- Recolor the two lights on Rey’s yellow saber to blue and purple
Finally! One of my ideas made it on the changelist. Wooooo!!! Hopefully one of these special effect geniuses here can make it a reality. 😃
Also: YES I KNOW LUKE’S SABER IS GREEN AND I AGREE IT STANDS FOR HIS CHARACTER BUT IT JUST DOESN’T MAKE SENSE FOR THIS STUPID SCENE IN THIS STUPID MOVIE BECAUSE SHE ONLY HAS HIS BLUE ONE AND IT BREAKS EVERYTHING BUT WHATEVER I DON’T ACTUALLY CARE.
The main reason I think it should be blue and purple in the context of this edit.
The only thing Rey knows of the green is it trying to murder Kylo. Hero Luke accept the blue saber, not the green.
Oh, and that’s a genius idea to make the little lights green and purple in the end scene. (It even makes a tad more sense that purple and green would add up to a yellow hue.) Who’s up for it? lol
Blue and purple
Anakin/Luke/Rey and Leia’s
Luke’s green is AWOL, assuming she is using the crystals of the lightsabers she has
To address something from MR’s thread, I hadn’t really planned on using his clip of added sparks to the sabers at the end of Exegol. But, the final product looks fantastic!
Please include this! It makes Rey burying them at the end make so much more sense. They served their purpose and now she has her own path. If we really want to try something cool… when Rey ignites her saber there is a green and blue color during the ignition. Can the green be recolored to purple? Implying both sabers broke and Rey used the Kyber Crystals to make her own lightsaber with them would help sell Rey Skywalker more, at least for me.
Glad everyone is working so hard on this. Cannot wait for the finished copy. Any progress on the Skywalker Puppet Pals scene?
I don’t want to sound nitpicky. The work out this project has been outstanding.
I still think a little of the coloring looks off. It’s really dark at the beginning, then the sky has a green hue in the right corner behind Rey, then goes back to being dark. The shot of the burning TIE has it almost looking pitch black around it but Rey and the Porgs are lit up. I love the idea and the hard work but I don’t think it 100% there just yet.
It would be nice to have Luke say that as Rey looks at the X-Wing. Could work as a little foreshadowing.
Any changes that make the trilogy feel more connected should be encouraged.
I’m not sure why the birth of her son would stop Leia from being a Jedi. Did she need to be a stay at home senator? I think it may cause more confusion. She needed to have a push to not continue. The death of your child would do that, and it ironically comes true.
But the good part is that in death Ben is brought back home, which is why Leia’s body waited for him. So, the death of her son at the end of her journey has a different meaning. Sounds like a misread prophecy 😉
How many hours did we last before you two started bickering again? We should start a new thread and vote on the winner daily.
Also… have Luke turn into Hagrid and say “You’re a wizard harRAY”
Hey guys, I’m not a mod but let’s have grumpy discussion elsewhere. I swear this thread is turning into the General Discussion page.
Do we have a remaining things list for V2? Any proposed changes that have yet to be owned by someone that we would like to try and have done by V2?
Not that it is my decision but I think we should try solidifying a list of remaining things for this edit and any other discussion could go to the Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker Redux Ideas thread.
I think reusing the Falcon scene would be great, minus the dice. If Kylo’s new helmet could be added it would be a great way to connect back and show how he is still conflicted, and will only help flesh out Han’s scene later on.
That would be better like this…
"The life force of your bond, a dyad in the Force. A power like life itself. Unseen for generations. Your coming together will be your undoing. And now, the power of two restores the one true Emperor.
So excited! Cannot wait to see how these “finished” copies look!!!
When was That? I haven’t heard from him in ages. I hope his film is going well.
It was quite a while ago.
I did have a pm with him where he said he was working on something. An aged Bryan Cranston has a striking resemblance to Shaw, I think that was something he was exploring.
Luke hitting a Grand Slam and taking out an AT-AT sounds hilarious and it is exactly the type of exaggeration that Luke was talking about in TLJ with “The Legend of Luke Skywalker”
The galaxy in TFA thinks Luke is a myth because of his god-like status.
Just thought of a fun change that could make for a good easter egg. When Rey is on Pasanna and stumbles across the kids watching the puppet show, how hard would it be to make it look like Luke versus the First Order and slightly extend the shot as a nice callback to TLJ. Especially with Rey’s reaction afterwards. Doesn’t seem like it would be too complicated for someone to mock up. Not even sure if it is worth the trouble though…
It’s nice seeing something you suggested like forty pages ago coming to fruition haha
It might be good to have Luke and the walker falling which would explain why the kids are laughing.
Yeah, I’m with you on this. Do you have a high res version of the images you’ve used?
This was not made by me. All credit to Cinefy
It might be good to have Luke and the walker falling which would explain why the kids are laughing.
It’s in this thread! I had suggested it and found someone mocked one up. Not sure who let me see what I can find!
I believe this was Cinefy
That would be nice for pacing. I also suggested some planet arrival/leaving scenes which would be awesome if some talented people here could create them.
The work on this has been great so far. I would love to see the 4k look like this, but I would love to get a link when completed.
