logo Sign In

JoyOfEditing

User Group
Members
Join date
27-Jan-2025
Last activity
5-May-2025
Posts
148
Web Site
https://www.youtube.com/@JoyofEditing

Post History

Post
#1645273
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

G&G-Fan said:

Color-matching the ESB Imperial scenes to match the stark black look of the ANH Death Star

I’m probably gonna stick with switching the Death Star to the ESB colors, because then the Imperial look will be consistent across the OT, but now you’ve got me curious to see what aNH’s idiosyncratic colors would make Empire footage look like. . . If I get a chance today, I’ll play around with it and post the result.

Post
#1645105
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

JoyOfEditing said:

HAPPY STAR WARS DAY!!! - Here’s my recut of the Bespin Duel from tESB in the style of the Prequel fights: https://youtu.be/WCWVJhDJyhA

In other news, I finished the script for 4.2 of the Editing Show, so if work doesn’t get to crazy, the next proper episode should drop next week.

Speaking of Episode 4.2, I’ve been working on trying to match the Death Star Scenes with the Imperial “look” from Empire Strikes Back.

Here’s a comparison of happens when you color match the conference room with the Executor’s bridge:
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/12y0SU2SG173NqzlHLdyP_kH0RYhkycrO?usp=sharing

Post
#1644928
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

Bingowings said:

JoyOfEditing said:

Aloha!

My work schedule finally slowed down a bit, so I’ll be back to working on proper editing breakdowns later today, but in the meantime here is one of my favorite recut scenes from Attack of the Clones: https://youtu.be/ZaOsg-B0iqg

Enjoy the Edit!

-JoE

Between yourself and what SomethingStarWarsRelated was attempting to do I can see a fun watchable Star Wars peeping out. Be careful with cranking the contrast up too much. Some of the footage is very difficult to see at times. The action cuts are really good. Big plus being the lack of research rubbish changeling effects, even the name sounds stupid

Cheers! Yeah, the contrast is set correctly (to my tastes) in the source file, but YouTube’s compression system flattens all of the black information, and I don’t have the patience to develop a custom codec to make it happier (I just upload my custom HQ H.264 codec that I use for final renders). If you ever want to see the uncompressed HQ version of one of the clips, PM me, and I’ll shoot you a link. It still might be darker than you’d like, but I’m going for a dark look overall for compositing/aesthetic reasons (The darks hide effects seems and the contrast increases the perceived speed of the speeders + I’m taking inspiration from the look of the original Blade Runner).

On the changeling thing, I totally agree that it’s a distraction from the main plot. The fact that Zam is a changeling is interesting, I guess? But it has no bearing on either how she tries to kill Padme, or how she tries to escape from the Jedi. Personally, I think it’s WAY funnier if that final (and only in my cut) face shift is actually what a Kamino Saber Dart does to somebody when it hits them. I mean they are cloners after all, so developing a poison that causes instant and lethal genetic mutation is kinda on brand.

Post
#1644776
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

BedeHistory731 said:

The match cut (is that the right term?) between Anakin on the stretcher and Padme on the hearse might be my favorite touch in the whole sequence! You’ve done fantastic work in condensing the falling actions of III.

Technically it’s a “cut on form” (I only know that because my teacher at film school hammered all of those terms into our heads, haha!). I think I got the idea from seeing somebody else make a similar cut ages and ages ago on YouTube, but I can’t find it anymore. That hearse to hearse transition is so smooth, I can’t believe George didn’t use it in the original cut. Ending on two funerals sums up the tragedy of Revenge of the Sith really well in my opinion.

My favorite touch is the Necklace Transition to the Lars Homestead. I like the idea of Padme’s love for Anakin being symbolically passed on to Luke, since that love is what will bring balance to the Force in Return of the Jedi.

Post
#1644659
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

Yo! Quick Update:

I’m working on the script for Episode 4.2 of the Editing Show. I’m aiming for a STAR WARS day release, so we’ll see how that goes.

In the meantime, in honor of Revenge of the Sith’s 20th Anniversary, here’s my recut of the ending: https://youtu.be/YAsmcEc7cjI

The falling actions of Episodes I-II and VI-VI range between 2.5 and 5.5 minutes. Revenge of the Sith clocks in at just over 14mins. . . So this recut’s main goal is to align it with the rest of George’s SAGA, as well as to get rid of as many spoilers for the Original Trilogy as possible (The DEATH STAR, Tarkin, Darth Vader’s iconic suit, Leia is Luke’s sister [Padme dies after giving birth to Luke but before giving birth to Leia], Yoda and Ben’s exiles, etc.).

Lemme know what y’all think and enjoy the edit!

-JoE

Post
#1644000
Topic
HELP NEEDED: 5.1 Soundtrack for STAR WARS (1977 Cut)
Time

Hey y’all, this is a shot in the dark, but I was wondering if anyone had gone to the trouble of remastering the original, non-specialized audio track for STAR WARS in 5.1? The specific scene I need is the “Look Sir, Droids!” sequence, because I need the original music and timing.

Can anyone point me in the right direction?

Cheers!

-JoE

Post
#1643594
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

Rors said:

JoyOfEditing said:

Rors said:

JoyOfEditing said:

Aloha!

My work schedule finally slowed down a bit, so I’ll be back to working on proper editing breakdowns later today, but in the meantime here is one of my favorite recut scenes from Attack of the Clones: https://youtu.be/ZaOsg-B0iqg

Enjoy the Edit!

-JoE

Not from my taste, but everything you’ve been working has been incredible.

Cheers Buddy! What’s been your favorite scene so far?

I love the way you edited Obi-Wan and Anakin vs Dooku, it reminds me of “Dune: Part Two”. By the way, I also love the Droid Factory scene, even though, I wish you kept the scene where Obi-Wan talks with Dooku.
I will use some of your ideas to my own cut(When I have time).
And I agree with you, AOTC is great if it’s reedited.

Early on when I was breaking down which scenes I was gonna keep and which scenes I was gonna toss for Attack of the Clones, I took a long look at the Obi-Wan and Count Dooku scene, but just couldn’t find a way to use it, based on the way I reworked AotC as a whole. If you reinsert the Padme scene where she addresses the senate, the natural bookend to that scene is the other deleted scene where she’s interrogated by Dooku. My two cents is that the Padme Addresses the Senate Scene is ESSENTIAL to the plot of Attack of the Clones. It improves the sense of so many other sequences. In order to get the Obi-Wan and Count Dooku scene to work, you’d need an entirely different version of AotC to the one we got (and a totally different RotS). I think I’m with you, that that theoretical version of AotC would probably be a lot better, but at the end of the day, I’ve gotta work with the footage George gave us.

Post
#1643587
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

Rors said:

JoyOfEditing said:

Aloha!

My work schedule finally slowed down a bit, so I’ll be back to working on proper editing breakdowns later today, but in the meantime here is one of my favorite recut scenes from Attack of the Clones: https://youtu.be/ZaOsg-B0iqg

Enjoy the Edit!

-JoE

Not from my taste, but everything you’ve been working has been incredible.

Cheers Buddy! What’s been your favorite scene so far?

Post
#1643504
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

BedeHistory731 said:

Now that’s certainly better-paced! So much simpler than the overdone set piece from the original cut.

Don’t tell anyone. . . But I think Attack of the Clones is becoming my favorite STAR WARS film. . .

The writing/editing of original version is ABSOLUTELY BONKERS, but when you sit back and think about just how many cool sequences George crammed in there, it’s kinda mind-boggling.

Post
#1642665
Topic
STAR TOURS (1987) Restoration and Saving of the Original Movie Attraction (Released)
Time

oojason said:

JoyOfEditing said:

I’m well late to this party, but I’m looking for a HQ scan of the STAR TOURS main screen. Has anyone come across one in recent days?

I need it to fry Porkins properly: https://youtu.be/dJZC6yTDbyw

Cheers!

-JoE

darth_ender is likely the person to ask for that, mate. Knowledgeable and friendly bloke with a love for Star Tours - so definitely worth sending him a PM to see if he can help (or knows someone who can).
 

These may be of some use…

35 Years of Star Tours Adventures With D23 - Star Wars Celebration Anaheim 2022 - with some quality shots 39 minutes in.

STAR TOURS 1987 | 70mm Ride Film - though with annoying logos - could be worth asking the youtuber if he has the original logo-less source? It does appear to be decent quality…

Star Tours (1987) — Original Simulator Film - decent-ish quality (1080p60 according to youtube)

Cheers, Mate! I’ll drop Darth a line.

Some of the videos you linked are pretty good, but the real problemo is the YouTube compression. Phase3 pointed me in the STAR TOURS direction, and I reckon he can easily upscale a proper scan of the 70mm, even if it’s only 1080ish. However, if I can’t find a non-compressed version without frame blending it will be super tricky to line it up with the vanilla footage.

Thanks for all the help!

Post
#1642308
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

Hardened1337 said:

JoyOfEditing said:

FYI. If y’all missed the fun we were having recutting the “Duel with Dooku”, the full recut is now on YouTube: https://youtu.be/V0BDkajSyjU

Enjoy the Edit!

-JoE

Nice to see that you used the cut at that i found at when he picks up the lightsabers^^ Just a question, how long is your AOTC? I’m currently working on a 1 hour version, these videos gives me a lot of ideas, so thanks for making them 😃

Dang it! I knew I missed someone to give special thanks to! Sorry bro! I added your change to the description. I wish YouTube, would let me replace videos with minor alterations, but it is what it is. . . That was one of my favorite tweaks to the scene. Great job!

1 hour? Wow, that is ambitious! Mine is almost exactly 90 minutes, and so are all of the rest of my recuts of I-VI (except for III which comes in around 75mins - still feature length, baby!). I didn’t aim for a specific run time, but I found that STAR WARS films just seem to pace out beautifully at 90mins for some reason (especially Empire Strikes Back). I’m really curious as to how you’re gonna get it down to 1 hour. . . I don’t think I could find a way to do that.

My cut of Attack of the Clones is 99% done. I’m just doing little tweaks at this stage, so why don’t you pick the next sequence I upload. What would like to see?

Post
#1640959
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

jkimm said:

Haha, that was a horrendous scene. Fortunately there are enough good moments to salvage the film into something watchable. 😄

Did you make any major changes to the assassination worm and Coruscant chase?

Yeah, the Picnic Scene just before that bizarre frolic is actually one of the better written scenes in AotC, if you tweak it a bit.

Honestly, the thing that hurt me the most recutting Attack of the Clones was the slow realization of how close George was to making a great film. I found it shockingly easy to get the romance arc working (I thought it would be hard.), but once I figured out the three or so mistakes that George made across the whole film, and corrected them globally, the whole movie fell into place.

To answer your question, yes, I overhauled the whole front end of the movie. It would take too long to write out a full change list, but the basic gist is this. I recut Anakin and Obi-Wan as a great team with good banter, removing all of the whining and helicopter parenting. Anakin is especially reframed as being extremely talented, to make it believable that Padme falls for him. I also reworked Jango, so that the first time you see him is when he plugs Zam with the dart. That change ends the first act with a sense of forward momentum charging into the second act.

Post
#1640958
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

G&G-Fan said:

JoyOfEditing said:

For me it was Anakin getting trampled by s giant Tick-Cow while Padme does a photoshoot for the upcoming Renaissance Fair. . . That’s the point where I knew we were in trouble. . .

I hate the romance is much is the next guy but Padme’s dress in that scene is probably the most beautiful dress I’ve ever seen.

You’re not wrong. Padme’s whole wardrobe for the Prequels was ridiculously well designed. One of her best designs is in the deleted scene where she addresses the Senate. If I was the costume designer, I would have been SO TICKED when that scene got cut.

Post
#1640490
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

jkimm said:

JoyOfEditing said:

Yeah, these things definitely vary depending on peoples tastes. There are many parts that made me cringe in the theater 20+ years ago and have only gotten worse over time. I’ve never been a fan of characters making lighthearted jokes in the middle of a battle. It takes away any serious threat of them being in danger. Surprisingly, I’m fine with much of the humor in the original trilogy. I really appreciated you removing C3P0 and R2 dodging the crossfire in ANH though. haha

Interesting! That makes a bunch of sense. I think those quips don’t bother me so much, because I spent some time working in manufacturing, where you’re constantly in danger of getting killed by a forklift. One day your buddy would get sent to hospital with his leg cut open, the next day you’d be working beside your wingman and grab him by the vest as a forklift cleans out his mobile computer out from under him. I hate to admit it, but your first response in all of those moments is to crack a joke. The worse it is, the quicker you are to make a joke (none of which I can repeat here 😉).

I can relate and have used dark humor at inappropriate times too. 😊

As far as Anakin and Padme joking around, I wouldn’t mind as much if it occurred after the battle was winding down. Not a big deal - just personal preference. Of course, it’s not nearly as bad as C3P0’s head being swapped out with a battle droid and all that ensued. I almost walked out of the theater to demand a refund 😄

For me it was Anakin getting trampled by s giant Tick-Cow while Padme does a photoshoot for the upcoming Renaissance Fair. . . That’s the point where I knew we were in trouble. . .

Post
#1640475
Topic
New YouTube Series about recutting George's STAR WARS SAGA.
Time

Yeah, these things definitely vary depending on peoples tastes. There are many parts that made me cringe in the theater 20+ years ago and have only gotten worse over time. I’ve never been a fan of characters making lighthearted jokes in the middle of a battle. It takes away any serious threat of them being in danger. Surprisingly, I’m fine with much of the humor in the original trilogy. I really appreciated you removing C3P0 and R2 dodging the crossfire in ANH though. haha

Interesting! That makes a bunch of sense. I think those quips don’t bother me so much, because I spent some time working in manufacturing, where you’re constantly in danger of getting killed by a forklift. One day your buddy would get sent to hospital with his leg cut open, the next day you’d be working beside your wingman and grab him by the vest as a forklift cleans out his mobile computer out from under him. I hate to admit it, but your first response in all of those moments is to crack a joke. The worse it is, the quicker you are to make a joke (none of which I can repeat here 😉).