- Post
- #1037415
- Topic
- ROTJ is the best Star Wars film... discuss!
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1037415/action/topic#1037415
- Time
Excellent thank you haha
This user has been banned.
Excellent thank you haha
Apparently he was mythed when they dubbed him.
He was also miffed.
I did it on purpose!
I’d love to see the footage with Dave prowse saying vader lines in his accent haha. Apparently he was mythed when they dubbed him.
Double post…sorry
How could they even think of changing the holograms! I think the timed/cut vader breathing/fighting is just brilliant and the action is realistic, that is what sets these films apart. I met Dave prowse in the city toy shop and he was a giant in full vader costume. Obviously he was signing stuff but that was on the back of Jedi. Jedi will always have a strong place in my heart and it’s easily better than anything that has been made since…
I saw Jedi at the cinema on its release and thought it was the best film i’d ever seen at the time. The jabba’s palace,rancor scene was epic at that time and the vader,Luke and emperor moment was immense. How people can say this is below any of the newer films is beyond me. It is part of the OT and still the third best of the lot. Lastly the figures sold were amongst the most collectable at the time.
I’ll just leave this here, probably one of the best scenes in the entire trilogy.
I think Rogue One definitely had sone moments but they obviously looked long and hard at ESB to try and recreate the darkness and style of it and in parts it worked.
I’m starting to think that IP55 is slightly more annoying than Mala.
Who’s the troll? I’m a firm believer you are a prick
I called you annoying, not a troll. Perhaps you should invest in some reading comprehension.
That’s funny
…I’ve probably got more letters after my name than your address mo fo
I’m starting to think that IP55 is slightly more annoying than Mala.
I’m a firm believer you are a prick
I’m a firm believer you will be banned if you don’t learn some manners. Strike one.
The members of this forum seem eager on calling folk Trolls, that was clearly troll behaviour yet you warn me?
I’m starting to think that IP55 is slightly more annoying than Mala.
Who’s the troll? I’m a firm believer you are a prick
The only thing that exists on my world is the OT, vader lived on the death star and other ships haha. Not some count ducula castle…cannon,prequels and Wikis are just shite that was created after the event.
What part of previously unused Ralph McQuarrie OT concept do you not get?
None of it, the films are the films.
I have to agree Just because Ralph designed it doesn’t mean we should all accept it as canon.
I dig it though.It’s something Disney pulled out of their asses.
Ftfy
There’s no need to remake the OT. Just leave it the way it was… before all the hideous changes.
There is a need £££££
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_film_remakesWikipedia is just shite that was created after
Wrong pedia.
It’s full of bollocks whatever pedia
Oh ok.
Whilst I don’t think wikis are a sound reference resource this serves a lazy purpose…Canon Wikis however are total fiction made as said
After the event
There’s no need to remake the OT. Just leave it the way it was… before all the hideous changes.
There is a need £££££
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_film_remakes
The prequels and the new Disney films seem to have lost the fundamental element that made the Out what it was? Why can’t they evoke that same emotional response?
To be fair it was never referenced in any of the films before Rogue One. So if your personal canon is the films only, as mine is, then the question of his home is an open one. Well, at least until Rogue One was released anyway.
But there are multiple things we aren’t told and shown in the OT. Vader slaughtering Rebels is a perfect example.
Somethings should be left alone…
If it doesn’t add anything to the story or characters sure but this isn’t the case.
I enjoyed leaving that to my imagination… Then someone did the unthinkable and wiped out the childhood memories of millions of 40+ folk.
Funny, my childhood memories seem to be fully intact.
Your star wars ones tainted…
Then someone did the unthinkable and wiped out the childhood memories of millions of 40+ folk.
Not possible.
Also, what 005 said.
It’s on topic, R1 is a prequel
To be fair it was never referenced in any of the films before Rogue One. So if your personal canon is the films only, as mine is, then the question of his home is an open one. Well, at least until Rogue One was released anyway.
But there are multiple things we aren’t told and shown in the OT. Vader slaughtering Rebels is a perfect example.
Somethings should be left alone…
If it doesn’t add anything to the story or characters sure but this isn’t the case.
I enjoyed leaving that to my imagination… Then someone did the unthinkable and wiped out the childhood memories of millions of 40+ folk.
Would you like someone tinkering with your old holiday films lol
Why do some people (Lucas included) think Mos Isley should be a big, busy, sprawling city? The OOT depicts it as a run down truck stop. Much like those you see on the highway in the middle of nowhere. Not too busy, but necessary. I like that much more.
I agree 👍 the SE damaged that isolation of it, OT made sense as a ’ once upon a time busy place’ now full of scum in hiding.
The only thing that exists on my world is the OT, vader lived on the death star and other ships haha. Not some count ducula castle…cannon,prequels and Wikis are just shite that was created after the event.
What part of previously unused Ralph McQuarrie OT concept do you not get?
None of it, the films are the films.
I have to agree Just because Ralph designed it doesn’t mean we should all accept it as canon.
I dig it though.Personal Canon = ANH, ESB and ROTJ
I fixed that for you.
Accepted
The only thing that exists on my world is the OT, vader lived on the death star and other ships haha. Not some count ducula castle…cannon,prequels and Wikis are just shite that was created after the event.
What part of previously unused Ralph McQuarrie OT concept do you not get?
None of it, the films are the films.
I have to agree Just because Ralph designed it doesn’t mean we should all accept it as canon.
I dig it though.
Canon = ANH, ESB and ROTJ
Please be OUT
There is only one order…
I wouldn’t want to hear the Imperial March before its first appearance in The Empire Strikes Back.
It’s in Phantom Menace, so there’s another knock against the prequels.
(https://youtu.be/OLQ-rCSbFeQ)No, it’s not “another knock against”. And R1 is part of the prequels by the way… (and it’s the fourth best prequel).
Clearly a massive troll, if that’s what you actually think I feel sorry for you!
It gives (to OT) damaging backstory,
I concur… A huge blemish
I’d go as far as one of the biggest cinematic fuck ups in history!
The only thing that exists on my world is the OT, vader lived on the death star and other ships haha. Not some count ducula castle…cannon,prequels and Wikis are just shite that was created after the event.
What part of previously unused Ralph McQuarrie OT concept do you not get?
None of it, the films are the films.