I think it’s really cool that this edit is making visual changes whilst still attempting to look like something made in 1977. Recently I’ve come to believe that maintaining that authenticity is really important, rather then shoving 90s CG (or more modern CG) into a 70s movie. It just doesn’t look right.
These are some cool ideas I might incorporate in my Prequel rewrite.
Owen was Obi-Wan’s brother.
Then why does Owen hate Obi-Wan so much?
Vader was already in the suit when the Empire began, he rose the through the ranks as damaged goods (mainly through being Tarkin’s henchman).
When did the Empire begin? What put him in the suit before he fought Obi-Wan?
Has anyone considered addressing Palpatine by name in the OT? It would spoil the twist of the PT for first time viewers, assuming they watch the movies in production order as they should, but it would help tie the films together more cohesively in a subtle way.
It’s not a twist for anyone who’s seen the OT.
Woohoo, a five second throwaway line that could’ve been replaced with a dozen other things.
Vader wouldn’t be able to turn Leia to the dark side if she wasn’t Force sensitive.
Also throwaway line is genuinely hilarious considering it’s what causes Luke to almost turn to the dark side and kill Vader.
I forgot to mention this before, but it also heightens the stakes. Luke says that if he dies along Vader and the Emperor, Leia can take over as she’s also Force sensitive. If there was nobody else in the cast that could become a Jedi then the audience wouldn’t feel like there’s any risk of Luke dying.
My objections to Leia being a Skywalker are as follows:
- It comes out of nowhere
“No, there is another.”
Just because the answer to who that was was changed between movies doesn’t mean it wasn’t set up. The specifics of the pay-off just changed.
- It feels contrived that the secret sibling is someone Luke already knows
I can’t necessarily argue with “feels like” but within the lore it’s been justified three times over the circumstances in which they met. Bail Organa and Obi-Wan know each other, Obi-Wan trusted Bail with Anakin’s daughter, Bail trusted his daughter to find Obi-Wan leading her to Luke.
Having Luke’s sister just so happen to be the only other woman he’s spent the three films with is contrived to the point of ruining my immersion.
So you admit there’s nobody else it could be?
Say what you will about Rey being a Palpatine (I won’t pretend that isn’t stupid as well) but her grandparent only comes in at the end specifically looking for his granddaughter; he didn’t just bump into her at a bar.
The only reason she’s able to find her way to Exegol is because she managed to solve this intricate treasure hunt that Palpatine couldn’t have possibly predicted. He didn’t seek her out at all. He asked Kylo to kill her.
Removing the familial relationship is so much better because the having them pull a sister out of a hat yet having it be an established character only for it to go absolutely nowhere not only shrinks the universe but is just generally the single worst piece of writing in the entire Saga and I’m including Rise of Skywalker in that statement. It’s incredibly clumsy and embarrassing and I hate it.
It doesn’t go nowhere, it’s used by Vader to taunt Luke.
Acting like this is worse then The Rise of Skywalker is so insane it makes me think that you like shipped Luke and Leia in the first two or something, because it takes some major emotional attachment to actually believe that.
‘Star Wars: De-Incest Edition’
Leia is not Luke’s brother- snip out all the pieces of dialogue that say so.
At the top of my head only includes: Some of the stuff Ghost Obi-Wan tells Luke on Dagobah, some of what Luke says to Leia on Endor, and the baby Leia in Episode III (which I know isn’t OT, but still).
None of this would diminish Leia’s role in any of the films and would remove the incest-y details.
alternatively just remove Luke and Leia kissing (both times).
that’s better for me personally. Leia being Luke’s sister is just too iconic and ingrained at this point. Luke and Leia’s conversation in ROTJ is so good and her being used as emotional leverage by Vader also makes it all worth it.
Episode 8 of Ahsoka gave us a perfect new Hayden Anakin force ghost. Just roto him out, put him in the scene, and you’re good. I might try and attempt it at some point.
your google doc doesn’t exist anymore
With all the Ahsoka content out would it be possible to take older Hayden and make a new ROTJ ghost with it?
That Anakin ghost in episode 8 is kinda perfect when you think about it
This one has officially started. I’m doing these in order.
I’m really trying to figure out how to handle the first act. I want when we meet Anakin to be closer to the time code when you meet Luke in A New Hope, while also keeping the Otah Gungah. After consideration, Boss Nass comes out of nowhere if you remove him from the beginning, and I like the sea monster chase (I always like the creatures of Star Wars). I was gonna move it to the third act, but I don’t think things add up under the new context. I also want to keep the opening negotiation sequence, though cut down. I think it’s important to establish the Jedi as peacekeepers, not warriors, and I like the opening action scene. In the end it’s gonna be a question of what to sacrifice for the sake of pacing.
I think one of the best ways to make the Otah Gungah sequence and Jar Jar more bearable is to dub him with an alien language. I wasn’t gonna do it at first but now I’m considering it again. Last time I watched this film and heard, “Yousa in big dodoo this time” I was seriously wondering whether I was even watching Star Wars.
I feel like, without Otoh Gungah, Boss Nass & Co come out of nowhere in the 3rd act
That’s also true. The main issue is just how long it takes to get to Tatooine. I’m hoping to find a way to cut it so it works for my own edit, tho.
I find it kinda ironic that you cut the bongo sequence with the sea monsters because the cool creature stuff is the only reason I’d ever keep the journey to Otoh Gungah at all. Just my preference tho, obviously you can do what you want.
As I think about it more, I’m debating the change of Anakin’s vision foreshadowing his burning on Mustafar, as I think it almost victimizes him a bit too much. Vader being born partially from what’s pretty much self-preservation, while still making him look selfish, might border a bit too much on him being a victim rather then a power hungry monster. The only thing is, short of AI dialogue, I can’t really think of another way to add the “Anakin wants to be immortal” angle, which is important to my version.
Is the reason you’re keeping Anakin’s turn mostly the same is because you think it was executed well originally, or because you can’t really think of any additional changes to make it better?
I think the one in ROTJ is better because in the composition it moves towards the Millennium Falcon thus making for a more dynamic shot.
Man, I just decided to watch through these movies again recently and it made me remember about this post from years ago! I hope one day you revive this project G&G. Your Return of Godzilla and Godzilla vs. Biollante hybrid was something I was so hyped about!
That’s funny, I also just recently rewatched the Heisei era.
I’ll likely revisit these. But I do know that I’m not gonna combine Return and Biollante anymore. It’s just too different and while the film might be coherent it wouldn’t exactly feel right. Instead I’ll make an edit of Return of Godzilla that’s more entertaining. Especially editing the Tokyo rampage to make Godzilla more destructive, taking shots from the Super X fight.
Man, I just decided to watch through these movies again recently and it made me remember about this post from years ago! I hope one day you revive this project G&G. Your Return of Godzilla and Godzilla vs. Biollante hybrid was something I was so hyped about!
That’s funny, I also just recently rewatched the Heisei era.
I’ll likely revisit these. But I do know that I’m not gonna combine Return and Biollante anymore. It’s just too different and while the film might be coherent it wouldn’t exactly feel right. Instead I’ll make an edit of Return of Godzilla that’s more entertaining. Especially editing the Tokyo rampage to make Godzilla more destructive, taking shots from the Super X fight.
That’s a shame. The “nooooo” scene is cheesy but the scene where he walks on the Star Destroyer next to Palpatine is my favorite scene in the whole film.
Would have liked Luke’s lightsaber to have been yellow.
Piss lightsaber
Would any editing trick help imply that part of the reason why Anakin joins the Sith is because he loves the idea of being second in command of the galaxy? It’s a way that him being rejected the rank of master could be much more impactful. He was rejected a powerful position, but Palpatine is offering him power greater then anybody but him.
Ngl I was listening and I was like bruh that supposed to be Temeura Morrison 💀
Not even the worst of TCW did the same irreversible damage to Star Wars that the prequels and Rise of Skywalker did.
Yoda, Obi-Wan, Plo-Koon, Mace Windu, Ki-Adi Mundi.
I believe you are referring to “The Hidden Planet” fan-edit
https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Star-Wars-Episode-II-The-Hidden-Planet-1956/id/101823
As a way of showing Anakin’s lust for immortality in his own right (as an additional motive for him turning), AI some lines from Ian McDiarmid. Something like, “I know deep down, my boy, you crave the power to live forever. You crave it just as much as I do. As any Sith.”