. Elsewhere Pablo Hidalgo basically told everyone what we already guessed right? On Twitter somewhere iirc. In reality it’s only something that can be answered probably someone higher up at Disney rather than LFL.
It looks a lot darker than Mando and BOBF, which is something that I’m very on board with.
Your eyes can deceive you, don’t trust them.
Well okay, cool thanks for stopping by. I hope you’re not too sad that they’ve spent so much time burying the work of you and your colleagues.
For a sec I thought that John Williams was in full Ewok get-up
Looks like Mos Espa again tbh
Trilogies didn’t really exist before Star Wars though. At least not in the same fashion. It could have been series like Planet of the Apes where it just kept going until it ran out of steam entirely.
Anyway, on topic, no Vader as he was in SW originally should not have been shown in the PT.
Imagine if ‘you should not have come back’ was actually Vader referring to the Death Star. I mean why not. Throw in Palpatine, CGI Tarkin, CGI Leia.
The Book of Boba Fett 1985 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CseVAyj0PsU
Is “Star Wars: The Interactive Video Board Game” available in PAL?
This was a mess. A very stupid one that makes the whole creative team seem questionable. If they were going to be making him a leader instead of a killer, where’s the clever diplomatic resolution? Are we supposed to believe that this pathetic band kept out a huge force from a whole planet? Won’t they just move to another region? Why didn’t anyone lay explosives under the battle droids? There are so many baffling writing problems that we would be here all day. Sigh.
I would have settled for a revenge story. But so far I’m confused what he’s doing, or why Bib Fortuna… betrayed him somehow?