This user has been banned.
I mean yeah he can be an ass at times but he wouldn’t stoop to that level.
Thanks?
Anytime buddy. And don’t worry we’re two peas in a pod you and I.
But Luke is not the representative of an interstellar threat. He’s not in charge of an army. Kylo Ren is. Both characters are so different you can’t compare.
We can if we let go of this double standard we have on heroes and villains having to be on completely different wave lengths. Also we also need to acknowledge what type of villain Kylo Ren is in TFA so that when he evolves in the later films we can relish the change in his temperament.
“Long before we had this title, the idea of The Force Awakens was that this would become the evolution of not just a hero, but a villain,” Abrams said. “And not a villain who was the finished, ready-made villain, but someone who was in process.”- JJ Abrams
Poe’s joke stays. I liked that bit
Good, no need to suck the fun out of a Star Wars film.
MalàStrana said:
I believe the first act to be Kasdan’s (because it’s really close to what him, Lucas and Kurtz had in mind when they talked about REVENGE OF THE JEDI and the sequel trilogy)
It’s also the best part of the film so even on that basis alone I would agree.
and the second and third acts to be JJ’s. We’ll know the truth in a decade or so.
And I also believe that some of the sloppiness of the 3rd act is due to JJ. I doubt it was Kasdan’s idea to have R2 conveniently wake up when the plot needed to. Though I should be used to plot conveniences in Star Wars by now since all of them suffer from them.
He gets jealous when someone is more insufferable than him and tries his best to get him banned. So just ignore him.
I don’t remember Frink ever talking about a member’s disabled kids on this forum. I mean yeah he can be an ass at times but he wouldn’t stoop to that level.
I still would advise against cutting all of Kylo Ren’s rage scenes just like I would advise cutting all of the dialogue in which Luke whines in STAR WARS and ESB. It would hurt the arc of the characters assuming of course Kylo matures throughout the trilogy like Luke it.
MalàStrana said:
At least you should cut the line about Kylo who should finish his training, otherwise why would he have appointed him second in command of the fleet?
Maybe because there are no other Jedi with the exception of Skywalker so all Kylo would be doing is fighting non Force Sensitives should combat ever ensue. And his scene where he stuns Rey on Takodana shows he’s more than competent at deflecting blaster bolts.
Are you going to remove Poe’s joking during his arrest ?
I hope he doesn’t. Perfectly sets the tone for the film.
MalàStrana said:
(I would have added “And Kasdan to write it”, but since TFA I’m not sure the guy is still the great screenwriter he once was)
He co wrote it with JJ so whatever you feel regarding TFA would not be entirely his “fault”
And i hope they find another main character actress.
She is kind of plump.Oh look. Another 2016 registrant is a piece of garbage.
What the hell happened to this site? Is it just the influx of TFA trolls? General influx of members since TFA, resulting in a higher than average troll count?
Immediately after the film’s release, we had a number of new Stormfront-esque members complaining about black people, so I’m guessing it’s the former.
I also thing this semi wave of Prequel apologists have something to do with this as well.
GL should have invited Irvin Kershner to direct this one.
Damn man…
Well I plan on keeping those, more like what Finn says “have a boyfriend? Cute boyfriend?” Or maz saying “where’s my boyfriend!” Also I may trim the “Who’s in charge now phasma” a little
Idk, I liked the ‘cute boyfriend’ joke, but the others I can understand. Just please for the love of god leave Chewie talking to the rebel doctor, I thought that bit was hilarious.
I think the “cute boyfriend” thing was going a bit too far but him asking if she had a boyfriend in general was funny. As was the Chewie doctor bit.
That_OT_Ruler said:
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x42wipg
X-Wing Assault on Starkiller Base - The Phantom Menace Music
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x42x58s
Battle at Maz’s Castle - The Empire Strikes Back Music
Music doesn’t work as well in this scene though and I still don’t like the idea of making Finn absolutely pitiful at using a lightsaber when he already sucked at it in the first place. If I know I couldn’t swing the thing I would not use it against a Dark Side Warrior at a later time. Especially when I can grab a blaster.
Also as soon as you do the music for the opening scene, the scene in the Forest where Kylo Ren captures Rey, and Han’s death post them because those scenes are where the original soundtrack was at it’s strongest in my opinion. And I know this edit doesn’t exactly seem like my cup of tea seeing as how I liked TFA but I’m kind of looking forward to seeing your take on it.
And here I thought you had already seen that post…Do what must be done Lord Siver.
I’m still not sure preserving a “twist” that we all knew was coming before the film came out is worth it imo.
Other than the weird change in the audio it kind of works. The conversation after the whole Star Killer thing is vague though.
https://vimeo.com/162007178/ Kylo and lor san teka password is tfa
That’s pretty much exactly what I’m doing minus the “You’re so right”
Now we need to see the scene with Kylo and Snoke talking about Han having BB-8 and the Awakening in The Force. If it’s in there.
Bingowings said:
He also wore the same clothes after he died while Anakin wore almost identical clothes to him as a ghost despite never knowly wearing them while he was alive.Work that one out smarty pants :-p
Don’t make him whip out the novelization of an early script on you. You don’t want those problems.
Maybe it happened too fast but the writing around how he found the Falcon was sound.
Great…the film hasn’t even come out yet and people are already calling the lead a Mary Sue. Next people will be calling Episode VIII a rehash of ESB before the fucking concept art get’s leaked.
theMaestro said:
It was a bit too convenient that Rey & Finn just happened to run into Han Solo in the middle of space.
Han tracked them and his ability to track them (and knowing that the First Order would undoubtedly do it too) is why he sought out Maz.
Says it’s blocked 😦
I like the idea of your edit and would like to see a more detailed list of what you’ll be doing but the timestamp on the deleted scenes sucks you straight out of the film. And imo the scene is not good enough for such a drawback.
Do you have any problems with the OT?
If that happens I’d feel bad for those who threw their receipts in the garbage.
imperialscum said:
How is it good for me?Maybe you’re one of these people now a days who lives to hate things and if so this will be a thing you can add to your list. Assuming of course you’re one of these people.
No, I live to like things (those that I can like of course).
I’m glad that you’re not one of them. Unwarranted hatred of things that don’t deserve it and being a contrarian is so played out now.
I’m sorry TFA wasn’t to your liking and I hope Episodes VII & IX are films you can enjoy.
Imagine how much better PT Fanedits would be if we could separate dialogue from music and sound effects.
I don’t think this would help much.
Perhaps but they would be a lot more presentable.