- Post
- #1566570
- Topic
- <em>REY NOBODY</em> - A Collaborative Thread
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1566570/action/topic#1566570
- Time
Finally! The journey reaches its end - again. XD
Finally! The journey reaches its end - again. XD
Good to know, BD!
Movie Dumbledore has been made as nice as any of us can make him, Rev. š
So, have we settled on a crawl yet? XD
Are we never gonna reach a consensus on the crawl? XD
You made a wise choice sharing your work here, luc. š
Still looking forward to this! Iāll give it a watch as soon as itās ready!
it has to feel organic, important and complimentary to the original film - or it will come across as cheap and fanedit-y.
I acknowledge that such material has to be used sparingly, otherwise it wonāt work. Iām sorry I didnāt make that clear. XD
You still have the clip of Dooku at Qui-Gonās funeral?
Iām loving these new ideas! If weāre gonna get as much story as we can out of the films, then why not turn to external sources? š
Youāve done your own edits as well, Jimmy?
House of Gaunt fan-film would be great for a HBP edit!
I wonder how that would fit in?
Such incredible use of a fan film Iāve heard of, but never actually checked out until now! If this is how youāll be treating David Yatesā next two Potters, consider me as hooked as can be! š
This was in the past. Look at the READ ME document in his drive. I am not sure if it is appropriate for me to post this information in these forums.
If requested, I will remove the posts if desired by Andreas.
I have no idea where it is anymore. š
Wait a minute! I didnāt know Andreas was sick!
Iāll get to watching in a bit! š
No matter, I can always pick my own favourite edits of each individual movie while following your recommended viewing order. š
You are a GOD at strategising these things! Based on quality, would you recommend any edits of the movies?
I never saw that Prisoner and Goblet had been released. If they are, Iād certainly like to check them out.
Actually, Iām a beta viewer. Itās quite common with fan edits. š
CaMSmurph:
Are the Harry Potter movies available on his drive?
I am not sure if something was changed, but his drive is now indicating I need permission to access.
Also, thanks for the review without the spoilers. I would love to watch these even more now.
Iāve lost access as well. I have no idea whatās happened, but I guess Andreas will keep us updated.
Both outstanding from beginning to end! The new intro in PoA should give you an idea on what to expect. As PoA is rightfully considered the best in the series, little has been altered, save for a few nitpicks.
The new colour grade helps bring back the warmth of the first two movies, and as the story gets darker, so do the colours. What a way to compliment the mature storytelling!
Cuts are seamless throughout, and in keeping with musical continuity, Andreas brings back John Williamsā classic themes from Sorcererās Stone and Chamber of Secrets. PoA is Williamsā final contribution to the Harry Potter series and it really is a shame that his themes werenāt brought over from this point onward. God bless Andreas for remedying this in the best way possible!
Also, keep your eye out for a few clever cameos. š
GoF is just as good, if not better. Dark and difficult times lie ahead, indeed. Andreas has put together a much scarier affair than the theatrical version. This is particularly evident in the graveyard. The changes to Voldemort, in particular, are really something else. I wonāt elaborate as I feel this should be viewed as blindly as possible.
The restructuring here is something no other GoF edit has done. It actually improves the story incredibly well to have the Yule Ball take place after the Second Task. That way, the Second and Third Tasks donāt feel like they take place mere weeks apart.
This is also the first of the Ultimate Editions to make use of select deleted scenes, all of which have been cropped and upscaled to fit the IMAX format Andreas has prepped for these new editions. The additional scenes in question add some important plot details and character moments which, I daresay, shouldnāt have been left out. This truly feels like a more complete experience!
The new sound mix in both edits is nothing short of impeccable. The SFX and ambience in certain scenes makes the environment feel moreā¦ magical. Thatās all I will say on the matter.
While I can certainly point out a few things that need improving, I think I speak for everyone when I say, Andreas doesnāt disappoint! Thank you, good sir, for keeping the magic alive. And extra special thanks to Chloe of Fanedit.org for helping him through this! Well bloody done to both of you! š
Canāt wait for Order of the Phoenix through Deathly Hallows!
Take your time, dude! Do you have any planned changes for V2?
Oh, yeah. I love watching deleted scenes. I thought you wanted all of that put into the movies.
I wouldnāt mind watching them on their own. š
I canāt believe Iām seeing a Finn in this movie that actually feels like he went through TLJās character arc.
Neither can I. Still no Duel of the Fates, but weāll take what we can get. š
George Lucas would be proud.