adywan said:
Janskeet, i've been reading a lot of what you are intending to do in your edit in this thread an others and many of the things have me completely baffled. you seem to be ripping the movie apart without any proper thought. For one, you mention the colour of the crawl to be too "orange" and that you prefer the ROTJ crawl colour. Well are you working on a colour calibrated monitor because if you are not you are not seeing the true colours of anything. The ROTJ crawl is horribly washed out. you also pointed out that the blue hue is missing form the cockpit windows. well it shouldn't be there at all anyway. you need to check to see just how thick the cockpit is and you will see that this is the thickness of the window frames and it is in shadow ( which has been tinted blue which you would see if you have a calibrated monitor).
there seems to be many things that you are taking out just because you don't understand them, which is a very bad mistake in my opinion.
Now i don't mind people using my edit for their own edits but its looking like your just going to rip it apart without any proper thought or understanding and with you doing it to something i put in a lot of time and effort to create i'm kind of concerned about this. You mention that you going to be changing some of the Fx shots too so you will have to learn to use an FX program like After Effects. Maybe you would be better off using the original Star Wars for this instead of my edit. If this is just going to be a personal project for yourself then fair enough, but if you intend to do all these things and then release it then, after seeing what you are intending to do, i would prefer it if you didn't use my edit for this.
Adywan, thanks for reminding me about the colour calibration. I thought my monitor was colour calibrated because I did it when I first got my monitor, but then I remembered that I reinstalled Windows XP on my computer 3 months ago so I need to recalibrate it. I think my monitor colours are still good though. I have a widescreen 1440 x 900 LCD Viewsonic. I happen to like the yellow color of the text in the ROTJ crawl. I know that is probably not what was deliberate or originally intended, but I like it that way and like what I said to ChainsawAsh (which pissed him off) that's the way I want it so I will make it that way for myself. I like the music timing in the ROTJ crawl too so I will change the crawl to move at the rate that is syncronized with ROTJ.
As far as the cockpit thing goes, I understand the thickness of the cockpit windows, but I think there should be more blue shining through the windows in that shot, but that is just my opinion.
I don't know what you think I'm doing that is "ripping it apart" it's mostly just enhancements of a few shots and a few removals of sounds and dialog.
I don't plan on making this edit for the public, but if I do, I will PM you it first either through rapidshare or youtube and you can approve of it before I give public acces to it. Fair enough? I want to use you version because the idea of this edit is to finish fixing all the continiuty erros left by you (not that there is a lot, or any of major importance) But this will probably never be finished anyways. I don't think I will have the patience to learn After Effects.