I’ve had an idea and I’d like some opinions on it.
I cannot accomplish seamless branching within encore, however, I’ve realized I can create the illusion of seamless branching by making the branching point right after r2, 3po, and Luke enter the homestead (I believe this is a reel change as well) where there are a few seconds of black before it fades back in to 3po in the oil bath. At that point, while there would be a slight blip in the branching, it wouldn’t be noticeable because the screen is black for a couple seconds anyways.
The benefit to doing this is that the film overall would have to be compressed less than it would with two full encodes of the movie on one disc, and thus the film visually would look better throughout. The downside is that I would likely have to use the AVCHD versions of the 5.1, 2.0, and 1.0 tracks, as I wouldn’t begin to know how to edit the native dts tracks to fit the cut down runtime of the tracks, so there would be a very slight drop in audio quality.
So my question is, would you all rather me have lower video quality by having two separate tracks for each version of the movie with higher quality audio, or higher quality video by branching at that point, but sacrificing a little bit of audio quality? Personally, I prefer video quality to audio quality, and don’t really hear a difference between the avchd tracks and the mkv tracks, but I admittedly don’t have much of an ear for audio quality.
Or hey, if anyone knows how I can make the dts audio fit the cut down tracks, all the better, but I’m oblivious to how I could do it.