logo Sign In

GundarkHunter

User Group
Members
Join date
10-Mar-2003
Last activity
9-Apr-2017
Posts
4,720

Post History

Post
#226750
Topic
A Scanner Darkly - First 24 minutes
Time
Originally posted by: none
I haven't read Blade Runner's precursor, but wasn't that a short story? So it needed filling out if it was to become a feature film.

Blade Runner's precursor was "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep" [DADOES], which was a full novel. There were many elements cut from DADOES to make it into Blade Runner, including the titular electric sheep. Prestige in the future society of DADOES is measured by the pets you own, and people have become so jaded and chemically infected that they need "empathy boxes" and mood machines in order to feel anything. None of this material made its way into Scott's film. I would love to see what Paul Verhoeven, David Fincher or Darren Aronofsky would do with a remake, because they have all made films that touch on issues explored in DADOES. Does this mean I hate Blade Runner? No, but I do wish that some of the material, which goes a long way to explaining what Deckard is (and no, he's not a replicant) would have made its way into the film.

That being said, I think Linklater is trying to distill the main concepts out of A Scanner Darkly, and I'm looking forward to seeing the end result.

Post
#223353
Topic
What DVDs should I upgrade?
Time
Originally posted by: Coldon
Hey man, you have a pretty solid collection. I dont know if you are a freak about picture quality (anamorphic vs. non-anamorphic and whatnot).
But if you are, you should consider upgrading:

12 Monkeys (the new edition is anamorphic and has an INCREDIBLE full-length documentary and commentary)
The Big Lebowski (the new collectors edition has a vastly improved image quality. However, it doesnt really have any extra bonus features)
Jaws (the new 30th anniv. Edition has the original mono track and the full-length documentary from the laserdisc.....not the sub-par and heavily edited version on this release)

Also...you seem to be into Wes Anderson's films AND Criterion releases....
Please, if you ever get Rushmore, buy the Criterion edition. The image quality is AMAZING and the bonus features are great. Especially the shorts.

First off, the original edition of 12 Monkeys is anamorphic and contains the full length documentary "The Hamster Factor and other Tales", one of the finest documentaries on filmmaking ever made. Period. You won't catch me upgrading.
The new version of The Big Lebowski is somewhat of an improvement, but probably not enough to warrant an upgrade. The original looked fine on a 16 foot screen in my film studies class.
Jaws--I'll eventually upgrade, but I'l wait 'til the price drops even lower.
I will second the vote for the Criterion Rushmore. It's a great looking DVD.