logo Sign In

JadedSkywalker

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Jun-2020
Last activity
14-Jan-2026
Posts
1,716

Post History

Post
#1412093
Topic
Best battle of the Original Trilogy?
Time

The original approach to the Death Star with the X-wings and Red Squadron’s run on the trench in Star Wars. That is my favorite.

The best in terms of number of shots and the difficulty in achieving them technically is the Battle of Endor and the final epic space battle. Then the Battle of Hoth and how painstaking the work was to hand animate the stop motion AT-AT Walkers.

Post
#1412088
Topic
Prediction for Star Wars X, XI, and XII
Time

I don’t think they should or would change the canon. It would be much more easy two have 2 different canons if the old EU was continued in a different adjacent timeline. The could even adapt some of the comics, and novels into animation under the Legends imprint.

Would the original cuts of the OT also count as Legends? Since the Maclunky edit is the official canon along with Han shooting second.

Post
#1412085
Topic
Best Performance by an Actor/Actress in the Star Wars Movies
Time

Mark Hamill as Luke. I’m split between whether his best performance was in Return of the Jedi, or Last Jedi.

I also liked Qui Gon played by Liam Neeson, i think he brought a humanity to Phantom Menace. I like Ewan Obi Wan as well in all 3 prequels.

I like Daisy as Rey. She had that same kind of youthful effervescent giddiness that Mark had in A New Hope, or as i call it Star Wars. I like that Rey, despite her humble origins she chooses to be good, and has a good heart.

Post
#1411103
Topic
Unpopular Opinion Thread
Time

That was Rey being the new Luke, being the only one who thought Kylo could be redeemed.

Like Luke was the only one who believed Anakin could return from the darkside.

Rey was right by the way they won the war because Ben Solo was redeemed. He saved her from dying and traded his own life.

I guess you could complain they just recycled episodes IV-VI and the Disney movies offered nothing new.

Ben turning to the light restored the Balance.

Post
#1411099
Topic
Is the 1997 Special Edition important?
Time

It wasn’t a restoration though. They cut up and butchered the negative to conform it to the 1997 edit. The original effects were replaced by either recomped or new cgi shots.

Nobody would be complaining if all they did was restore the faded color, created a new faithful multi track digital mix. Or replaced that Landspeeder shot with vaseline on the lens.

Imagine if Han did not shoot second, if he was the only one who fired.

So many unforced errors, like the worse cgi X-wing shots instead of the original motion control photography.

Post
#1410703
Topic
Unpopular Opinion Thread
Time

Kasdan did not provide for the story in Star Wars the same way he did for Raiders of the Lost Ark.

He saved that movie. Other than making the dialog punchier and tightening up the script anyone could have polished up Empire or Jedi. Kasdan never was the author. Nor was Gloria or Willard co-authors on Star Wars the way they absolutely were on American Graffiti.

Lucas is bad on dialog and bad on drama so he hires people who fix those aspects.

Lucas is 100% the author of the OT good or bad, the same way he was for the prequels. Its his story and its in no way collaborative. The stories are his and very personal. They are in his imagination and his head. No matter how much he wished he could hand it off to someone else it was impossible.

It was a mistake to give Disney an outline and to believe they wouldn’t screw it up. He has to write these things and oversee them himself to get the desired result.

Post
#1410375
Topic
Prediction for Star Wars X, XI, and XII
Time

The real question is how can you have conflict when the galaxy is at peace, i don’t think you can do the Sith/Empire storyline a third time. Nor can you do superweapons again.

Seeing the Republic restored and the Jedi order rebuilt wouldn’t take a whole nother trilogy.

They fell into the same problems with the EU. Their solution was to create a new enemy the Vong.

Then they inevitably fell into rinse repeat civil war, Jedi/Sith conflict again.

Post
#1409511
Topic
What do you like about the EU Pre-Disney?
Time

The Boba Fett comics. Twin Engines of Destruction, Death Lies and Treachery. And Enemy of the Empire.

The Dark Horse comics Droids.

Anything by Al Williamson but especially Crimson Forever. The newspaper strips reprinted in the Russ Cochran 3 volume set.

Jango Fett Open Seasons.

Star Wars Republic

Knights of the Old Republic comic.

Star Wars Dark Times comic.

Star Wars Legacy. and Legacy II.

Knight Errant.

Crimson Empire I and II.

Dark Empire I and II.

The Star Wars.

Star Wars Tales.
Star Wars Rebellion
X-wing Comics.
Mara Jade by the Emperor’s hand.