G&G-Fan

mmmmmmm make no sense this does

Hal 9000 said:

Add a bunch of random alien characters to the rebel alliance in ESB.

And that’s bad because?

More aliens =/= bad. In fact, maybe that’s something I’d like to see more of… maybe…

I adore SC 38 I think the fight is amazing. It perfectly captured Vader’s fighting style

Of course SC 38 was used. The fight is actually good and actually fits the characters personalities and skill sets instead of looking like two old men fighting with sticks (Vader is 42 not an old man and is supposed to be an expert duelist who “Helped the empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights”). To me that’s enough to forgive it being different.

Besides, of course the fight scene is going to be filmed differently then the talking scenes.

JackNapier said:

That never happened

Yeah it’s been pointed out to me. I guess what happened is that I heard someone say he said it and then in my mind I shaped the screams to form the words

Luke’s line is legit tho

But another time I misheard something from the OT is when Luke receives the vision of his friends being tortured on Cloud City I always thought Yoda responded to Luke’s question of whether they will die with “If you go to see”, only to realize through subtitles he said “Difficult to see”.

Two things from Vader’s Redemption/the Emperor’s Death

Right before Vader/Anakin picks up the Emperor (as he looks down at Luke one last time), Luke shouts “Father!” desperately one last time. And when Anakin does pick up the Emperor, the Emperor screams “Anakin, you murderer!”

DZ-330 said:

I think if it was included it should be when Vader first appears:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQ3h20LYzBA

I would miss the Battle of Hoth version of the march during the extended Death Star battle though if it was being removed.

Yeah that’s fantastic, even better then the other video honestly

Hal 9000 said:

I guess I’ll chime in, too. I think including the Imperial March fits in well with this project’s intentions. It’s not meant to replace the original, but be an uncompromising Special Edition with good taste. Ideally, though, there wouldn’t be an ESB-thunder-stealing montage of an Imperial fleet when we first see the Death Star.

Not that any of it matters, as it’s Adywan’s call and he was clearly happy to include both in the original Revisited.

He could totally use this version (the one that was originally going to be in ESB but replaced): https://youtu.be/30pQcy8AkIQ?t=164

As you guys can tell I’m with DZ and Eddie on this

I literally did not think it was possible to prefer the original Empire theme over the Imperial March… but damn

The Imperial March is “overused” in the same way that the Force theme and the opening title crawl theme is.

jarbear said:

Regarding the use of Imperial March, this was a Vimeo link someone did ages ago.

https://player.vimeo.com/video/225892219

It’s beautiful

exitzero said:

It’s Imperial March not Darth Vader’s theme song. The Imperial March is in Episode 2,3, Rogue one and even Solo: A Star Wars story. In episode 6 it’s used when the Emperor arrives at the Death Star. Playing the Imperial March for the Revisited’s grand reveal of the Death Star is fitting. That being said, Rogue One Death Star music is fine. Whatever Adywan thinks is best for the scene.

John Willaims disagrees with you

Well yeah because the Imperial March is Vader’s official theme, its literally in everything else that has him in it and everytime he’s foreshadowed or mentioned

Noooooooo I love that the Imperial March was in ANH:R I want it to be in the new version

wocke said:

Actually, I thought it was a pretty good pro-Lucas post. Sorry you missed that part of it.

Huh. Well, saying George Lucas has “no sense of writing or film” might’ve just given me the wrong vibes 😃

I did it, and it looks fantastic! Great work!

Jesus christ I think that is the worst anti-Lucas post I’ve ever seem in my life. You clearly know jack and shit about the man and just eat up all of the Lucas hater shit you see. Especially the whole “rough cut of the film was garbage and the editors having to fix it” bullshit despite that being so much of a lie a guy made a 2 hour video debunking it.

But go ahead and whine because Lucas made a few creative changes you didn’t like to a franchise HE created.

That guy with no name said:

G&G-Fan said:

Octorox said:

BMadden said:

Another vote here for the Spleen. I’m hoping someone will have it up there pretty soon.

Done.

How do I get it? I’ve never used myspleen before.

You dont need myspleen, Just go to https://swrevisited.wordpress.com Then press “about revisited” and then “how to get” it should give you the links to download.

I’m aware. There was context that you missed. They were talking about putting it on ‘spleen and so I asked. But I downloaded it from Ady’s site anyway since nobody responded.

Octorox said:

BMadden said:

Another vote here for the Spleen. I’m hoping someone will have it up there pretty soon.

Done.

How do I get it? I’ve never used myspleen before.

Oh, I see

And yeah, the smile does look very similar

doubleofive said:

I believe Adywan did a study and found a shot from him making similar expressions from a different angle. We don’t know of a reshoot filmed specifically for that shot, so I just stick with that theory.

How did he get the alternate angle footage?

May I ask how you learned that Hayden’s head that was added to ROTJ came from alternate angles of him saying goodbye to Obi-Wan? I’m not like questioning the fact I’m just curious to know how to found out.

Darth_Zounds said:

When Luke introduces himself to the droids in ANH, he should call himself Luke Lars.

When Obi-Wan tells Luke about his father, he should spell out his father’s name was Anakin Skywalker and thus his name is actually Luke Skywalker.

Ok but how is that terrible? It’d help explain why he was never a target for the Empire or Darth Vader. Is this just a thread for “Edit ideas that acknowledge the prequels” (even though this wouldn’t even be exclusively dealing with the prequels)?

BedeHistory731 said:

I still hate it and would rank it as the worst scene in the series. It represents everything wrong with Star Wars fans, how all they want is just mindless scenes of “cool characters” using lightsabers for violence.

I like my Vader far more subdued, not this videogame nonsense.

Yeah, because you know, Vader “helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi knights” and was the Emperor’s main enforcer by just sitting around.

TestingOutTheTest said:

Maybe I’m confusing it with mood, but Vader’s presence in ANH is something that’s more ominous. He’s often not the focus of the shot, and it creates this really great eerie effect; like how Leia backs up into him when Alderaan’s about to be destroyed. Vader inspires dread throughout ANH, but his hallway scene is all about terror. And that’s fine, that’s great, but explosive Vader shouldn’t be his opening. It should come at the end during his duel with Obi-Wan so that it feels like a major payoff to the hints that they both possess incredible power.

I guess I can see where you’re coming from. But I mean, Vader shows his power in the beginning when he literally lifts a man up with one hand, so its not like they were holding out until the end.

BedeHistory731 said:

I just hate the hallway scene. The fandom ruined it for me. If it would be feasible to cut it and not lose any plot, I would leap at the opportunity.

I adore it. One of my favorite Star Wars scenes now.

How

Btw sorry I’ve been silent, still working on this stuff. ROTS and ANH especially.

SparkySywer said:

He reached 420 posts then stopped

This can’t be a coincidence

As we all know, that is the ultimate number