Will there be more shots of Dagobah in the edit? I'd like to see Dagobah more opened up for some scenes. It really feels to crowded and "on set." In one of the first scenes it shows Dagobah nice and open with some atmoshere to it. I know Bespin will look dazaling, I want the same for the swampy Dagobah. This si just for an added one or two sequences, not all of it.
Yoda does need to be green. But the blue gives Dagobah an alien feel to it.
I don't mean to interupt this intelligent conversation, but lets here some SW ideas. This talk has been going on for about 1.5 pages.
I didn't know that, interesting. I wonder how much better AOTC would have been with Kersh. He probably would have shot at all real locations, except Coruscant.
(which I actually enjoy quite a bit)
There are some strong scenes and then some totally stupid scenes. With heavy editing, added scenes, and cleaned up CG, who knows?
Darth Venal said:
shanerjedi said:
ESB is such a great looking fantasy film.
Great direction
Why didn't Irvin Kershner direct ROTJ? One can only wonder what it would of been.
shanerjedi said:
ESB is such a great looking fantasy film.
That it is, especially when Ady gets done with it!
When in 2010 will this edit be out?
Obi-Wan technically never owned R2. Besides, Obi knowing where Yoda is, is important. They had to know where each other where.
True 005. I'd still take him out of the SB battle, unless someone can make the battle unbelievable.
Take him out of the SB battle, add him the the space battle. I'd keep him in the Sail B Battle, but he looks totally stupid.
Where is the inconsistency?
Actually, you might be right, but it would be weird to not see him in ROTJ.
I'd like to see him fight in the final space battle. That could easily be done. I'd take him out of the SB battle. It would shorten the worst battle in the movies, and also not make Boba look like a total dumb ass. They make him out to be all BA in ANH and ESB, then he looks rediculous in his battle.
You cant just take him out of the whole movie, talk about an inconsistecy.
The ESB pic does look the best. I just mabey seen a bad video.
What do you guys think about the rumors that were posted up the page?
I think someone who doesn't know a lot about film like Ghost could get the wrong idea from that statement.
Look, I already cleared up what I meant to say. If you would read previous pages, you probably would have a better idea of what your talking about. I'm not that stupid to say break away from the plot. I know alot about the film btw, believe me, that's why I'm here.
Oh yah, I forgot about that. I did read that 2 times and even showed it to other people.
I'm not thinking right now.
About the 005 page, are you guys for the Boba Fett changes? (the having him take the plans to the rebels). It could work. I don't know how you would make the new scenes. It would take him out of the SB battle, therefore shortning it. How would you kill him off, the Falcon?
Thanks TV's Frink. I want to see some ideas and mockups I might of missed.
How do you get to the middle of the threads eisier (not having to go one page at a time)?
Like page 100 or any page.
Nope.
All I meant was we don't need 10 minutes of the SB battle. Cutting time off it wouldn't be breaking from the story. It would be better to see Luke dominate it rather than him looking like he didn't know what he was doing.
I misread it. I skimmed fast and quickly posted it elsewhere.
A NEW trilogy? I personally want to see all 6 movies their full potential before we see a new trilogy. Could it be a re-made PT? Before the PT? After the OT?
I really trust Steven Speilburg. I trust that he really has some story to work with.
WOW! I would love to see what Steven Speilburg would do.
Now the question is, Will there be more changes and added scenes.
Theres nothing wrong with the pacing, it is how stupid the battle is and looks. We don't need to see 10 minutes of screwing around when we only need to see 3-4. How ever long the "battle" is (more like a scene from a play it's that bad), it still gets the point that there is a battle. It's not like we are taking out important scenes that build characterism.
Sometimes you need to break from the story a little bit to make the overall movie better to watch. The final battles should be nothing short of spectacular because it is the end of the best saga of all time. What will get more people in to SW, the SB battle or an updated more important space battle?
No it's pretty much returned to it's original pre-blue tint palette which is what I want to see so I'm happy with it.
Alright, good. I thought I seen it on youtube and it was gray, I'll go re-check.
Still, he doesn't look like a Jedi. It is a consistency issue. And yes, Luke was that good because he defeated Vader later in the movie. You guys would say that Luke in ROTJ is about the same as Anakin in AOTC. Right? Yoda is the best in the business, Luke should be close by then. He was trained a little from Obi-Wan to.
It shouldn't be about how good Luke was guys, the battle is lame compared to every other battle in these movies. We should see more in space rather than a dragged out SB battle. It should be harder for Lando to even get in the DS. Ani and Obi in ROTS didn't just fly into Greivous's ship. There is more to show in space and less to see on the SB.
Now do you guys like the Dagobah "color correction." IMO, it was to extreme. It looks dead and gray. TOO, dead and gray.
Now for the Sail Barge Battle, is there a way to make alot shorter? Think about it, if Luke was any PT jedi, the battle would be over in about a minute. Luke should be that good in this point of the trilogy. Plus, alot of the scenes look fake any way, and mabey the time loss could be made up with a longer space battle.
A battle like that shouldn't be given that much time in the movie. The end battles should. Overall, it would the SB battle feel not as stupid and corny.
Iv sent you that CG animation you asked for that you needed for your film to your hotmail account
Is this supposed to be confidential. You didn't need to post that, it has me curious now.
Second, I don't think his entrance is weak, but it could and should be better considering his importance and the importance of the battle. When he walks in, I don't like how we can't see him that well because he has to push everything out of his way in a crowded room.