Bobson Dugnutt

One comment on his channel in particular isn’t very favourable about us

The guys in the “forum” are super salty right now and so so sooo jealous you had made money from your craft and they are living in their grand parents basement.

Well actually, I live in my parents attic for starters. And secondly, why is forum in “quotation marks”? And thirdly, I don’t think making profit from fanediting is a good thing…

Sir Ridley said:

I’m considering it, if the shots fit in seamlessly and make the sequence better then I will include them.

I’ve added the shot of Kylo igniting his saber in the forest for my own perpetually unfinished edit. It fits the scene well and besides the hood being present, it works well. I added a lot of the cut stuff from the trailers and TV spots before stopping work after Finn wakes up in the desert.

https://vimeo.com/247987600

suspiciouscoffee said:
27 minutes, color, mono

Thank god you clarified it’s in colour, so many fanedits these day don’t mention it and I’m left in a state of confusion and disarray.

I haven’t even seen it yet, but if it’s anything like Rogue One, I can already guess that trimming and cutting the excessive fan service and cameos would improve the film.

The 1080p No-DNR version of 4k77 is also now up on Mega. PM me if you want it.

It appears that the UHD version is now up on Mega. 84gb in total. PM me if anyone wants it

stretch009 said:

Google is your friend.

It really wasn’t, I thought it was some other private tracker like Myspleen but then there were different providers and fees and I found more questions than answers

RU.08 said:

You can use a free provider like free-usenet.com, the only catch is the download rate is limited to 1Mbps so it will take a while to download.

I got as far as making an account installing BinBar, but now it wants a host and a port. I’m hopelessly clueless about this sorta thing.

Possessed said:

Man dorms have really strict rules these days.

Not just the man dorms, but the women dorms and the children dorms too!

RU.08 said:

ChainsawAsh said:

You’ll probably have to wait until it makes its way onto public trackers, at least as far as the apparently-forever-closed-for-invites MySpleen goes.

I’m pretty sure someone will upload it to alt.binaries.starwars soon, so just keep an eye on that if you aren’t on the Spleen.

Isn’t that on Usenet? Which is a paid thing? I’ve heard it come up every now and again and I still don’t understand how it works

thebluefrog said:

There’s some deleted and unfinished FX footage of the Mustafar fight that I’ve never seen anyone use. Could be something to look into for some alternate angles and shots.

Some of them are used here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O84zsjLvOfk

Like Obi-Wan and Anakin fighting on a cliff instead.

Where did these scenes come from? Were they compiled from trailers or elsewhere beacuse I’ve never seen these before

bruceleekato said:

Star Wars Special Edition 2004 : Official DVD
Star Wars Special Edition 2011 : Official Blu-Ray

The greatest 2 fanedits of all time, its a real shame some low-life scum sell theses people’s hard work on Ebay for profit and personal gain.

Did you just look up a list of offical releases and now you want every single one for collection purposes or something? What are you even going to do with all of them?

Possessed said:

Bobson Dugnutt said:

I feel like you’re all just making up these updates at this point, or I’m going crazy

You really can’t see them?

OP hasn’t posted to this thread in some time, where exactly am I suppost to be looking?

I feel like you’re all just making up these updates at this point, or I’m going crazy

It was filmed with the Red Weapon 8K, so it should be in real 4k. Maybe the VFX aren’t, but the real stuff is

http://www.red.com/news/gotg-vol-2-to-shoot-on-8k-weapon

Dek Rollins said:
I’m currently working on a V2 of my regrade, which will now completely remove the blanket despecialized statement that is heavily present on the Blu-ray of the thread.

I wasn’t impressed by the newest Blu-Ray master of this thread. I always prefered the DVD master, but its becoming less and less watchable in quality over the years. I’m looking forward to your v2 regrade as your v1 has become my go-to version of this thread.

My regrade screenshots are have a bit of a lower bitrate, which doesn’t represent the final product

http://www.framecompare.com/image-compare/screenshotcomparison/12CNNN8U

Look, I’m planning to contract a terminal disease so that I can get a Make-A-Wish so I can wish for the OUT to be released on Blu-Ray. It’s a foolproof plan guys.

I hope you don’t mind, but I used your regrade as a base for my own. I adjusted the contrast, saturation and added a bit of yellow back into it to make the colours pop a bit more

Here’s the start of the airport fight as a preview
https://vimeo.com/260197607

I’d like to know your thoughts

The 70mm IMAX cut is probably the best offical cut of the film, but the 35mm is probably the next best thing. It has one less cringy line and smaller better thing

I noticed that too last night, in fact every link doesn’t work anymore. I think they cleaned out their database again

I beleive its mostly disliked, but IMO, it looks great, but needs some work on some scenes. There is a green tint that is noticable in the earlier scenes, but is still somewhat prevalent later on. There is a lot more detail here over the 2009 BR. The 09 BR is softer looking and pink in areas, while this one is sharp and teal. The new print is definitely my go-to until someone regrades it.

Here is a good comaprison between the old release and this new one.

http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/123880
http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/123881

DominicCobb said:

Bobson Dugnutt said:

The part when he’s talking about killing the sandpeople and Padme said “To be angry is to be human” and most of that scene was a DVD addition IIRC

Which parts of that scene were DVD additions?

The “To be angry is to be human” and the “I’m a Jedi, I should be better”.

Here’s a full list of stuff added, changed or cut on DVD and Blu-Ray

• When Obi-Wan and Anakin speed through the power couplings, the shots have been swapped around on the BR
• When Obi-Wan grabs Anakin’s lightsaber out of the air during the speeder chase, there were some more speeders in the shot in the theatrical
• Shmi’s voice during Anakin’s nightmare was added on the BR
• Padme saying “To be angry is to be human” and Anakin’s “I’m a Jedi, I should be better” after he kills the Tuskan Raiders was added on the DVD
• More sparks have been added to Jango’s jetpack after the Reek stomps on him on the DVD
• When Padme falls out of the gunship into the dunes, a clone trooper asks her if she is alright, in the Theatrical she says “Yes”, while in subsequent releases she says “Uh huh”
• Dooku’s escape has some rearranged shots on the BR
• During the wedding, Anakin’s hand wasn’t CGI and barely moved in the theatical before being changed to CGI for the DVD

There were some colour changes too from the DVD to the BR, mainly a blanket green tint. Just from looking at the Centropy copy, its clear that the DVD is more accurate to the theatrical colour timing

If you want the IMAX cut, I think it’s been remade and put up somewhere, probably on the Spleen or something. But I’d be interested in a scan of the 35mm. It’d lay a lot of rumours to rest, mainly the extra speeders and the Jango Fett jetpack thing. I’d also be interesting in seeing the practical mechanical hand in better quality. I’d definitly donate to it

The Phantom Menace scan got funded, I’m sure they’d be enough intrest in one of Episode II. But I think poita has enough on his plate currently with him doing the 97SE Trilogy and Episode I.

Yep, it was also in the DVD and Blu-Ray, never got removed

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tYjnH8UfYOQ