logo Sign In

DuracellEnergizer

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
30-May-2010
Last activity
30-Dec-2020
Posts
24,211

Post History

Post
#593708
Topic
What are you reading?
Time

darth_ender said:


What's funny is while I was looking for my review, the comment just before mine was this:


DuracellEnergizer said:

I kinda like the Jedi Academy Trilogy; it's how I'd imagine those old pulp magazines to be - not particularily well-written, but entertaining nonetheless.


 DOUBLE STANDARDS!!!

;)


And this is why no one, especially I, should make hasty judgements based on one complete novel, an abridged audiobook, and another novel that I had only read once before years ago as an undiscerning twelve/thirteen/something-year-old kid with little-to-no good taste.

Post
#593696
Topic
What are you reading?
Time

I just finished reading the infamous Jedi Academy Trilogy by the infamous Kevin J. Anderson. Beyond the general inanities, I actually found the first two books readable. Sure, the characters are rather flat and the Sun Crusher is probably the stupidest non-PT/SE concept to come out of the SW universe, but they were pretty much a quick, easy read, and some parts were even engrossing; I actually enjoyed reading the Kessel sections in Jedi Search (the first book). The third and final book, Champions of the Force, though ... that was painful; it seems the stupidity and cringeworthiness was dialled up a thousandfold for this entry. I ended up having to force myself to finish reading this, and I don't usually have to do that, not with any book.

With that out of the way, I've started reading I, Jedi by Michael A. Stackpole. It's supposed to retell, in part anyway, the Jedi Academy Trilogy story from the viewpoint of another character unmentioned in the original three books. It'll be interesting to see how this book compares and contracts with Anderson's story.

Post
#593075
Topic
Is "Empire Strikes Back" really George Lucas' least favorite?
Time

1990osu said:



walking_carpet said:

its one thing to say characters cannot be one way or another - but the characters in the PT have no depth and are not remotely compelling (except maybe palpatine).


IMO Palpatine was compelling because he had to be in order to remain consistent with the original trilogy.


Until he turned into Henrietta from Evil Dead II and started waving day-glo dildoes around, that is ...

Post
#592808
Topic
The Clone Wars: Season V
Time

I honestly wouldn't mind if Palpatine used lightsabers if

1. The lightsabers were stolen Jedi lightsabers (having him build and keep his own lightsaber pretty much renders his comments on lightsabers in ROTJ completely senseless)

2. Uses them sparingly

3. Uses them as a means to mock the Jedi and desecrate their weapon, not because he needs to

Post
#592586
Topic
The Clone Wars: Season V
Time

Darth Bizarro said:


So why exactly would it be acceptable to assume that Yoda would condone and even train a Jedi to use a lightsaber, and yet somehow completely ridiculous that he might use one himself.  That doesn't make any sense.  So yes, it is just a matter of opinion.


So if a parent teaches their child how to ride a bike, that automatically means they themselves have to ride or even own one of their own?

Post
#592578
Topic
Is "Empire Strikes Back" really George Lucas' least favorite?
Time

1990osu said:


2002 George Lucas interview:

Q: What religion are you?

A: I was raised Methodist. Now let's say I'm spiritual. It's Marin County. We're all Buddhists up here.

 

More evidence that Lucas underwent a major personality shift between the OT and the PT, which also explains the strong good versus evil undercurrent which for some reason he is so uncomfortable with in the PT.


Makes you wonder why he didn't give any of the PT villains redeemable qualities if he's so uncomfortable with stark black-and-white morality tales.

Post
#592562
Topic
Last comic read
Time

The Dark Empire trilogy

I still like the art, and the characterization of Palpatine (at least in DEI, anyway), but the story is a little on the weak side, especially with the final two entries in the trilogy. In DEI, too much vital information on Luke's initiation into the dark side is glossed over, briefly mentioned in passing rather than being shown to the viewer, and DEII & III feel like rough drafts that could have been good sequels with a little more development and polishing, but as they are feel rather pointless and unnecessary.

Overall, I don't hate the Dark Empire trilogy like some SW fans do, but it could have been far better.

Post
#592208
Topic
The Clone Wars: Season V
Time

Darth Bizarro said:


How does introducing a secondary set of villains prove that they should have been in the movies.  That's like saying that having the Black Sun appear as villains in Shadows of the Empire proves that they should have been in Empire Strikes Back.


Was Black Sun ever established as being a major antagonist in the OT timeline in various interviews, notes, and spinoff material back in the day only to ignored when TESB and ROTJ rolled around? No? Then your comparison fails.

First, the idea of whether the Emperor should or should not have a light-saber is entirely a mater of opinion, not forgone fact (same thing with Yoda BTW).  But even if that weren't up for debate, how exactly is the Emperor going to defend himself against two attackers simultaneously both of whom are wielding double bladed lightsabers with only one lightsaber.  He needs two so he can block two simultaneous attacks.


The guy's got access to telekinetic and electrokinetic abilities. Waving a neon sword around when he can just toss/block/kill a guy with his mind or fry him with bolts of lightning is stupid.

Post
#591952
Topic
A Post-ROTJ Trilogy: What's To Come for the Big Three, And More
Time

I have one question and one suggestion.

I'll start with the suggestion. Personally, I kind of find the name "Jeni" - or at least the spelling of "Jeni" - for your protagonist kind of weak. Could you perhaps throw an "H" or another extra letter or two in there, to give it some oomph?

As for the question ... It's kinda silly, but it's one of those things I'm always obsessing over; what colour is Jeni's lightsaber supposed to be? Is it the standard blue/green, or something more exotic?