Ed Slushie

I think with how much ai voices have improved it could probably be worth giving the “Rey is Anakin’s reincarnation” theory another go. As in, replace every mention of her being a Palpatine with a mention of her being The Chosen One / the spirit of Vader. I think the only on-screen lines that would need to be cut are “Because you’re a Palpatine” and “For my Grandchild to come home” which are things that have already been cut from some other edits. Maybe it would even be possible to edit it so that, in the scene where Kylo offers her his hand in the hangar, he’s actually holding out his mask (and he could have a line like “I spent years thinking I was the next Vader, but it was you all along. You’re the one who should be wearing this mask.”)
Edit: oooh and it would also explain why the first we see of Kylo after he asks “Who is she” is him looking to Vader’s mask for guidance. Like he’s asking “Is it true? Are you her?”

Hi, is this still available?

Is saying “AI dialogue” based on anything? Or just a vibe?

Anakin Starkiller said:

Honestly we should crowdsource shared masks for every lightsaber scene for this purpose, since I know plenty of people do this and have to imagine it’s a real pain in the ass.

Since Luca Frik, who made the “crackly saber” effect for the duel scene, presumably traced the outline of the saber for that effect already, there might already be a mask for this scene (or at least the start of one)

I think I’ve got the masking part down, but how do you turn one clip into a mask for another? I can Luma Key it but that makes everything too bright, resulting in a purplish-pink lightsaber: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SrQK7JrJcpPe1zPLndvs_bARQsPHrWui/view?usp=sharing

Edit: I found it, “Track Matte Key”

Omg thanks! What program is this in?

Anyone who has ever successfully changed the color of a lightsaber in post - how did you do it? Yes I am still trying to turn the Skywalker Saber red during the DSII duel. But it’s not going well. Is the person who changed Leia’s lightsaber from Blue to Purple still here?

Except as an animatic, which might be worth doing if anyone’s into that.

An idea I’ve had for a while but don’t think I’ve ever shared: to better parallel the Blue-vs-Blue duel from RotS, have the Skywalker lightsaber be red during the duel on Kef-Bir. (This would also just make the duel more visually striking, I think).
It wouldn’t have to be Red for the whole movie - it could turn red when Rey activates it in the Throne Room (implying that her vision in the vault made the crystal bleed) and then it could turn blue again when Ben gets it on Exegol.
I’ve tried editing this in myself but it’s very tedious - and given how quickly the edit that turns Leia’s Saber purple was made, presumably there are some people here for whom it’s easier (and the amount of time the lightsaber spends on screen between the throne room and the KoR fight isn’t much longer than the amount of screen time Leia’s saber got).
So if anyone else is interested in actually doing this I’d love to know.

I thought I saw someone make a composite shot in The Rise of Skywalker of Leia watching the Falcon leave Ajan Kloss. Does anyone have that?

Hi, are you still sending links? If so, I would like one too.

Hi, my google drive link doesn’t seem to include this version. Can I get an updated link?

Jar Jar Bricks said:

For my “sign in” slot I’d ideally like to have AI Benicio Del Toro say the following: “Libertine, standing by. Living free, joining up!”

The Libertine is the ship DJ and gang stole in TLJ and I’d love to see some redemption for his character in this film even if its more of an easter egg. The second part is the inverse of his signature phrase: “Live free, don’t join.”

Speaking of characters getting redemption via cameos, would it be too over-the-top to suggest that Jar Jar himself showed up at the battle? Cause he has a lot of dialogue from Lego Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga and I think it could be a fun easter egg.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQUV8jXFy-Y&ab_channel=Zenger
When the fleet first shows up he could say “Jar Jar Binks here to helps” (from 0:40) and then maybe when a Star Destroyer blows up he could say “Meesa good at dis!” (from 1:59).

I would suggest “Lightspeed-Ram” as that would come much closer to matching the lip movements.

Replace the opening crawls with narration by Philomena Cunk.
“The Death Star was destroyed just 4 years before the release of unrelated Ortolan jizz anthem, Lapti Nek.”

I thought episode 2 was pretty good. The pacing was weird when it started to focus on Bo-Katan but I liked seeing Grogu do some stuff on his own - it actually reminded me a lot of the game Stray. Also that ending did a way better job getting me excited for the rest of the season than episode 1’s did.

In addition to the Wilhelm scream, have the Spongebob Squarepants “My Leg” scream play in the background of every movie.

I’m torn between liking this one and hating it: In the flashbacks of TLJ, Luke isn’t shown trying to kill Ben with a lightsaber, instead he appears to be trying to smother Ben with a pillow. Luke then explains he had a vision of Ben hiding some forbidden artifact under his pillow so he went to investigate and that’s why he was holding the pillow (there was no artifact, it’s implied the vision was sent to him by Palpatine).

The Lego Star Wars Holiday Specials are not non-canonical spinoffs of the live-action movies but are instead spinoffs of Lego Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga and canon to that game’s timeline.

Threepio says “we surrender” and all the stormtroopers on Endor start dying for reasons they can’t explain (it’s as if they lost the will to live).

For as long as the movie has existed, I’ve wanted to see an extended cut of The Rise of Skywalker.
Though there have been several fan edits that improve the movie’s pacing, and several that incorporate fan-made or behind-the-scenes shots, I haven’t seen anyone try to make an edit that is purely additive. That’s what I aim to do here; and, to keep it canon-compliant, I’m basing it on the film’s novelization, The Rise of Skywalker: Expanded Edition by Rae Carson.
As this edit is still a work-in-progress (I’m only up to Pasanna), I don’t have a complete list of changes, but the rules I’ve set for myself are as follows:

1. Add as much to the movie as possible, as long as it doesn’t look obviously fake or contradict the book.
2. Change the order of events in the film to match the order of events in the book, unless doing so creates an obvious continuity error.
3. Do not remove anything from the movie unless it’s not in the book.

The sources I’m using to extend the movie include:

• Hal9000’s TROS editing resource pack
• The Disney+ series “Star Wars: Vehicle Flythroughs”
• Various behind-the-scenes VFX clips which feature slightly-longer versions of some of the film’s CG shots
• This fan-made Battlefront 2 Cinematic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bNND_yM90Q&lc=UgwhaMnLAWjexJPTAhl4AaABAg.9di9u3ZVxOz9dmztHl9HJa&ab_channel=RogueSithShortFilms
• Slowing down shots with optical flow, wherever possible.

This isn’t really an idea, but does anyone know where one could find an HD version of this tv spot?

For anyone interested in opening the movie with Kylo’s vision I altered the Star Destroyer Vehicle Flythroughs opening to start from a freeze frame so that it can more easily be placed after a title crawl:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQ3zs6vK7WA

Also, sorry to be pedantic but “Bounty Hunter Pursuit” was the name of the Lego set (and later, level in Lego Star Wars TCS) based on that AOTC scene; the song itself is “Zam the Assassin/Chase Through Coruscant.” While there is a song on the soundtrack called “Bounty Hunter’s Pursuit” it’s what plays during the asteroid field chase.

I just noticed that in the book, Palpatine’s line “Your master, Luke Skywalker, was saved by his father. The only family you have here is me” is actually “I’ve made this very proposal before. But on that unfortunate day Luke Skywalker had his father to save him. You do not.” And I was thinking, because he says the line “I’ve died before” earlier in the movie, would it be too hard to mix together the rest of the sentence, or something close to it? Because not only do I like this version better, but if we could then it would be possible to remove Rey saying “my parents were strong, they saved me from you” and still have the conversation flow rather naturally. It would go something like:

R: All you want is for me to hate but I won’t. Not even you.
P: I’ve made this proposal before. On that day, Luke Skywalker was saved by his father. The only family you have here… is me.

Personally, I prefer the shuttle because it means Ben, the last Skywalker, uses a ship associated with Palpatine while Rey, the (ex?)Palpatine, uses a ship that belonged to Luke Skywalker.