logo Sign In

Mark's Down On Your Syntax

User Group
Members
Join date
4-May-2016
Last activity
20-Jun-2025
Posts
608

Post History

Post
#960612
Topic
Rogue One * <em>Spoilers</em> * Thread
Time

Say it in a north of England accent. Imagine Wallace or Sean Bean saying, “That’s a Red 'Un, that is.” Red being rouge, and One being un.

That’s no moon, Gromit - it’s cheeese!

JEDIT: Now I’m dragging this thread off topic! I’m interested to hear your thoughts on if Tarkin will play a part in the movie. Let’s talk about that 😃

Post
#960171
Topic
General Star Wars <strong>Random Thoughts</strong> Thread
Time

I saw a rando YouTube video earlier, “My Star Wars collection - Vintage Stuff”. A good 85% of what she’s showing is Phantom Menace stuff. Yeah, I suppose it’s 17 years old at this point but… vintage? Way to go kid, now I feel like a proper old codger.

Also, she genuinely wonders if the term “sand people” is politically correct anymore. I’m too scared to check the inter webs to see if she’s the only one but please, don’t let this be a thing.

Post
#959816
Topic
Extended original cut of first film released way back?
Time

I believe that you strongly remember the event. I tried to make it clear that I wasn’t saying it didn’t happen. The fact is that if the scene was cut into the film, shipped to a theatre and shown then it was very likely a one-off (or close to it). An unintended error by Fox or the production team (?) The fact that nobody involved in the production has mentioned this scene being cut into the film on its original release to the public coupled with the fact that the Special Edition was used to allow them to get the scene cut in makes me think it’s more likely you’re misremembering. It’s not an attack on your memory or on you personally, nor is it me trying to bolster my “denial” about your recollections. We’re not having an argument here because neither one of us can do anything of value with our “side” of things.

But false memory syndrome is a reality, it’s hugely interesting to me and I think that reading up on the phenomena would be of interest to you too. As you can see from this thread you’ve been posting in, memories of things happening in Star Wars that might not have actually happened or that very few other people have seen is not uncommon!

I want you to be right, cinebird. I think it’d be brilliant if there was a rogue copy of Star Wars released that had the human Jabba scene in it. I wonder in forty years if people will be saying the same sort of things about The Force Awakens?!

Post
#959627
Topic
Extended original cut of first film released way back?
Time

Dek Rollins said:
I wouldn’t say the examples you two gave of your own are really comparable to having memories of whole scenes existing that are missing from the official cut (all of which are actual scenes that were filmed, not figments of imagination).

I can see what you’re getting at, Dek. The “size” of the memory really isn’t important though because it’s still a faulty mechanism that’s creating it to start with. The fact that the memories are of things which exist in one form or another actually reinforces the false memory.

The Jabba scene didn’t really come into the general consciousness unti the lead up to the Special Editions in 1996/97 and I’d be very suprised if cinebird’s memory of the scene predates that time. A briefly glimpsed photo, a half-remembered magazine article, a story told in an interview could all have combined into creating an impression of what the scene was and later solidified and cemented when the actual footage of the scene was shown in a 1997 documentary. Add to that the amount of times cinebird has likely seen the CG Jabba scene in the past nineteen years which further ties it into the rest of the movie and affects, by association, his “memory” of the initial, and likely most emotionally resonant, experience of it.

Have you heard of the Mandela effect, Dek? It’s worth reading about if you haven’t! (At least, I remember it being worth it.)

Post
#959501
Topic
Extended original cut of first film released way back?
Time

False memory syndrome is a real thing. There’s a lot of threads on this site where people discuss things they remember but didn’t (and in a lot of cases, couldn’t).

I can distinctly remember an X-Wing flying into the Death Star shields and exploding in Return of the Jedi when I saw it in a triple-bill showing nearly 30 years ago. I remember it happening and it’s a real memory. But it didn’t happen, ever.

As much as we human beings can rely on our memories we simply can’t trust them. They don’t work like video recordings and even established details in genuine occurrences are able to be changed, reordered or just plain invented after the fact.

Try remembering what colour socks you wore that day, exactly how many other people were in the theatre or how much the ticket cost. Try remembering practically anything from back then with as much absolute certainty as “human jabba was in the movie”.

I’m not saying there’s no chance you’re right - you could be, I wasn’t there - I’m just saying there’s a reeaaally strong chance you’re probably misremembering.

Post
#959496
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

I searched for “horror movies full” on YouTube and skimmed the results until a thumbnail tickled my fancy. I watched the movie. Then I clicked the next recommended video that was a full length movie. This is how I roll. I am living life to the fullest here.

First up, YouTube told me it was called “Unnatural” but the title onscreen was “Maneater”. It was made in 2015 and has the plot where a genetically engineered animal escapes and eats people, until it gets stopped. This one was set in the snow. They somehow managed to get James Remar, Graham Green, Ray Wise and Sherilyn Fenn to star in this. Poor Sherilyn has succumbed to the ravages of age and, owing to the fact that I’ve seen her in nothing but early to mid 90’s stuff before today, she was the scariest part of the entire movie.

I give it 1 Botox injection out of 5.

Next, a steaming pile of fetid putrescence masquerading as a movie - “The Hollow” (2015).

Three Emo teen sisters (or whatever Emos are called nowadays) go to live with their aunt on an island after their parents die. “It’s Halloween, and there’s a storm coming!” a worried local helpfully warns. The dialogue is expositional and stilted and the plot is belly-button fluff. The whole thing is bad and it’s about 40 minutes too long (a lot like this post.)

Despite clear evidence that the threat is supernatural everybody runs around with guns and shoots at it. Bizarrely, some of the locals survive by hiding in a large freezer - because apparently the vengeful spirit of a murdered witch just can’t deal with refrigeration equipment. A dog dives through a car window for no reason! EVERYTHING IS A JUMP SCARE!! The three teen leads are actually very good actresses and deserve better work in their careers than this tripe.

It’s so bad it’s actually kinda fun though so I’ll give it 2 and a half Canadian-tax-breaks out of 5.

What a wild Saturday night that was.

Post
#959462
Topic
The Place to Go for Emotional Support
Time

Mike, when you said you put the phone upstairs to eat I totally read it the wrong way, “Why doesn’t his phone eat at the table?”, I thought.

I hope your birthday, at the very least, doesn’t entirely suck and if you can grab even a moment of calm then you damn well consider it a happy day. Don’t dwell on it when you slip or when you’re fighting the urges - dwell on the times when you don’t. It’s not about beating your problems or being fully in control it’s about not letting them rule you ALL the time. One second of time when you’re not giving in is worth a day full of slips.

Please keep fighting, Mike. There’s a lot of people here who care about your wellbeing.

Post
#959197
Topic
All Things Star Trek
Time

Bloody lawyers. They had a real opportunity here to embrace fan creations and get a two-way relationship going. But they obviously decided that the “we make, you buy, we make again, you buy again” model was the way to go.

No matter how many fan films or edits or YouTube compilation videos are out there it’s never going to stop fans seeking out, and purchasing, the official versions. The more people are talking about something, original or not, the better for the brand it is.

The people who make knock-offs or try to make a profit selling fan creations aren’t going to stop because they have no compunction about breaking the rules to start with.

Post
#959194
Topic
The Measurement Thread
Time

I live in England, where we seem to be stuck in this frustrating mix of metric and imperial measurement.

We use miles almost exclusively for long distances (no road signs have kilometres) but feet and meters interchangeably for anything shorter. Depending on who you’re speaking to, and it really doesn’t seem to an age or class thing (at least where I live), you have to adjust which you use because people tend to get a bit funny with you if you use the “wrong” one.

For example, when people buy tobacco the vast majority ask for it in imperial weight - even though the packaging is 100% metric. It’s a very odd combination of ways of measuring and must be even more confusing for the young’uns.

Don’t even get me started on what happens when you go from Northern Ireland to Southern Ireland - daftness.

It doesn’t really matter which you use but I wish they’d just pick one and run with it.

Post
#958976
Topic
Last movie seen
Time

“Child’s Play 3” (1991)

I’ve never seen a Chucky movie before and this was on the telly so I thought I’d give it a watch.

It wasn’t as bad as I imagined it would be. The character of Chucky is actually rather charming and self-aware. It had a ridiculously convoluted load of old twaddle driving the movie forward at an entertaining pace. It had cute little Justin Whalen from Lois and Clark in it. It had some really awesome visual effects too.

I was amused and had fun, and I’d happily sit through another one. How many of these did they make?

I give it 3 demon dolls out of 5.

Post
#958964
Topic
BEAUTIFUL WOMEN NEW RULES IN FIRST POST (NSFW) UPDATED RULES
Time

This thread is called "Beautiful Women" not "Sexy Pieces of Ass I Wanna Tap".

It could be about beautiful animals or flowers or clothes or anything! It’s people sharing their opinions on what they find attractive. Honesty, have you been around the Internet, YHWX? The fact that everybody here just posts a picture and pays a compliment in a respectful way says a lot about the general character of the people we have here.

There’s far worse places on the net (which you can easily find) to start asserting yourself against what you think you’re seeing here.

People like things that they find attractive. You like things that you find attractive too. It’s perfectly okay for you to not advertise or share your tastes regarding other human beings but it’s very rude and, dare I say, self-righteous, to repeat a contrary opinion that wasn’t asked for in this thread over and over.

There is no difference between a thread where we express a preference for a movie and a thread where we express a preference for a lady. There just isn’t!

I like you, YHWX, you have a good sense of humour and you’re clearly intelligent. I hope you stick around on this site, because heaven knows we need people like you here, but I wish you’d use a bit more tact sometimes.

All said with a happy face though, it just doesn’t sit well with me when I see people picking the wrong fight 😃