Sign In

CamSMurph

User Group
Members
Join date
8-Aug-2017
Last activity
24-Jun-2021
Posts
182

Post History

Post
#1436273
Topic
Harry Potter and the Magical Touch of Editing (Released)
Time

almightycutie said:

Ah I thought you meant removing the whole sequence, not just the lines about where they are going. I guess the lines don’t bother me enough to change it. I’m sure some other edits have made that change though, especially all the ones that have combined the final two movies.

So you’re basically leaving the scene as is?

Post
#1436254
Topic
Harry Potter and the Magical Touch of Editing (Released)
Time

almightycutie said:

I think that particular scene does break some of the serious tension happening, but with how it plays out and leads into McGonagall talking to Harry I don’t know how I’d remove it. I guess I don’t really mind that scene though.

The only thing I really wanted to change, and I might go back and try again, was the Harry flying through the air with Voldemort during their fight, and blending into each other. I liked most everything else about the movie though.

I think it’s easy to remove the following exchange:
Filch: Exactly where is it I’ll be leading them to, ma’am?
McGonagall: The dungeons would do.

Post
#1436191
Topic
Harry Potter and the Magical Touch of Editing (Released)
Time

almightycutie said:

I wasn’t aiming to just make extended editions. JJPotter already made great, fully extended copies. I only added the ones that I thought enhanced the movies. If I thought the deleted scene detracted from the tone or pacing, or just didn’t fit in very well then I didn’t add it.

Right. How come you haven’t removed anything from DH P2? I personally would have removed McGonagall sending Slytherin House to the dungeons. :v

Post
#1434523
Topic
Harry Potter Extended Editions (Released)
Time

Master Lawdog said:

Is there any way that deleted shots and scenes that were present in trailers and unused music can be a part of these?

That sounds like a real challenge, but in no way impossible. That would make them pure “Extended Editions” in a sense. I hope JJ finds the motivation to resume production on these edits soon and ups the ante in terms of editing. The transitions could use smoothening out, and some aren’t really needed. Just look at the Half-Blood Prince EE for instance.