logo Sign In

GlastoEls

User Group
Members
Join date
3-Nov-2012
Last activity
18-Apr-2024
Posts
355

Post History

Post
#741158
Topic
Star Wars Day (UK) - Screenings of OT
Time

Just to finish off this thread, here's the review of the day from the British Film Institute themselves:

http://www.bfi.org.uk/news-opinion/news-bfi/features/8-things-we-learned-star-wars-day?utm_content=bufferca05d&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitterbfi&utm_campaign=buffer

Some quotes:

The special editions remain as controversial as ever.

Yet, with the 1997 special ditions of the Star Wars trilogy the only versions in official circulation, a big-screen viewing makes the dated anniversary additions stick out like a sore thumb. And didn’t the audience know it (the loudest boos saved for Hayden Christensen’s spectral appearance at the end of Return of the Jedi). Director George Lucas clearly meant to impose closer ties to his prequels retrospectively, but if you’ve just broken a leg, it’s hard to see the logic in breaking the other one in the name of symmetry.

Post
#741046
Topic
Star Wars Day (UK) - Screenings of OT
Time

walking_carpet said:

adywan said:

GlastoEls said:

Disney does not want what just happened.

Boos for Greedo. Muttering at Jedi Rocks. But the ENTIRE theatre yelling and jeering Hayden SO loudly...

 Oh, i wish someone could have recorded that

 The horrendous re-cut that mixes vader going to a star destroyer (alert my star destroyer, blah, blah, blah)  in ESB is horrible too.  did the crowd boo at that?  people always say ESB had the least changes,  but that one is one of the worst

Agree with your point and opinion of that scene, but no.

They booed all mentions of the prequels during the panel discussions, and loudly clapped when the attending people (Biggs, Greedo, Jabba actors, plus second unit directors, etc) mentioned the OOT "originals" being better.

They grumbled during Mos Eisley swinging Jawa and Jedi Rocks, muttered during the "Wesa Free", and then it was chaos during both Greedo and especially Hayden (450 people pretty much all booing each time he came on screen - so funny and therapeutic for an originaltrilogy.com member!).

Like I say above, whereas this was a cine-literate crowd (film club members) it wasn't just Star Wars hardcore; surely this can't be sustainable for future releases at this point?

Post
#739368
Topic
Episode VII: The Force Awakens - Discussion * <strong>SPOILER THREAD</strong> *
Time

chyron8472 said:

imperialscum said:

OT with CGI would not be as great but still great.... while PT with real models would not be as shit but still shit. That's what I said.

 Speak for yourself. I refuse to watch Return of the Jedi if it has Jedi Rocks in it. Ruins the tone of the entire first act.

 That's not CGI, that's just bad!

Post
#735713
Topic
**RUMOR** Original theatrical cut of the OT to be released on blu ray!!
Time

unamochilla2 said:

By "smart," he may be referring to at least including the UOT with the SE, if not released separately.  However, if the Diamond Edition line is any indication, Disney usually re-releases a title with some incentive to buy... such as remastered picture/sound, unseen deleted scenes, new bonus features, etc.

EXACTLY - and there's a huge incentive with the UOT, not released in the best part of 20 years!

Post
#734104
Topic
Other than Jar Jar and midichlorians, what don't you want in episode 7?
Time

deepanddark20 said:

As much as I love Obi-Wan Kenobi, and as much as I love Ewan Macgregor, I wouldn't be able to accept Kenobi's inclusion in any further Star Wars movies played by Macgregor. The idea of Kenobi showing up as Ewan Macgregor ever again after being played by Guiness in the previous 3 movies just can't work. It would be a clunkiness that is far better to avoid by simply not including the character anymore, as much as he will be sorely missed.

Agreed.

Plenty of room to visit him on Tatooine between 3 and 4, anyway.