logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
2-Nov-2025
Posts
1,604

Post History

Post
#1382758
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

I liked The Rock, Pearl Harbor and Armageddon but i’m not going to pretend they are great cinema.

Sometimes a movie is just something you watch for enjoyment and it is nothing more than that. Something to do for a couple of hours.

The only thing i liked about his Bayformers movies was the monologue at the end of the first film and the inclusion of Peter Cullen as the voice of Optimus Prime. Dumb movies and they can be enjoyed a lot more if you are not a Transformers or Generation 1 fan. The Last Knight cannot even be defended as a dumb flick to be enjoyed, though it is truly one of the worst films i have ever seen. And Marky Mark phoned that movie in.

As for Bayturtles those movies are truly abominable. Especially the second one.

Post
#1382662
Topic
The Worst Scene/Sequence in Any Star Wars Film
Time

How about Vader going Crazy on the Rebel troops in rogue one. Yeah the scene might be cool but it doesn’t fit the style at the beginning of Star Wars 77 at all.

It was very flashy like something the prequels or sequel movies would have done.

The other one i would mention is Greedo shooting first in the Special Edition, or Jabba and Boba Fett in Star Wars.

Post
#1382413
Topic
What is your main way of watching the Original Trilogy?
Time

Wow i haven’t watched the films on VHS in a while. Not since buying the Fox rental tape just to review it/compare it to other releases. My go to versions in the 1990s were the pan and scan one last time set and the pre THX pan and scan set. I last watched Return of the Jedi as 4K83. Haven’t found a good HD version of Empire 1980. And i only watched some of 4K77 because i haven’t had the time to really sit down and enjoy it.
I also haven’t watched the Evergreen Japan Laserdisc of A New Hope yet and had planned on doing so.

Post
#1382067
Topic
What was changed for 1995 THX version?
Time

The 1995 CLV discs are nearly identical to the CAV 1993 laserdiscs. Same master. Same noise reduction, same audio.

The only difference i can see is the reduced price of the CLV discs and that you could purchase the 3 films separately without the huge oversized definitive box. The CLV discs are much less prone to laser rot especially if they are the US releases which were pressed in Japan.

Both releases had THX certification.

Post
#1381142
Topic
The Thread Where You Wax Rhapsodic about Your Book Collection
Time

A while ago i bought a bunch of IDW comics editions of some Al Williamson Secret Agent Corrigan and Alex Raymond Rip Kirby. I also have the Al Williamson Russ Cochran publishing Star Wars on the same shelf. And the deluxe limited edition of The Star Wars. That was a gift. The Art of Return of the Jedi first edition. The Star Wars and Return of the Jedi portfolios by Ralph McQuarrie.

Some random Dark Horse, Marvel and DC stuff i have in a box of comics. And i have a whole shelf of books on Icelandic Sagas, Mythology and a whole Tolkien and Robert Jordan shelf of books i haven’t touched in years.

I had a much bigger Star Wars and Tolkien collection i gave away to the library and friends/family. It all takes up too much space. I gave away my first editions of Lord of the Rings and the Silmarillion. All my Edgar Rice Burroughs paperbacks still sit on a shelf or are in boxes. My first edition of a Princess of Mars is in a draw somewhere. I have all the Frazetta books from the John Carter series. I have only a couple of the Venus series.

I found i have some stuff i never knew i had or had forgotten as well. Like Star Wars illustrated screenplays, radio drama scripts a bunch of EU. Laurent Bouzereau annotated screenplays. The making of return of the jedi, a journal of the empire strikes back once upon a galaxy. Empire strikes back notebook etc.

I gave away my first edition of Rinzler’s making of Star Wars. Large coffee table book took up space, i enjoyed reading it though the one time i did.

Post
#1381135
Topic
What methods were used in coming up with the choreography of the lightsaber duels?
Time

I have no idea but i think Empire has the best duel. I think the prequels are like dance choreography, or at least Episode I is. There is a lot of flashy movement. That is not to say i hate it. I like Duel of the Fates but the originals had better sword fights. The sequels only had one duel which was good force awakens. The one film where there should have been a duel Last Jedi didn’t have one. They missed a chance to have Luke be a badass instead of a Force Hologram.

Post
#1381113
Topic
All Things Star Trek
Time

I like a lot of Star trek but i feel like the TNG films were a lost opportunity.
1 great action flick, 1 mediocre film and 2 awful films.
Even Star Trek V as bad as it is has its moments. The TNG films just never really worked, and i wonder why. Great cast, the potential is there and they had good writers and creatives. Yet nothing ever really gelled.

Post
#1379445
Topic
The Rise Of Skywalker - Abrams' Vision or Executive Meddling?
Time

I would go to see another film with Rey becoming a Jedi Master and taking Finn as her apprentice.

We could finally see the Republic restored and the Jedi order rebuilt.

I don’t know if you could do an entire trilogy out of it but a stand alone episode 10 maybe.

I don’t see Lucasfilm doing that though.

Also conflict makes good drama, well the conflict of Star Wars is played out you can only do so much Jedi VS Sith stories, or rebels vs empire.

Post
#1379442
Topic
What are you reading?
Time

The George Lucas interviews. It is a compilation of various interviews given to the press and magazines through the years.

I’ve read the ones on THX and Graffiti so far. Its interesting. His contempt for the Hollywood system and grudge for the edits made to his first two films is kind of hilarious. Especially the bit about art being pretentious and BS, and how he is more like a watchmaker.

How he admits to not being a good writer and that his strength was as an editor. And how he relied on his friends on the script, and how he threw out the first 3 drafts of Star Wars. That he considered the lead for Star Wars to be a girl before he cast Mark Hamill to play Luke.

Not like the 1990s and after how he had the whole thing as one big script and it was always the story of Darth Vader.