- Post
- #518411
- Topic
- Last movie seen
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/518411/action/topic#518411
- Time
EyeShotFirst said:
RedFive said:
Plus, I was pleasantly surprised by the work of David Yates, who really put his own mark on the movie, which I didn't expect for part 7 of a 7 part series.
Actually, each Potter film is pretty different in style and look.
Also, Yates has directed every installment since #5. So he's done 4 Potter movies (3 if you count the two Deathly Hallowses as a single film), more than any other Potter director. (Interestingly, his films are all my favorites, despite the fact that 5 and 6 change a lot from the books.)
I also quite enjoyed HP7.5, but I don't think I can separate part 1 from part 2 and judge them on their own merits. I'm definitely cutting them together as a single film when part 2 comes out on DVD/Blu-Ray. (Not cutting anything out either, but I don't mind a 4.5-hour long movie - the "uncut" version of Das Boot is my favorite and it's 4 and a half hours long, too.)
Anyway, most recent movie I've seen:
Cowboys & Aliens
The first hour of it was absolutely magnificent, with great performances, great direction, and a compelling story long before the aliens arrive. In fact, I'd absolutely love to have seen just the Cowboys side of this flick, without any of the Aliens.
Ford's Dolarhyde and Craig's Lonergan are initially set up as antagonist and protagonist (respectively), but Craig's character has enough dark shades so as to be potentially as dangerous as Dolarhyde, if not more so. One of the best moments in the film comes when Lonergan is chained to a wagon together with Paul Dano's Percy (Dolarhyde's son) - as the aliens begin to attack, Lonergan asks Percy to give him his hand.
"Why?" asks Percy.
"I can get us out of here," responds Lonergan.
Warily, Percy raises his shackled hand to Lonergan ... who promptly breaks his wrist in order to get the shackle off.
At this point I should mention that the supporting cast - from Dano to Sam Rockwell to Keith Carradine - are all fantastic, especially Dano and Rockwell. Olivia Wilde isn't particularly revelatory - if you liked her in her past work, you'll like her here.
Now here we run into my problem with the movie - the last half hour.
The beginning 10 minutes of the film is essentially The Bourne Identity plus A Fistful of Dollars. Then the Bourne aspect gradually fades as District 9 and Aliens get thrown into the mix.
All of this is great, very enjoyable, and I loved almost every minute of it.
Then for the last half hour it turns into Independece Day on horseback in the desert.
Which is fine if you weren't expecting the moral ambiguity of the two leads to continue to be the driving force of the movie ... but it doesn't. In fact, their shades of gray almost entirely evaporate by the time the final battle starts. Both Dolarhyde and Lonergan are essentailly heroes at this point, and they don't really do anything that could be considered morally reprehensible for the last act of the film.
That's not quite what I was expecting. It felt like the studio got the original script, liked the first 2/3 of it, then said, "Well, we're giving you a bunch of money to do this, so make them good guys by the end." This idea may be supported by the fact that there are, like, 6 writers credited on the film.
So in the end, I found it very enjoyable, but all the complexity and nuance just vanishes in the last half hour.
7/10.