logo Sign In

Commander Courage

User Group
Members
Join date
16-Aug-2004
Last activity
1-Oct-2015
Posts
724

Post History

Post
#128505
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Trooperman:

"Shroud of the Dark Side" it is, then. I rather like your suggestion of giving Episode 1 no subtitle; in this case it would actually make sense to title the first film of the series "Star Wars," as opposed to the fourth. More input on this from others would be welcome.

And I really do wish you could have the crawl redone just once more. It is one of most effective ways of altering fan edits, and establishing Padme's Queen/Senator relationship would go a long way. Your "deadline" isn't until Christmas, so surely something could be worked out.

I've been meaning to ask you about releasing a trailer for SotDS, and what you've suggested is along those lines, but more of rough behind-the-scenes stuff if you will. As MTHaslett said, anything not up to par will be ripe for ridicule. My suggestion would be to wait until you have enough finished product and put together an offical looking trailer if it wouldn't be too much trouble. THAT would be awesome.
Post
#127061
Topic
<strong>The Official Greencapt 'Batman &amp; Robin: De-Assified' Edit thread</strong> (Released)
Time
Yes, if one takes Batman: The Movie properly, as a parody, it's quite a hillarious movie and does its job well.

The problem with Batman & Robin is not only was the 60s style inappropriate for a 1990s movie franchise that had already been established as a serious, quality version of Batman, it was badly executed at that!
Post
#127059
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Queen Padme Amidala serving as Senator! I like it, a lot!

You mentioned the opening crawl, I had been meaning to bring that up again. I know we've been over this before (and you have the final say of course) but the title, which I was satisfied with originally, I really do think should be changed considering you plan to go with "Balance of the Force," and "Revenge of the Sith," for I and III. This makes the entire PT consist of ___ of the ___ titles. "Dark Force Rising" or "Dark Force Ascendent" have always been favorites of mine. I do like "Shroud of the Dark Side," I just think it will be a bit repetitive. And I would alter your crawl in the following manner:

Episode II
DARK FORCE ASCENDENT

It has been ten years since Surpeme Chancellor Palpatine assumed leadership of the Galactic Senate, and unrest once again pervades galaxy. Several thousand systems have declared their intentions to secede from the Republic.

This separatist movement, under the leadership of the mysterious Count Dooku, have made it especially difficult for the limited number of Jedi Knights to maintain peace and order in the galaxy.

Queen Padme Amidala, now serving as Senator of Naboo, is en route to Coruscant to vote on the critical issue of creating an ARMY OF THE REPUBLIC to assist the overwhelmed Jedi....

Palpatine wasn't exactly elected, so "assuming leadrship" is more in line with his dubious rise to power. The full titles of Palpatine and Padme make everything more 'official.' I made reference to Padme's current political status, and overall altered the crawl to match more with the original. And while I see where you were trying to parallel the last paragraph of ANH's text with "pursued by....," and while it does sound more dynamic, it's not exactly a true repesentation of what's going on. Those are just my suggestions, and once again you're the boss, so if you don't agree with them/don't want to redo the opening I understand.

And I take it you're referring to my notes about Padme remaining a Queen. Yes, some of the edits work regardless. Such as cutting Windu telling Anakin to ask Palpatine about Padme leaving Coruscant. Now it plays as Anakin going to tell his friend and mentor the good news about finally getting a mission of his own.

I'm glad you and MF got in contact and collaborated on the Syfo-Dias solution. I look forward to be surprised by something in this edit!

And since you can control the pitch of audio I wouldn't worry about Jar-Jar's yodelling in TPM and go for the German version!
Post
#126964
Topic
<strong>The Official Greencapt 'Batman &amp; Robin: De-Assified' Edit thread</strong> (Released)
Time
Indeed, greencapt. An improvement of ANY kind to this film is more than welcome. I'm not expecting something of Batman/Batman Begins quality, and I'm not one who totally loathes Schumacher (I thought Batman Forever was a good movie), so chances are I'll enjoy this edit. If not, it will still be interesting to see what was done to the film to improve it, although I won't remember enough to pick up on most of the changes anyway!
Post
#126960
Topic
Help: looking for... &quot;King Kong&quot; and &quot;Son of Kong&quot; - in Color
Time

With the mention of kinds of movies in this forum now I figured this was the right place for this.

King Kong has been one of my favorite movies since I was a little kid, but the only copies I have are taped off TV. I am well aware that both KK and SoK were originally made in B&W, but I grew up watching them in color, and really couldn’t watch them any other way. Since neither have yet come out on DVD, and even when they do I doubt it will include the colorized versions, I wondered if anyone around here could help me out. Does anyone have/know of any way to aquire these things? Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Post
#126957
Topic
***The &quot;Darth Editous&quot; Episode IV DVD Info and Feedback Thread*** - a partially &quot;de-specialed&quot; DVD
Time
Erik: First Class covers! I like your color scheme personally, and don't see what all the fuss is about. And e veryone seems to have gotten the THX video covers confused: ANH was blue, ESB was purple, and RotJ was red. I much prefer yours to those selections.

DE: "8. R2 uses the wrong tool to "access" the power outlet." Were you going to edit this but out? I quite liked it and don't see why you'd want to cut it.
Post
#126661
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Jar-Jar: I didn't know you could alter audio enough to lower the pitch of his voice; that's an excellent idea! And I'm all for giving him some class with British-style subtitles if you think it'll work w/out being distracting.

"Darth Dooku": This could all work very well into a possible Maul=Grevious subplot, as Dooku will in no way be reffered to as "Darth." (And I know you'll be changing Yoda's line, but it still makes more sense mind my mind). Of course Palpatine refers to him as a Sith Lord in RotS, so unless you'd want to edit around that, he'll simply be "Count Dooku: Sith Lord." For the end of Episode 2, I'd suggest either cutting Sidious 1st line, or pluging in a Palpatine "Count Dooku" from RotS.

Queen/Senator Amidala: If I understand correctly, the plan is Padme is a born Queen, but she's reffered to as Senator in 2&3 as it is the capacity she is currently serving in? Where does that leave the line, "I was the youngest queen ever elected, and I'm not sure I was ready," and the rest of Anakin and Padme's walk on Naboo for that matter? Were you still going to bring this up in a Gunray/Dooku conversation? If not, what were plans on how to do that? Regardless of my questions, I think this is a good solution that covers most of everything, and is in-line with the point I was trying to make earlier about Princess Leia serving in the Imperial Senate. Only then she was still referred to as "Princess," which is what I was suggesting be altered with Padme, a few references to "Queen" here and there. But overall I think we've found our answer.

Speaking of Kevin(), did he ever reveal to you his way of removing the nowhere subplot of Syfo-Dias ordering the clones? I'm not asking for this apparently secret info, but was curious as to whether you had a way/were going to use his way in SotDS?

Screencaps: WOW. There is no argument the environments look unquestionably improved and realistic. However, Anakin and Padme's skin seems to have turned blue as a side effect. Is there any way around this?
Post
#125484
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
-The Geonosians are not actually seen until the dark tunnel with Anakin and Padme- artistic thing.
That works; suspense and all that. (I assume this is excluding Poggle the Lesser) That makes for only two edits IIRC: The Geonosians watching Obi-Wan record his message and the guards outside Obi-Wan's cell.

The Lucas audio is a very creative change, an easter egg to look out for. The nightmare is sounding very intense, which is a very good thing, it should be! I can't wait to see the finshed product for this scene in particular. One question though, in the next scene Anakin is looking out a window? This would be Padme's apartment, but weren't you going to cut that scene?

Sure-I can make it blue. Is the problem with green that the purple might show through, while if you use blue, it wouldn’t be a big deal?
That is part of it yes, not to mention Mace's lightsaber was blue for a long time in the EU before Lucas officially gave-in to Sam Jackson's request of purple. All that aside, I think it just looks better/suits him better than green.

Similarly, in Episode III, when Palpatine says, “Count Dooku,” and we see Dooku accompanied by battle droids- the motif will go there as well. It’s important for me to tie things up musically between the films as well.
Funny you should mention that, as it is THE scene I envision of Dooku when listening to the theme. I believe we'll find it fits there the best out of all the Dooku stuff.

Even so, what do you think of a small hint of the “Lawrence of Arabia” theme when Anakin and Padme come to Tatooine?
That's a thought. Are we wanting to give Tatooine a theme here? Maybe, but I think there are some things that are fine just the way they are. I don't want to overkill the altered music, as it is one of my favorite aspects, but it's appropriate in some places and inappropriate in others.

That’s a good idea-would you know where to find the audio?
About the final scene with Dooku and Sidious- Palpatine no longer addresses Dooku as Tyrannus (the reference is also cut during the talk with Jango)

So even with Dooku as a Sith, there is no "Darth Tyranus"? That would technically make him "Darth Dooku," and I'm not too sure about that. Of course, NO ONE calls him Tyranus outside that one conversation in AotC, but surely there is a good way to handle this.

And yes, anyone with extensive knowledge of Christopher Lee's filmography: Help! Surely SOMETHING along the lines of, "No, wait! You don't understand! He's---," can be cobbled together. The look he gives Palpatine is good, yes, but I really do think dialogue like that would enhance the scene and give Dooku an even more shocking death.

Indeed! You two have consistently provided excellent feedback with this (while nearly everyone else has lost interest) and therefore it seems fitting that you should be rewarded accordingly. Of course, a disc goes to Rikter because he distributes these and puts them on the Internet for others to see.

Thanks TM, I don't see why more people wouldn't be interested in a project like this. It's the most ambitious fan edit yet, and your idea of working together to brainstorm and bounce ideas around is certainly making for a superior product. I think I can speak for MTHaslett when I say WE have the easy job; coming up with ideas in our spare time is fun, but YOU have to figure out a way to execute everything, not to mention the time it's going to take to put all this together. I salute you!

I had never thought of that…hmmm. The way I really wanted to do this was for Padme to be a queen from birth, and then she resigns for some reason and becomes a Senator for II and III. Maybe she resigns because she doesn’t believe in the monarchy. I’ll really have to think about how to do this.

Yeah, Lucas really left us with quite a dilemma. I appreciate his attempts to show a different culture in that galaxy far, far away by having an elected Queen, but the fact that she is FOURTEEN is rather silly. Add to that the fact that Padme tells Anakin in AotC she "wasn't the youngest Queen ever elected." Ridiculous. It would make MUCH more sense for her to be born a Queen and remain one throughout life. But MTHaslett does make a really good point about, "So this is how Liberty dies? To thunderous applause." And yes, the confusing nature of all the titles in Star Wars makes this all the more difficult. But I don't think "resigning" from being Queen is the answer, nor is it necessary. My comparison to Leia was not in reference to her being Padme's daughter, rather SHE fought for democracy and served in the Senate as a Princess, and was referred to as "Your Highness" and all that. Princess and Queen here are both titles of ceremony, but Leia and Padme choose to take the next step and actually serve their people in the democratic system of the Republic (and later the Imperial Senate).

What do you think of Jar-Jar…speaking in English with either an uneducated British accent or an Australian accent? This would make him different and in contrast with all the other Gungans. It could also possibly give him some charm and wit lacking in any of the other versions. Utilizing some of the Magnoliafan subtitles and some of the original material (and my own ideas), his new dialogue would be recorded in synch with the character’s lips (not hard, as it’s a CG character).

I still think an alien language is the best way to go with the Gungans and Nemoidians. I like the line about the beard though. And you keep referring to MagnoliaFan as Kevin, as in Kevin Smith, but I think it's been pretty much confirmed he is NOT Kevin Smith.
Post
#125145
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Queen Padme Amidala: I'm not sure how much of this applies to your edit, as what scenes and line have been added/cut. The Four People whose lines would have to be altered would be: Padme, Obi-Wan, Palpatine, and Mace (Anakin is not a problem as you're redubbing him anyway). All 4 of these characters have lines in TPM that can be scavenged for use in SotDS. "Queen," "Your Majesty," and "My Lady," can all serve as substitutes for "Senator."

PALPATINE: "Oh, but I do [your majesty].

ANAKIN: So have you...grown more beautiful I mean [cut]...for a Senator I mean[cut].

TYPHO: I'm very grateful you're here, Master Kenobi. I'm Captain Typho, head of Her Majesty's security service. [cut]Queen Jamillia has informed you of your
assignment.[cut] The situation is more dangerous than the [Queen] will admit.

OBI-WAN: We're here to protect you [cut]Senator[cut], not to start an investigation

[cut]OBI-WAN: Do you know who it was you were trying to kill?
ZAM WESSEL: The Senator from Naboo.[cut]
OBI-WAN: Who hired you?
ZAM WESSEL: It was just a job.

YODA: Track down this bounty hunter, you must, Obi-Wan.
MACE WINDU: Most importantly, find out who he's working for.
OBI-WAN: What about [Queen] Amidala? She will still need protecting.
YODA: Handle that, your Padawan will.
MACE WINDU: Anakin, escort [the Queen] back to her home planet of Naboo. She'll be safer there. And don't use registered transport. Travel as refugees.
ANAKIN: As the leader of the opposition, it will be very difficult to get [her] to leave the Capital.
YODA: Until caught this killer is, our judgement she must respect.
[cut]MACE WINDU: Anakin, go to the Senate and ask Chancellor Palpatine to speak with her.[cut]

[cut] PALPATINE: I will talk to her. Senator Amidala will not refuse an executive order. I know her well enough to assure you of that.
ANAKIN: Thank you, your Excellency.[cut]

The entire apartment scene with Jar-Jar will be cut, as it will be implied he is the permanent Senator from Naboo (see later).

Btw, I don't know why everyone takes out "Don't worry, we have Artoo with us" I like the line; it's a natural thing to say in an awkward situation, and wouldn't be questioned if it was in the OT.

The entire scene of them walking the streets of Naboo will be cut. After the establishing shot of them landing in Theed cut to them approaching Theed.

MACE WINDU: Do you think these cloners are involved in the plot to assassinate [Queen Amidala]?

The alien dialogue is easy to change in subtitles.

MACE WINDU: Anakin, We will deal with Count Dooku. The most important thing for you is to stay where you are. Protect [Amidala] at all costs. That is your first
priority.

MAS AMEDDA: This is a crisis! The Senate must vote the Chancellor emergency powers! He could then approve the use of the clones.
PALPATINE: But what Senator would have the courage to propose such a radical amendment?
[cut]MAS AMEDDA: If only Senator Amidala were here.[cut]
Shot of Jar-Jar deep in thought; he is Senator of Naboo.

OBI-WAN: On his way to Naboo. He is escorting [Queen Amidala] home. I have to admit, without the clones, it would not have been a victory.

That's a pretty good overview of how to keep Amidala a Queen throughout. I have no idea the logistics of making that work technically, though. Thoughts?
Post
#125114
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
The Episode II dream has evolved into a rather long and kind of abstract piece of work, so just about anything can fit at this point.

I really like the way you are handling the dreams, and would suggest altering those in RotS to match. It seems MagnoliaFan is doing something similar in his dream, incorporating dialogue from Qui-Gon and Shmi as well. I would edit it just a bit different from you however:

Qui-Gon: It will be a hard life. One without reward. One without remorse. One without regret.
Shmi: Don’t look back. Anakin…
Anakin: Mother…
(Images and sounds of Tuskens attacking (from ANH), and beat up Shmi)
Anakin: No…please, no…mom!
(Cut to the close up of Anakin awakening from his nightmare)

I'd be against intercutting Anakin squirming in bed, as it takes focus away from the dream and just look awkward. The final shot of him opening his eyes at the end would be more effective, IMO.


http://img345.imageshack.us/img345/2424/zmace1blue4al.jpg
http://img345.imageshack.us/img345/3109/zmace2blue4uz.jpg
If you're going to change Mace's blade color, blue is definitely what to make it. I'm sure you'll be a good judge of whether it looks good or not.

Certainly. Dooku doesn’t really have a theme as much as just the 4-note motif from Uranus, and it doesn’t show up often- only once in a while for dramatic effect. For instance, it’s introduced when Dooku enters the interrogation room (where Obi-Wan is held). It is heard again in the arena as Dooku comes out. And finally, as Dooku turns around to face Obi-Wan and Anakin, it is used again.

I quite liked the "Seperatist Theme" used in AotC, very subtle, but effective. The Holst will be a neat alteration though. And I'm glad you decided against using the 2001 motif at the beginning of the duel (too recognizable).

You seem to have thought through everything about Dooku being a Sith, and I do like him and Sidious' final scene. A future RotS change I think is necessary with this would be a sound clip of Christopher Lee saying something along the lines of, "Wait! You don't understand!" Then Anakin cuts his head off.

I have to get III done before I to complete my recording for Anakin. Without III, II is incompatible in SW. Another big picture plan- for Episode I, I am going to use a prologue before the Main Titles. It seems fitting to provide some history before beginning a 6-film saga. So we have the fanfare along with the Fox Logo, Lucasfilm Lmtd., etc. etc. Then, instead of going directly to "A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away," we go to a new frame of text. "A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away, there was a great war. The Jedi Knights, guardians of peace and justice..." etc. We have brief shots of battles and spaceships and other things in between the background story. I'll need to do research into the EU for ideas on this.

This is a very intriguing idea, one that certainly merits more in-depth discussion at a later time.

Queen Padme Amidala: I'm not sure how much of this applies to your edit, as what scenes and line have been added/cut. The Four People whose lines would have to be altered would be: Padme, Obi-Wan, Palpatine, and Mace (Anakin is not a problem as you're redubbing him anyway). All 4 of these characters have lines in TPM that can be scavenged for use in SotDS. "Queen," "Your Majesty," and "My Lady," can all serve as substitutes for "Senator." I'll have something more specific later.

At present, I am only committed to sending out 3 copies of this- one to Rikter, one to MTHaslett, and one to Commander Courage. I can't commit to any more, so Rikter will be the distributor (unless MTH or CC make copies as well).

I'm honored to be on the short list! My extreme nerditude is paying off!
Post
#123788
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Yes, I felt it was about time to change my signatue. But when my Batman phase runs out, maybe the genius of Al Gore will return.

Back to busiess, as it were, MTHaslett once again has excellent input. I'm in agreement on pretty much everything, except for the replacement of Across the Stars with the Han & Leia theme. AtS is an excellent piece and fits the romance appropriately. Han & Leia's theme belongs in the OT...with Han & Leia. But other than that, listen to him TM!

"Obi-Wan's going to burn me alive." *cringe* I think it would best to leave only Anakin's sigh of frustration in reaction to his broken lightsaber. No in-joke one-liners please.

Qui-Gon: I've been thinking of ways to expand his role in the saga, as he is also my favorite charcter in the prequels (Liam Neeson is also my favorite actor). A good source would be the Episode 1 tone poems (I've mentioned these before in one of Obi-wanton's threads). I don't know if you're familiar with them, but Qui-Gon's goes as such:

It will be a hard life.
One without reward. One without remorse. One with regret.
A path will be placed before you. The choice is yours alone.
It will be a hard life, but you will find out who you are.

I have several idea on how to utilize this. One being during Qui-Gon's funeral parts of this could echo in Anakin's head. However, based on how you are handling his dreams, they would be an ideal place in insert the voice of Qui-Gon. Perhaps in the first dream quote "It will be a hard life," and in the second, include the complete first and second lines. Then in RotS, during the ruminations sequence, the third line. along with some spliced dialogue, "[You are] [the Chosen one]." I'm getting a bit ahead of myself here, but you get the idea.

As far as the overall music goes, I'm really excited to see how your alterations it into the film, as music (especially in Star Wars) can make a HUGE difference. Though I like the choice of "Uranus" as Dooku's theme, don't you think it's a bit bombastic, and is bound to get repetitive after awhile. Although you might have all this worked out already and rearranged it. Either way I think this merits more discussion.

You mentioned rotoscoping lightsaber before; I would love to get a screenshot of your attempts. I'm going to soon have After Effects, and the first thing I'm going to play around with is rotoscoping. Mace should have a blue blade, definitely. Now I've always thought Dooku should have a purple blade for quite a few reasons:
-Variety. Jedi: Blue and Green, Sith: Red and Purple.
-Symbolism. Dooku is a mix between Jedi (blue) and Sith (red), which of course makes (purple).
-Royalty. As Sam Jackson often reiterates, purple is the color of royalty. Dooku is a Count after all, so there's a connection there as well.
I know it would be a pain to rotoscope, but if I ever figure out what I'm doing, I'll do it myself anyway. The ONLY disadvantage would be in RotS when Anakin takes Dooku's saber; as it stands now he holds in his hands the balance of good and evil. I'd really hate to loose that, but if we're reinventing the charcter of Dooku the lightsaber is a good place to start.

I believe we've discussed before the subject of Dooku being or not being a Sith, and you sided with the official scenario. There are various advantages and intriguing story points to both, but especially with Dooku no longer using Force lightning, it would be all the easier to make him a rouge agent of the Force. This ties into my editing wish that Grevious=Maul, but that is for a later discussion.

I don't have time to expand on the logistic of Queen Padme Amildala, but I will I get the chance.

What I've been keeping in mind, and I hope we all will, is that Episode 2 in whatever form it mayt be needs to be able to fit into Episode 3. We all have our ideas on what to do with that film as well, so before setting into stone anything in this one, we should consider how that will impact any alterations we'd want to make to the next one. The goal is to not only make everything more like the OT, but to enhance the prequels into a tighter trilogy and story of its own (which will help along the former objective as well).
Post
#123165
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Trooperman: Seeing this edit come along the way it has is great, especially now that things are getting more and more concrete.

Of course I have some feedback:

Breaking up Anakin's nightmare adds a much greater importance to them, and the placing after his conversation w/Palpatine is excellent. I'm not so sure about the fade to black, however. ANH is the only film to use these, and I think a wipe similar to what was done w/the nightmares in RotS would make for more continuity. And have you found a way to replicate the dream effects used in Episode 3?

The plan for the duel looks good, but I have to plead with you not to use that HORRIBLE shot of CGI Anakin leaping across the room.

Interesting you mention lightsaber sound effects, as I believe Magnolia Fan did something similar in BotF. Personally I think it is unecessary as I enjoy the variety of sound effects. Btw, has anyone noticed they changed several of the sounds effetcs in the ANH duel for the DVD? Originally they sounded quite a bit different than the other duels. While I appreciate them FINALLY fixing the visuals, I wish they would have left the audio alone. Again, variety is a good thing in some areas.

As for Anakin's possible soliloquy, I say try it and if it doesn't work, just cut it.

Two thoughts of my own:

Have you considered expanding Qui-Gon's role at all, or at least found a suitable replacement for "NOOOOO!"?

And I don't know if you've seen ADM's edits, but one of the things he did was remove all references to Padme as a "Senator," and her being an elected Queen. She is thus a Queen thoughout the PT just as Leia is a Princess thoughout the OT. Of course this would take some substantial editing, most notably the removal of Padme and Anakin's conversation as they arrive on Naboo. What ADM didn't do that I thought would help the idea along was whenever possible insert someone saying "Queen" where "Senator" used to be. I've thought a lot of this though, so if you're interested in this possibility let me know and I can more thouroughly lay-out my ideas.
Post
#119290
Topic
Six DVD set to look like this?
Time
At first I really thought this list might be possible, and was very pleased with the potential changes, but as I went down the list I found it to be a bit too fanboyish, seriously calling its validity into question:
-9. Luke looks upset when Biggs dies and he sheds a tear (all CGI & PRT)
-4. A scene has been added where Yoda is teaching Luke how to fight with a lightasber made possible by Luke wearing a helmet while training (a stunt double plays him)
-5. The Wampa scenes have been edited and restored into the film as well as new scenes added. We see a Wampa being brought into the Rebel base and locked into a room with other Wampa’s. Later C-3PO knocks the sign off the door the Wampa’s are behind stating their there and when the Stormtroopers enter the base they open the door only to be attacked by the Wampa’s who then can be seen escaping as the Millennium Falcon blasts off out of Hoth
-8. Some of Yoda's facial expressions have been improved beacuse of CGI
-1. In the battle on Endor more Ewoks and Stormtroopers can be seen fighting and dieing and some parts of the battle have been edited out, members of Han’s team can be seen fighting as well (these scenes were shot during the production of Episode I, 7 years ago)
-2. Vader uses the force to reclaim his lightasber after he throws it at Luke and the sound of him turning it on again has been removed
-5. Vader has a flashback of Padme after his talk with Luke when he first meets him on Endor (filmed during Episode III)
-6. Kassykk & Utapau have been added to the end celebration scenes
-7. Some of Yoda's facial expressions have been improved beacuse of CGI
-9. Chewbacca's Tarzan call has been removed

Some of these are quite outlandish, not to mention unecessary; Luke crying and Vader's flashback in particular.
Post
#115412
Topic
Gripes About The Matrix Trilogy
Time
The Matrix is one of those movies that, if stand alone, would have become a cult sci-fi classic in years to come.

However, since they DID make more, it will now be remembered as yet another franchise that started out with unlimited potential that was squandered by inferior sequels.

(Btw, Master Sifo-Dyas, those are some good points that articulate many of my gripes about Reloaded and Revolutions.)
Post
#115287
Topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Time
Wow, klokwerk. That is FIRST CLASS. But of course, I have some constructive critcism.

-The "Trooperman's" on the front is certainly creative, but I think the standard "Star Wars" is the best way to go with that.
-What' with the Trademark symbol on the spine? Or is that TM for Trooperman? Either way I'd remove it.
-And if there's a way to shorten Anakin's saber on the back, perhaps tilting it a bit more to the left, because that thing is WAY too long.

Sorry if I sound like a delegator; that's some excellent work. I only wish I had Photoshop skills as good.